S4A update
#1
Hi all. Got this off a member of the S4A group. 

FYI if interested.  I’ve also attached WBA’s letter to S4A. 


Quote:Dear Member
 
Please see the attached letter from Ken dated 13 March 2023 together with the text from my reply to him a short while ago, shown below.
 
Best wishes
 
Leigh 
 
Leigh Kent
Vice-Chair, Shareholders for Albion
 
 
 
Email text:
 
Hi Ken
 
I hope you are well.
 
I had wished to respond before now. Unfortunately, work commitments for David Baker and I plus some unforeseen personal circumstances for me have meant this has not been possible, on this occasion. I know you appreciate that we act in our roles as unpaid volunteers and we have been very busy each week working on behalf of Albion shareholders and supporters since we took over the leadership of Shareholders for Albion two and half years ago. 
 
I propose to refrain from responding to and rebutting elements of your letter in full detail in this email, as that is more for legal correspondence and is not fair on you as an individual, given that the contents of this email are circulated more widely.
 
I note that you have not answered any of the questions raised and have instead chosen to answer your own questions. This is a basic and transparent deflection technique used by commercial and litigation solicitors, which I am calling out. I am afraid that your letter dated 13 March 2023 provides little in substance and is short of meaningful detail and reassurance. I do not agree that the minority shareholders are not entitled to be provided with the information requested.
 
You have chosen not to engage with minority shareholders either via an annual general meeting and/or by responding to pertinent correspondence submitted by them. You have, instead, prescribed that questions can only be raised by David and I on behalf of S4A and Action for Albion. I have done this and acknowledge your appreciation of that. Having done this, you/your legal representatives cannot then seek to hide behind your various points around legal privilege and confidentiality. If I am raising the questions/making points on behalf of members, they need to be able to see such questions/points along with the responses. I am completely transparent and accountable in my actions. 
 
We have a very large membership. I clearly cannot control what a member does or does not do with an email. That would be the same if you emailed one of our members. A copy of your letter will be sent to our members with the text of this email. In doing so, your message is being passed on and I can do no more. All of our members are adults who are responsible for their own actions. I trust that you are not suggesting that neither myself nor another member of our Committee have leaked information, but please confirm. You will appreciate that I need to clarify this in this email given the contents of your letter. Contents on this issue which are open to interpretation by a reader.
 
Outside of my role within S4A, I would, as an Albion supporter, question why you are averse to supporters and stakeholders being kept up to date on such matters, in any event. You have chosen to use the football club's money for matters which have absolutely nothing to do with the operation of football club and are accountable for that.
 
Para 1.2 states that you have Mr Lai's 'assurance' that the loan will be repaid. Para 1.3 states that it is Mr Lai's 'expectation' that it will be repaid. They are very different things. Which is it please? Please clarify. Indeed, given recent events, neither will provide any meaningful reassurance to most, if not all, of our members and the support at large.
 
It has been stated that Mr Lai has links to Wisdom Smart, but the official evidence we have seen to date does not show this to be the case. Please clarify.
 
You confirm that you are taking steps that you consider appropriate. Please can you confirm what they are. If there is genuine legal sensitivity, please confirm by way of separate email to S4A's solicitor, David and I. If this refers to the reported planned trip to China (further to a recent meeting between Action for Albion and Ron Gourlay), that is not recognised by us as an appropriate step. Mr Lai is contactable via other means (and indeed chairs Board meetings remotely). This relates to the collection of an overdue debt/enforcement of the same, not a matter which requires any discussion around it. 
 
We are pleased to hear that the accounts for 2021-22 will be released prior to the end of March 2023. That is in happy conflict to the situation we found ourselves in with the previous year's accounts, which were signed off before the end of March 2022 but not then released for several months (and until after season tickets had been sold), with no apparent justification.
 
Your unwillingness to reinstate the annual general meeting is perplexing. It is the priority of everyone at and connected with the club to achieve success. That is a given. That does not prevent holding an annual general meeting. You are a professional who is a director of a large company, which has a high turnover and a large public profile.  An annual general meeting is simply a routine part of sound governance and accountability for well-run companies and part of the basic duties of a company director, for which you are paid a salary. In the absence of an annual general meeting, we will need to proceed solely by way of open correspondence between us and updates to our members on the back of that; leaving potential for leaks which neither I nor anyone at S4A can prevent. 
 
You also state that you: 'feel that we have good lines of communication concerning the affairs of Club and Group.' Leaving aside that an annual general meeting is required in any event, I would have agreed with that at one time. I cannot endorse that statement now I am afraid. As previously stated (in one of the unanswered questions on the accounts for 2020-21), you had confirmed in an agreed statement to our members that money had not left the club when it clearly had (by way of the loan in question). There was also inadequate and late/after the event communication during the regrettable sequence of events around the notices in December 2022 relating to the MSD loan. I do, however, consider that we have excellent lines of communication with Ron Gourlay on matters he is responsible for and to the extent that he is responsible for such matters alone.
 
Kind regards
 
Leigh
 
Leigh Kent
Vice-Chair, Shareholders for Albion
Reply
#2
Thanks Ronnie, but I can’t see Ken’s letter?
Reply
#3
(03-28-2023, 07:09 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Thanks Ronnie, but I can’t see Ken’s letter?

Exactly. Neither could S4A, well not a meaningful and useful one by the sounds of it.  Big Grin
Reply
#4
So Ken has refused to answer all questions! Helpful.

(03-28-2023, 07:21 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-28-2023, 07:09 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Thanks Ronnie, but I can’t see Ken’s letter?

Exactly. Neither could S4A, well not a meaningful and useful one by the sounds of it.  Big Grin

Email him asking what he's had for tea, and who's paid for it, and when they will get that money back.
Reply
#5
Says file is too large and

Dear Leigh
Questions relating to Loans
Thank you for your email of 6 March 2023. I do appreciate you being the sole point of contact for these questions from the members of S4A.
Whilst minority shareholders are not necessarily entitled to be provided with the information that has been requested, I am happy to share information where I reasonably can and where appropriate. In your position as a solicitor, you will also understand that there are issues of confidentiality and legal privilege that I need to be mindful of.
With that in mind, as you will have expected, I will not address each point you make or answer every question you have set out. Instead, I respond more generally as follows:
1.1
I set out the details of the WSL Loan in my letter in September. That letter reported Mr Lai's stated intention that the WSL Loan will be repaid and that it will be repaid without a dividend being declared. I can also confirm that there is a loan agreement in place.
1.2
The WSL Loan is not yet repaid. Since the tum of the year I have been in regular contact with Mr Lai concerning its repayment. I have his assurance that it will be repaid
- that position has not changed - and I am taking the steps I consider appropriate to protect the position of Group in relation to its repayment.
1.3
I am aware that I have fiduciary duties and what they are, I abide by them at all times, and I take appropriate advice in relation to the affairs of Group. As per the above, it is my expectation and Mr Lai's that the WSL Loan will be repaid and such monies repaid to Group will be made available to Club.
on's Way, 430 Birmingham Road, Walsall, West Midiands, WS5 3LO @ 0871 271 1100 @ enquiries@wbafc.co.uk @wba.co.uk

1.4
In relation to the Warmfront Loan, the audited accounts of West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited are to be published shortly and I am aware that it will address the current situation with that loan, though I should remind you that I am not a director of West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited.
1.5
You ask about whether there is a plan to reinstate an AGM for Group at the Hawthorns.
I am aware that the practice for a great many years has been not to hold an AGM. I don't have an intention to change that practice at this stage. My priority is the success of the club and I feel that we have good lines of communication concerning the affairs of Club and Group.
As per my letter in September, this letter is marked "private and confidential" because the communications between the Club and Group and S4A should remain confidential. Club and Group agree that this letter may be shared with those fellow members of S4A who have a legitimate interest in its content, where such recipients also recognise and respect that these communications are intended to be and are kept confidential. I am aware that previous communications have been shared with non-shareholders and the media. You will appreciate that this was despite me being clear as to the terms upon which the information was shared.
Please could I ask that you do your utmost to ensure there is no repetition following receipt of this letter.
I hope the above is helpful to you and appreciate it will be shared with your fellow members
Reply
#6
Kieran Maguire
@KieranMaguire
West Bromwich Albion accounts show the loan due from owner Lai is not expected to be received and so write it down to zero. ☹️ #WBAFC

[Image: FseC-EpWwAAmuft?format=jpg&name=large]
Reply
#7
(03-30-2023, 01:12 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Kieran Maguire
@KieranMaguire
West Bromwich Albion accounts show the loan due from owner Lai is not expected to be received and so write it down to zero. ☹️ #WBAFC


[Image: FseC-EpWwAAmuft?format=jpg&name=large]

No shock there.
Reply
#8
Can ff shag him to death ?
Reply
#9
(03-30-2023, 01:17 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Can ff shag him to death ?

Lai was one of the models, it's why he's keen on getting revenge on us!
Reply
#10
Yep, note in the accounts says loan impaired to nil.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: