Last night's ratings....
#1
Can't see any ratings from the regulars so will throw some out there.

Button - 6 - Calm, composed and good with the ball at his feet. Doesnt look much of a shot stopper and get down slow. SJ miles ahead.

Peltier - 6 - Didn't notice him, which is fine for what he is. Solid enough. 
Kipre - 8 - Thought he was great, love his aggression and dominance both aerially and physically. Could develop into a top CB given enough game time. 
Ivanovic - 7 - Has just got it in his head. His positioning and timing of his tackles were a sign of his quality. Looked understandably rusty in possession at times. Will be a great partner for Big K and Ajayi. 
Townsend - 6 - See Peltier. He is turning into Mr 6/10. 

Harper - 6 - 7 first half, 5 second. Showed more consistency first half but lost his way. Defo needs a loan. 
Field - 8 - Some humble pie for me to eat here. His performance was mature and effective and he showed what a capable holding midfielder he can be. Broke things up and kept us moving. MOTM.
Gallagher - 6 - Saw flashes of the energy and dynamism that he will undoubtedly bring. But I think he struggled in posession for the most part, but at least tried to be positive. Will be a good signing. 

Phillips - 7 - Solid, dependable showing. Got up and down really well and had a part to play this year, for sure. 
HRK - 7 - 2 good penos, some decent hold up play. But not got the pace to play up there on his own without a #10 closer to him. Another Mr dependable though. 
Edwards - 6 - Showed willing and tried but stuff didn't quite come off. Got bags of talent though and can offer plenty from the bench this year. Ahead of 'Not so turbo' Grosiki for me now  

Subs: 

Grady - 6 - Not much impact and missed the peno. 
O'Shea - 6 - Not tested when he come on. Looked comfortable. 
Austin - 6 - not in long enough but banged his spot kick away as expected.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Great post Lurker.

FWIW I watched the game last night and I thought we should have won in 90 minutes. Many are forgetting that Brentford went to Southampton who played a very strong team and defeated them by two goals to nil.

It was a shame as another game next week would have helped for fitness etc.

Going forward if Bilic does look to play 3 at the back.

I think he needs pace down the sides. It’s why; Kipré, Ivanovic, Ajayi - may be the choice going forward.

We really need 3 more IMO of the right quality to make us competitive. Get the window closed and see where we are come 1st November.

Long season. Plenty of ups and downs. Don’t expect anything on Saturday, but I’m encouraged.
Reply
#3
Amazing how differently people see the game.

Button - 6 - polar opposite to Sam... slow on reflexes and shot stopping, and seems to go down in stages. Would have felt more confident with Johnstone for the shootout, but is more commanding and we did look more confident in set pieces. Distribution better than I have credit for vs Harrogate.

Peltier - 6 - capable backup, playing against a L2 side and a Championship’s Second team is his level
Kipré - 6.5 - so many excellent attributes and so much potential, but appears rash. The walking penalty he appeared in video clips showed tonight, albeit a very harsh one.
Ivanovic - 7 - His experience guided Kipré and held a defence that looked far stronger than in previous games.
Townsend - 6 - barely noticed he was there. Would have liked to have seen him put more attacking pressure on.

Field - 7 - broke up play, did his chances of a league start no harm again
Gallagher - 8 - thought he was excellent all game. His distribution was a little off but that’s just rustiness. Should have scored a couple, but will be a real key player this year.
Harper - 6.5 - First half I thought we were seeing the Harper of 2 years ago. Energetic, purposeful and dominant... second half we saw the Harper we’ve been seeing since his pay rise.

Edwards - 6 - so much ability but drifts in and out of games. Was a real chance for him to cement his place ahead of Grosicki and Phillips but didn’t step up
HRK - 7 - two well taken penalties. Not sure why we didn’t leave him on for the shoot out
Phillips - 6.5 - started well but vanished again. Really think his time is up here

O’Shea - 6 - still lots of work to be done before he’s ready to be a CB at this level. Noticed a difference when he replaced Ivanovic

Not really sure why we brought Grady on, and Austin did what he was brought on to do.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: