Harry Whitwell
#1
Another woeful decision has been taken already before the Chalton match tomorrow. Whitwell and also Mustapha have been picked for the 23's tonight, so ruling them out of the squad tomorrow. 
     Whitwell is the most creative player in the squad,I'm not interested that he's not strong enough or experienced enough or even may make a mistake, the same was said about Fellows. 
   Whitwell came back to play games and that was the message Robbie Savage gave everyone. The poor lad was given the Norwich game and played in a deep position first half and struggled. Second half he was pushed further forward and we started to see what he can do.He took the ball on the half turn and surged forward ,he was comfortable on the ball and yes he may of wanted too much time on the ball and got caught but that can happen. 
    As for Mustapha I take it he still isn't fit enough. What a laughing stock we are.
Reply
#2
"The most creative player in the squad"

I've read some hyperbole on here but that might take the crazy biscuit.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#3
What was the point I recalling Whitwell or bringing in Mustapha?
Reply
#4
(02-23-2026, 07:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: "The most creative player in the squad"

I've read some hyperbole on here but that might take the crazy biscuit.

Obviously a completely over the top statement but you do wonder why on earth he was brought back and why we’re not using a player who is in form.
Reply
#5
(02-23-2026, 07:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What was the point I recalling Whitwell or bringing in Mustapha?

None at all.

Were just a really shit, fuck awful club for youth. Anyone advising a young player would tell them to use our academy and jump at the first offer from elsewhere at the end at most.
Reply
#6
We had no pace or power and money.

We got a big, fast, powerful CM on loan for pennies in the hope he might be good enough. He probably isn't. Neither incidentally is Whitwell yet.

No conspiracy.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
(02-23-2026, 07:42 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We had no pace or power and money.

We got a big, fast, powerful CM on loan for pennies in the hope he might be good enough. He probably isn't. Neither incidentally is Whitwell yet.

No conspiracy.

If only there was some way of knowing this before signing, or cancelling a successful loan. Some way of watching players before they play for us. We could call it something like, I don't know. Scouting....

Sorry Lurker, your way off with this one, both were stupid mistakes by a club addicted to stupid decisions.
Reply
#8
(02-23-2026, 07:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: "The most creative player in the squad"

I've read some hyperbole on here but that might take the crazy biscuit.

I stand by that statement after watching him in the23’s and certainly judging by what he did at Forest Green.To temper that ,we have no creative players as such Molumby,Mowatt etc.I might give you Johnson and that’s about it.
Reply
#9
We can't be seen to be picking players that may have some form of attacking threat in them. Doesn't fit with the sideways and backwards patterns of play that has been so successfully deployed under Ramsay. Only a few more games required to work on the dynamic attacking threat that will actually see us finish a match with XG above 1.0.
Reply
#10
Whitwell was player of the season at Forest Green. Listen to what Savage said about him. Said he will be a top top player. Now as much as I think Savage is a prick he was a premier league and International footballer. He is also the manager that has seen the most of Whitwell in professional men's football.

Whitwell is far from the finished article but he is a very, very good prospect who has good touch and vision. He is also an intelligent footballer who plays with his head up and clan pick a pass.

The reason he was recalled, IMO, was because we'd just sacked Mason and Morrison was put in charge. Morrison knows him extremely well from his U21 work and wanted to see what he looked like in the Swansea cup match.

I think he definitely warrants a place in our match day squad at the very least as we are severely lacking creativity. He 100% should be ahead of Mustapha who will go back in a month or two.

And if he's not being considered at all we should have let him go back to Forest Green before the window closed or found him another loan because otherwise, as far as I see it, it's just another terrible football decision which is stunting the progress of a player we might very well need next season in LEAGUE FUCKING 1!!!!!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: