Penalty incidents
#1
Trip on Molumby  - blatant 
One given on Swift  - very soft
ONien holding Ajayi - soft
ONien dragging back Ajayi- should have been a pen
Roberts push on Townsend - soft but seen them given many times.
Reply
#2
What about the borderline assault of BTA which sent him flying into the advertising boards?

Absolute nailed on peno.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#3
Absolutely.  They weren't 'tough' decisions to make. No one would have marked the ref down or worse. Likewise the soft bookings for our midfield. Every foul isn't a booking ffs. And Swifts booking???? Ridiculous.
Reply
#4
The officials were shit. Again
Reply
#5
(04-23-2023, 09:00 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Trip on Molumby  - blatant 
One given on Swift  - very soft
ONien holding Ajayi - soft
ONien dragging back Ajayi- should have been a pen
Roberts push on Townsend - soft but seen them given many times.

Strange how different people see the same incident.

The only one I felt was clear cut was the holding of Ajayi . Also thought the penalty given was one I would have given. The dragging back of Ajayi was one that would have been given at prem level 2 years ago, but now not and I think rightly so. Not so much a drag back as a hand on the back. The trip on Mulumby no, push on Townsend probably not enough.

And as for BTA going into the advertising hoardings, I would have been furious if that would have been given against us.
Reply
#6
I didn't particularly think any of them were penalties. The worst thing the ref did was allow their players to get away with fouls that ours got booked for. Whilst both Molumby and Yokuslu deserved their yellows it killed our midfield from about 25 minutes into the game. He allowed a lot of theirs to go unchecked until the second half by which time we'd spent an hour chasing the ball.

The referee wasn't 'great' - when is a referee ever good? But he was far from the reason that we lost yesterday.
Reply
#7
Molumby one was nailed on IMO, as was the one given. Others would have been soft, but justified.
Reply
#8
(04-24-2023, 08:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Molumby one was nailed on IMO, as was the one given. Others would have been soft, but justified.

Agree. I think the only 2 people who didn't think the trip on Molumby wasnt a pen was Dingle Don and the ref. Swift was soft but can see why it was given.
Reply
#9
I have no recollection of the Molumby one at all.

When was it first half or second?
Reply
#10
(04-24-2023, 08:41 AM)Atomic Wrote: I have no recollection of the Molumby one at all.

When was it first half or second?

1st half
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: