Going well…
#1
I see the Mandelson story some wanted to brush aside isn’t going anywhere. Likewise Tommy Robinson and Musk continue to be emboldened and the Labour Party MPs start to openly question Starmers leadership. At some point centrist dads will understand that first and foremost a leader needs to be good a politics first, management second. You might want it the other way around but it’s never going to happen.

I expect patronising guff in response, but everything I’ve said about the direction Labour has taken is now become common place criticism of them across the political spectrum. Hey-ho I’m just a bloke on a football messageboard.
Reply
#2
(09-15-2025, 08:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the Mandelson story some wanted to brush aside isn’t going anywhere. Likewise Tommy Robinson and Musk continue to be emboldened and the Labour Party MPs start to openly question Starmers leadership. At some point centrist dads will understand that first and foremost a leader needs to be good a politics first, management second. You might want it the other way around but it’s never going to happen.

I expect patronising guff in response, but everything I’ve said about the direction Labour has taken is now become common place criticism of them across the political spectrum. Hey-ho I’m just a bloke on a football messageboard.

No you're a bloke talking politics on a football message board, in the politics section.
Reply
#3
WHAT ARE YOUR SOLUTIONS PINKO?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#4
After spending the last few months saying the flag shaggers and asylum protesters need to be heard because they have their grievances you are now blaming Starmer for emboldening fascists like Robinson and Musk. You have spent the summer being an apologist for these people, who's intentions were always to stoke division and racism, even when the reality of numbers of immigrants have been explained to you but you carried on because you wanted to further knock the government. And it's not just Tommy and Elon that have been emboldened, if the reported story is true, it is also the scum that have raped that girl in Brandhall.

There's your patronising guff
Signed
Centrist Dad
Reply
#5
(09-15-2025, 11:05 AM)baggy1 Wrote: After spending the last few months saying the flag shaggers and asylum protesters need to be heard because they have their grievances you are now blaming Starmer for emboldening fascists like Robinson and Musk. You have spent the summer being an apologist for these people, who's intentions were always to stoke division and racism, even when the reality of numbers of immigrants have been explained to you but you carried on because you wanted to further knock the government. And it's not just Tommy and Elon that have been emboldened, if the reported story is true, it is also the scum that have raped that girl in Brandhall.

There's your patronising guff
Signed
Centrist Dad

Bullshit B1, I didn’t make any apologies for anyone, I said if Labour don’t address the problem it would lead to Reform getting elected as the next government. Where have I said anything in support of ‘FS or Reform? I’m not the one using divisive language about an ‘island of strangers’, or trying to woo right wing voters who have long since given up on voting Labour even if they had any intention. Find one post where I have supported Reform, FS, or Robinson, you won’t find any, so don’t make stuff up. You are confusing understanding what will/is happening if Labour ignore the reasons why, with support of it, be that through ignorance or deliberately I suspect the latter sadly.t
Reply
#6
So you want them to address the problems of the flag shaggers whilst not going down the road they want. How are they supposed to silence the racists when all the media want to run and highlight is such a non-problem. They've signed a new deal on Nuclear Energy today that will create thousands of jobs but that isn't good enough because the focus is Mandelson, when a few months ago he was getting praise for protecting the country when it came to Tariffs.

Everyone understand the reasons why its happening - they're racists, but you want the government to understand the reasons why they are racists. Not saying every flag shagger is racist, however the core movement was started with that in mind. You have posted many times about asylum seekers being landed on poorer areas which will drive the locals to reject it.
Reply
#7
(09-15-2025, 11:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So you want them to address the problems of the flag shaggers whilst not going down the road they want. How are they supposed to silence the racists when all the media want to run and highlight is such a non-problem. They've signed a new deal on Nuclear Energy today that will create thousands of jobs but that isn't good enough because the focus is Mandelson, when a few months ago he was getting praise for protecting the country when it came to Tariffs.

Everyone understand the reasons why its happening - they're racists, but you want the government to understand the reasons why they are racists. Not saying every flag shagger is racist, however the core movement was started with that in mind. You have posted many times about asylum seekers being landed on poorer areas which will drive the locals to reject it.

You are proving my point for me, Labour have offered absolutely nothing in terms of setting out an alternative positive plan/view of the future direction of the country. What is Starmer’s vision for the country? What does he stand for? Why divide people into working and non working people? Why take the whip away from left of centre MPs simply for disagreeing with him? Why use divisive language such as ‘an island of strangers’? 

You scratch your head at why people aren’t happy with Labour, you blame the press, disgruntled left of centre former Labour voters, you throw the term racist around at people because you have decided their concerns aren’t to be listened to or valid. It’s condescending and the more you declare anyone who doesn’t agree with this incredibly narrow centrist political point of view, that it has to be said comes from a comfortable place in society the more Labour will tank in the polls and at the ballot box. 

Politics is not just about management, it never has been it’s about decision making, it’s about offering a clear vision for people to believe in and Labour offer none of this. Their narrative is everything is broke, it’s difficult, we aren’t listening but we know what’s best. You might think that’s unfair, tough, that’s politics it’s not just management.

Oh and to be absolutely clear I will never vote for Reform or Tory but Starmer’s Labour will never get my vote.
Reply
#8
Derek - B1 seems to be saying exactly the same things about the flag wavers that you used to say about Brexiteers. Which is fair as they are largely the same people.

However, because this Labour govt tried to reduce welfare spending in a manner you disagreed with, you now have nothing good to say about the Labour party and seek to stick the boot in at every opportunity. So despite having spent the last 10+ years saying that Brexiteers were idiots who have ruined the country (which again, fair), you have now had a massive volte face claiming that they are in fact, the down-trodden disaffected who the government must prioritise.

However, that isn't the real issue.

The real issue is that for someone who so prioritises welfare spending, particularly disability benefits, you don't seem to realise that you can cheer on the demise of this Labour government all you want, whoever gets subsequently elected will be even further to the right. And they won't just cut disability spending, they'll decimate it.
Reply
#9
(09-15-2025, 08:17 PM)Squid Wrote: Derek - B1 seems to be saying exactly the same things about the flag wavers that you used to say about Brexiteers. Which is fair as they are largely the same people.

However, because this Labour govt tried to reduce welfare spending in a manner you disagreed with, you now have nothing good to say about the Labour party and seek to stick the boot in at every opportunity. So despite having spent the last 10+ years saying that Brexiteers were idiots who have ruined the country (which again, fair), you have now had a massive volte face claiming that they are in fact, the down-trodden disaffected who the government must prioritise.

However, that isn't the real issue.

The real issue is that for someone who so prioritises welfare spending, particularly disability benefits, you don't seem to realise that you can cheer on the demise of this Labour government all you want, whoever gets subsequently elected will be even further to the right. And they won't just cut disability spending, they'll decimate it.

Brexit was an act of complete self destruction brought about by snake oils salesmen, selfish Libertarians and those looking for simple solutions to complicated problems, 

I am fully aware that Labour are least worse out of the Tories and shudder Reform when it comes to the  rights and support of those with disability. I don’t cheer on Labours demise, it annoys me and for some terrifies thousands if not more that they’ve become a Tory-lite party in the mould of Sunak and are rolling out the red carpet to Reform by offering nothing but continuity of failed policies that are indistinguishable from the Tories. People did not vote for more of the same and the majority of the disabled community feel hugely let down by Starmer, you seem to be arguing they should accept being scapegoated and at the brunt of cuts simply because Labour are ‘least worse’. 

I am against creating needless tensions within communities by placing HMOs on estates where those houses should and were previously family homes, but have become money making exercises for Serco and without any responsibility once people are placed there. It’s not a solution it’s a fudge and a very lucrative one for a company I have little respect for. I have zero support for sticking flags on lamposts, racists or agitators I’d like to add, before some try and insinuate that I have. You can be against poorly thought out solutions that only benefit multimillion pound companies with dubious track records in public service and not be some pitch fork wielding, Tommeh fan! 

Given austerity has offered absolutely no solutions to societal problems, i am mindful that if a government offers more of the same without any tangible positive change, you are going to have disaffected people who will look for simple solutions to complicated problems. You don’t have to support their views but a government needs to understand and try and address the reasons for them. I mean it can just ignore the problems but they don’t go away, they just turn to another party for answers, which is exactly why Reform are currently so popular.

Starmer is offering no vision for the future that gives people hope and I don’t see him set out any real plan, or have any political convictions, he and his advisers have handed over the narrative and initiative to Farage and Reform. He or another has four years to roll the carpet back up and give people the change Labour said they were delivering. Not more messages that it’s really hard, more cuts, crap about working and non working people, islands of strangers etc.
Reply
#10
Derek.

Where do you suggest we house asylum seekers instead?

The locals have complained about:

Hotels

Hostels

HMOs

Condemned tower blocks

Former army barracks

An actual ship!

So, considering that we 1)Have a duty to accept refugees and 2)Therefore need to put them somewhere,

Where exactly should they go?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: