Steve Bruce - an apology
#1
In other threads I have criticised Bruce as being unimaginative. I now have to accept that I was wrong.

Anyone who thinks Adam Reach is a right wing back must have one hell of an imagination.
Reply
#2
Perfect opportunity to play Ingram. Round peg in round hole etc. The kid is obviously desperately needed for the reserves game on Monday  Rolleyes
Reply
#3
This is a poor effort at blaming Reach for something that is completely beyond his control. Ingram has been nowhere near the side this season so why should he come in now? Reach was very lively at least until he moved into the middle, while TGH was pretty poor throughout. I would have removed Townsend who offered nothing at all for the 92 minutes he was on the pitch and moved TGH to RWB, but there you go.

The problem wasn't Reach. It's ridiculous to expect young players like TGH and Molumby (less than 125 career games between them) to transform a pedestrian midfield which has been modelled around the lumbering Livermore for several seasons and several managers. Meanwhile, it's difficult to comprehend why senior players can't do the basics properly, particularly getting shots on target or passes to teammates. Adam Reach isn't the worst offender by far, and he can't be responsible for every player's failings.

But we need a spacegoat. Reach has become the poster boy for all of the woes this season has visited upon us.
Reply
#4
Agree with Cheshire. Reach had a good first half yesterday.
If you read this board there's about a dozen players we should get rid of.
1 it's not going to happen.
2 it's unlikely to say the least that we'd replace with better.
Our best bet IMO is to support the incumbent because he's had a chance to assess the squad.
And if that penalty had gone in yesterday this place would be a lot quieter!
Reply
#5
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:This is a poor effort at blaming Reach for something that is completely beyond his control. Ingram has been nowhere near the side this season so why should he come in now? Reach was very lively at least until he moved into the middle, while TGH was pretty poor throughout. I would have removed Townsend who offered nothing at all for the 92 minutes he was on the pitch and moved TGH to RWB, but there you go.

The problem wasn't Reach. It's ridiculous to expect young players like TGH and Molumby (less than 125 career games between them) to transform a pedestrian midfield which has been modelled around the lumbering Livermore for several seasons and several managers. Meanwhile, it's difficult to comprehend why senior players can't do the basics properly, particularly getting shots on target or passes to teammates. Adam Reach isn't the worst offender by far, and he can't be responsible for every player's failings.

But we need a spacegoat. Reach has become the poster boy for all of the woes this season has visited upon us.
Agree with most but for two statements. TGH was not poor throughout, he offered energy and movement and we lost our way once Reach was put in midfield. I do agree Reach is not the problem and is a more than useful wing back at this level, certainly better than Townsend who has declined massively. Further, Livermore is our best defensive midfielder by a country mile and shouldn't be the target of so much criticism.  The two players most singled out by this bored, Livermore and Reach, are probably our most wholehearted players.
If for no other reasons than progression of their careers, the likes of Ingram, Taylor, Tulloch (and I'm sure a good few others), should be selected instead of the constantly underperforming Furlong, Ajayi, Bartley, Robinson and Townsend.
Reply
#6
Give our paucity of options and money, it may be worth a punt on Kane Wilson again. As has been said, he’s been in electric form for Forest Green (3 goals, 14 assists) and at 22 has time on his side but with Bruce at the helm I imagine we’ll be taking this opportunity to bring in Martin Kelly’s top level experience and hunger to put the last 2 years injury problems behind hlm.
Reply
#7
You completely misunderstood. I am not blaming Reach, he did as well as expected given that he was playing completely out of position though his inability to kick a ball with his right foot made him very easy to defend against. I’m blaming Bruce for picking him over Ingram, O’Shea, TGH, Phillips or anyone with a right foot in that position.
Reply
#8
I would have thought it was obvious why Ingram could or should have played.

He is right wing back in the reserves and has played that position all season, bar a few outings at right centre back.
He has played well in that position all season.
He has the speed and stamina to get up and down the pitch all day.
He is the best suited right wing back at the club, bar Furlong who was obviously unavailable on the day.
There was nothing riding on the game, so why not get some of our kids on the pitch. We employ them in the hope that they will make our first team, so why not give them that opportunity when it presents itself?
It was one game.
If Ingram is to progress with us then he has to play in the first team at some point.

This isn't about Reach per se. It is about shoehorning a player into an area of the pitch that they don't ordinarily play when there really is no need to.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)