VAR again
#1
Or is it Anthony Taylor this time.

The Man City disallowed goal yesterday, I think it was a foul by Harland, and it wasn't too far back in the play.

So all good? Not really. There was a huge number of fouls Taylor let go yesterday, it seems to be his thing. But there is absolutely no point In him reffing this way, if when a goal is scored he then disallows it for a foul, he was happy to ignore throughout the game.
Reply
#2
That was my take on the VAR you cannot change your mind when seeing it in slow motion, He didn’t give it so shouldn’t change his mind.
Reply
#3
VAR was sold on two key words… “clear and obvious”.

Drawing lines on the pitch and measuring to the millimetres is not clear and obvious.

Watching the same replay half a dozen times is not clear and obvious. Especially when incidents always look worse when slowed down and replayed over and over again.
Reply
#4
(10-17-2022, 10:12 AM)Duffers Wrote: VAR was sold on two key words… “clear and obvious”.

Drawing lines on the pitch and measuring to the millimetres is not clear and obvious.

Watching the same replay half a dozen times is not clear and obvious. Especially when incidents always look worse when slowed down and replayed over and over again.

+1

Whilst there are numerous decisions over the course of a season which are just plain wrong, they do not occur to most teams on a weekly basis. There are maybe 3 or 4 goal/pen decisions we’ve faced this season that VAR would have reversed but other than this, it should not be used.

VAR is looking for too many opportunities to justify itself when actually the aim should be to avoid using it. As ever, the technology works great, the people operating it however do not.
Reply
#5
(10-17-2022, 10:12 AM)Duffers Wrote: VAR was sold on two key words… “clear and obvious”.

Drawing lines on the pitch and measuring to the millimetres is not clear and obvious.

Watching the same replay half a dozen times is not clear and obvious. Especially when incidents always look worse when slowed down and replayed over and over again.

Absolutely. Spot. On
Reply
#6
(10-17-2022, 10:12 AM)Duffers Wrote: VAR was sold on two key words… “clear and obvious”.

This. Just as I said in the pub to the crowing Scousers yesterday.
Reply
#7
It was a foul that should have been given - I'm not sure if there a timeframe as to how far you go back in a passage of play though. I'd say if Haalnd fouled the keeper then that should be enough to disallow but not the yank on a shirt a few seconds before.
Reply
#8
(10-17-2022, 11:04 AM)Fido Wrote: It was a foul that should have been given - I'm not sure if there a timeframe as to how far you go back in a passage of play though. I'd say if Haalnd fouled the keeper then that should be enough to disallow but not the yank on a shirt a few seconds before.

Interesting how the VAR laws have changed. Anyone remember our player (can't remember who it was now) who was so obviously fouled in the build up to a Utd goal a few years back which cost us. 

It was way more obvious than the Haaland foul yet VAR never looked at it as it was in the build up so didn't matter.
Reply
#9
Just watched match of the day and why wasn’t Phil Mepham sent off it was a diabolical tackle, initial booking but VAR should have upgraded it the ball had gone V5 minutes before Mepham arrived, Maitland Niles had every right to be aggrieved.
Reply
#10
(10-20-2022, 10:13 AM)wba13 Wrote: Just watched match of the day and why wasn’t Phil Mepham sent off it was a diabolical tackle, initial booking but VAR should have upgraded it the ball had gone V5 minutes before Mepham arrived, Maitland Niles had every right to be aggrieved.

Cos he's a Central News presenter?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: