Ratings!
#1
May as well get this up before I hit the bar!

Not the prettiest of games, but the type of result sides that get the top 2 places pick up. We definitely need to tweak this system at home as we have lost our attacking instincts and were reliant on some woeful Stoke defending for a goal that I couldn't see coming any other way.  Still, a massive 3 points ahead of some tough, but winnable fixtures following a weekend that saw a lot of results go our way. Just need an Ipswich to pull off a shock tomorrow and it's been a brilliant weekend all round... Brighton losing the icing on the cake!

Johnstone - 7 - Improving. One dodgy kick, but felt he looked more commanding today. Claimed a few, distributed well... Needs to be a little more decisive coming off his line, but a better display. 

Holgate - 7 - His pace and technique masks a lack of intelligence. Makes too many bad decisions, but is infinitely better than Mears and Tosin. 
Hegazi - 9 - MOTM - Thought he was absolutely brilliant first half, and composed in the second. Cracking assist for the goal.
Dawson - 8 - Same as Hegazi - could see he loved his battle with Vokes and won everything. 
Gibbs - 7 - Quiet today. Murphy didn't give him much protection so wasn't as strong going forward but kept it neat and tidy.

Barry - 9 - Ran Hegazi close for MOTM, and could have been either really. Composed, assured and very tidy. I think it was a penalty mind.
Livermore - 6 - Grew into the game after a poor first half was much improved second. Needs to shed a stone, but can see he has quality for this league. 
Johansen - 8 - Looks a quality addition. Always has time on the ball, neat delivery with either foot and intelligent with his passing. Did a lot of running and whilst he was a little subdued against a Stoke side that had packed the centre, he'll be a very important player for us against sides that are more open.

Gayle - 7 - Wasted in this position, but still takes any chance he gets. We need to get him on the ball more... it's criminal how deep most of his touches were today.
Rodriguez - 6.5 - Worked hard but didn't come off for him today. Snatched at a couple of chances, but seems to overthink his finishes. 
Murphy - 6 - Looked rusty. Definitely fast, but he's got some way to go before he's fit to lace Barnes' boots.

Montero - looked lively but again not the brightest!
Harper - Added energy, but not much time. 

Moore - 9 - impressed with him today. Seemed to get the better of the tactical game with Jones, and whilst I've dropped a mark for him maybe making his subs a little late, he made the right call and saw us over the line. Roll on Tuesday.
Reply
#2
Wouldn't disagree with that. Perhaps a tad high for Johansen, 7 for me and Gayle and Rodriguez 6.5 and 6. Perhaps and extra half mark for Holgate and Gibbs.
Reply
#3
Blimey that was quick mon! Pretty much spot on as usual, have a bronx hat.
Reply
#4
Not bad. You've rated Johnstone too highly. Barry would probably get my man of the match award, but can't argue with Hegazi.
Reply
#5
Think those marks are about right, no arguments from me. Clean sheet so can't fault Johnstone's marks,
Reply
#6
Johnstone way over rated their sw4. 5 at best.

Johansen took an elbow in the mush very early first and dealt with that like a proper pro and just got on with it.
Reply
#7
I don't know why people have such a downer on Johnstone thought he did as well as he needed to do.
Reply
#8
(02-09-2019, 07:50 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Blimey that was quick mon! Pretty much spot on as usual, have a bronx hat.

Fast fingers and a desire for a beer!
Reply
#9
(02-09-2019, 07:54 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Johnstone way over rated their sw4. 5 at best.

Johansen took an elbow in the mush very early first and dealt with that like a proper pro and just got on with it.

Yeah, that ex Villa player only kept a clean sheet - boo!
Would agree with pretty well all of the ratings, SW4, but,if anything you've been kind to Murphy, who was bloody awful.
Thought Hegazi was indeed the man of the match, just edging out Barry.
Reply
#10
Defensively excellent and Hegazi seemed about as composed as I’ve ever seen him. Think Livermore was fairly solid but slowed our play down. Being overly critical maybe but Gibbs rarely had an option inside when the ball was spread wide left and led to fewer openings. Otherwise pretty strong performance overall and rarely looked threatened.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: