(08-12-2019, 10:58 AM)74bus Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I really don't get how people can get heights so far off and you're one of them. It can be difficult to assess anyone's height from a distance, but Johnstone is quite clearly a tall bloke.
Look at the team photo's he is taller than Rodriguez, who is 6 1, and looks about the same as Myhill. I'd say 6 3 is bang on.
People can make sweeping generalizations when they've never even met these guys. For instance people used to think Godden was shorter than he was, because he had a large head and stocky kind of build. However, I saw him loads of times in the 80s, as he used to live round Quinton, and he was very close/if not the same as my height, and I'm bang on 6 1 according to the gym last month, 1 86 in new money.
Perhaps he's standing on a box:
https://www.wba.co.uk/news/2018/august/w...quad-photo
The hounding of Johnstone is becoming embarrassing and he'll need to be mentally strong for it not to get at him.
I was in the BRE (halfway back) on Saturday and when their goal went in there were a few around us who decided straight away that it was his fault.
They must have much better eyesight than me!
Why isn't Barkley in goal, from that photo he's 8' 6"
Maybe point taken re. height on here. Although Kanu's wikipedia says he's 6'1 which would make Rodrigues 6'3 and Johnston 6'5. Gayle's about 5'8 so makes Johnstone just over the 6' mark
Perhaps it's just from my view that he doesn't seem to have any physicality in the situations where he should be coming for a ball.
I'll put this to bed now... I don't rate him but want to be proved wrong. If he was a £1m signing from Scunthorpe you get what you pay for. He's the most expensive keeper we've ever signed (educated guess - Mignolet is the 22nd most expensive keeper transfer fee ever at £9m) so I'm expecting him to perform to that level. And yes blah blah times have changed etc etc. he's young blah de blah blah but you expect the basics and sometimes the basics are alluding him
I've never barracked him at a game - only on the tv (like at Forest where I was amazed it went in).
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(08-12-2019, 11:43 AM)billybassett Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:58 AM)74bus Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I really don't get how people can get heights so far off and you're one of them. It can be difficult to assess anyone's height from a distance, but Johnstone is quite clearly a tall bloke.
Look at the team photo's he is taller than Rodriguez, who is 6 1, and looks about the same as Myhill. I'd say 6 3 is bang on.
People can make sweeping generalizations when they've never even met these guys. For instance people used to think Godden was shorter than he was, because he had a large head and stocky kind of build. However, I saw him loads of times in the 80s, as he used to live round Quinton, and he was very close/if not the same as my height, and I'm bang on 6 1 according to the gym last month, 1 86 in new money.
Perhaps he's standing on a box:
https://www.wba.co.uk/news/2018/august/w...quad-photo
The hounding of Johnstone is becoming embarrassing and he'll need to be mentally strong for it not to get at him.
I was in the BRE (halfway back) on Saturday and when their goal went in there were a few around us who decided straight away that it was his fault.
They must have much better eyesight than me!
Why isn't Barkley in goal, from that photo he's 8' 6"
Maybe point taken re. height on here. Although Kanu's wikipedia says he's 6'1 which would make Rodrigues 6'3 and Johnston 6'5. Gayle's about 5'8 so makes Johnstone just over the 6' mark
Perhaps it's just from my view that he doesn't seem to have any physicality in the situations where he should be coming for a ball.
I'll put this to bed now... I don't rate him but want to be proved wrong. If he was a £1m signing from Scunthorpe you get what you pay for. He's the most expensive keeper we've ever signed (educated guess - Mignolet is the 22nd most expensive keeper transfer fee ever at £9m) so I'm expecting him to perform to that level. And yes blah blah times have changed etc etc. he's young blah de blah blah but you expect the basics and sometimes the basics are alluding him
I've never barracked him at a game - only on the tv (like at Forest where I was amazed it went in). In the team photo Robson-Kanu and JRod look pretty-much the same height. An inch or two is a fair amount in height so really can't see why the internet gets it so wrong. I have mates 5 11 and I look a lot taller than them, but equally my 6 3 pal seems a good bit taller than me.
Feel sorry Johnstone is getting so much stick when he did nothing wrong on Saturday.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
08-12-2019, 12:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2019, 12:27 PM by Big Daddy Cool.)
He's a decent keeper. His reluctance to come out and claim the ball frustrates me but the stick he's getting is over the top.
A big part of goalkeeping is the mental side. If the fans start getting on his back at games then it will affect him. Give him support even if you don't rate him and trust Bilic's judgement that he's the best goalkeeper at the club.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
08-12-2019, 02:02 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2019, 02:11 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(08-12-2019, 12:20 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: He's a decent keeper. His reluctance to come out and claim the ball frustrates me but the stick he's getting is over the top.
A big part of goalkeeping is the mental side. If the fans start getting on his back at games then it will affect him. Give him support even if you don't rate him and trust Bilic's judgement that he's the best goalkeeper at the club.
So right. Any fans who abuse Johnstone need to sling their hook. No position can mess up like a keeper. As I said, my son was a decent keeper, but after he let in a soft goal to go 1-0 behind in a school match his confidence went to shreds, and he made another mistake later on, which again led to a goal. It didn't matter as they were well turned over 6-1 anyhow. After that he just had enough and said it's not worth it as too many of the dads shout like they are at a professional match, when he is just 12.
I have never and never will boo an Albion player. Everyone should support him.
(08-12-2019, 02:02 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (08-12-2019, 12:20 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: He's a decent keeper. His reluctance to come out and claim the ball frustrates me but the stick he's getting is over the top.
A big part of goalkeeping is the mental side. If the fans start getting on his back at games then it will affect him. Give him support even if you don't rate him and trust Bilic's judgement that he's the best goalkeeper at the club.
So right. Any fans who abuse Johnstone need to sling their hook. No position can mess up like a keeper. As I said, my son was a decent keeper, but after he let in a soft goal to go 1-0 behind in a school match his confidence went to shreds, and he made another mistake later on, which again led to a goal. It didn't matter as they were well turned over 6-1 anyhow. After that he just had enough and said it's not worth it as too many of the dads shout like they are at a professional match, when he is just 12.
I have never and never will boo an Albion player. Everyone should support him.
Absolutely 100% right. One back for you: How many serious mistakes can a keeper make before he needs to be dropped?
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(08-12-2019, 02:17 PM)billybassett Wrote: (08-12-2019, 02:02 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (08-12-2019, 12:20 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: He's a decent keeper. His reluctance to come out and claim the ball frustrates me but the stick he's getting is over the top.
A big part of goalkeeping is the mental side. If the fans start getting on his back at games then it will affect him. Give him support even if you don't rate him and trust Bilic's judgement that he's the best goalkeeper at the club.
So right. Any fans who abuse Johnstone need to sling their hook. No position can mess up like a keeper. As I said, my son was a decent keeper, but after he let in a soft goal to go 1-0 behind in a school match his confidence went to shreds, and he made another mistake later on, which again led to a goal. It didn't matter as they were well turned over 6-1 anyhow. After that he just had enough and said it's not worth it as too many of the dads shout like they are at a professional match, when he is just 12.
I have never and never will boo an Albion player. Everyone should support him.
Absolutely 100% right. One back for you: How many serious mistakes can a keeper make before he needs to be dropped? As many as the manager allows. The manager sees the keepers train etc so can make the call. Obviously, if the keeper's head has gone and confidence in shreds it's best they stay away until they are ready.
Incidentally, the poorest keeper I saw at Albion was Zuberhuler, but he clearly had a pedigree. However, he just didn't seem to fit at the Hawthorns despite having a hugely impressive career.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
(08-12-2019, 02:29 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As many as the manager allows. The manager sees the keepers train etc so can make the call. Obviously, if the keeper's head has gone and confidence in shreds it's best they stay away until they are ready.
Incidentally, the poorest keeper I saw at Albion was Zuberhuler, but he clearly had a pedigree. However, he just didn't seem to fit at the Hawthorns despite having a hugely impressive career.
We had a Uruguayan centre half like that too and despite his 'pedigree' he was still largely dogshit  .
Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
Zuber-howler christ I'd forgotten about him.
<shivers>
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(08-12-2019, 10:49 AM)Statto Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (08-12-2019, 08:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: (08-12-2019, 12:55 AM)Statto Wrote: He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
3. Don't agree with this at all. I think we've seem many keepers over the years from Godden to Naylor to Hoult to Foster all make big mistakes but overall they've done their job well and were applauded for it.
5. I don't think any fan was criticising him because of that ridiculous set of tactics. Everyone could see it wasn't going to work because he was passing to people who couldn't trap a bag of cement.
Simply put it was blindly obvious that a good keeper would have just come and punched that ball away as it looped into the 6 yard box right on the back post line. He had to travel no more than 4 foot to get it. He's a protected species so any player obstructing him would have given a free kick away. Taking pressure off the defence immediately.
All players make mistakes and a goalkeeper's are right in the spot light. But it's no coincidence for me that with Johnston in goal our ability to defend balls into the box has decreased.
He needs to learn that's all and if he does then he will be great. He's played 47 times for us and we've conceded at more than a goal a game so it's not an ideal start but he needs to start coming for balls and dominating his area.
PS. His wikipedia page say he's 6'4". If he's 6'4 then I'm 7'2". If he's 6' then that's being generous I really don't get how people can get heights so far off and you're one of them. It can be difficult to assess anyone's height from a distance, but Johnstone is quite clearly a tall bloke.
Look at the team photo's he is taller than Rodriguez, who is 6 1, and looks about the same as Myhill. I'd say 6 3 is bang on.
People can make sweeping generalizations when they've never even met these guys. For instance people used to think Godden was shorter than he was, because he had a large head and stocky kind of build. However, I saw him loads of times in the 80s, as he used to live round Quinton, and he was very close/if not the same as my height, and I'm bang on 6 1 according to the gym last month, 1 86 in new money.
He had the flat above KFC on the Hagley Road at one stage.
My Mum's mate used to manage the KFC and said he could have done with a revolving door with the number of different women!!
Was he a leg or breast man?
Posts: 986
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(08-12-2019, 03:42 PM)Fido Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:49 AM)Statto Wrote: (08-12-2019, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (08-12-2019, 08:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: (08-12-2019, 12:55 AM)Statto Wrote: He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
3. Don't agree with this at all. I think we've seem many keepers over the years from Godden to Naylor to Hoult to Foster all make big mistakes but overall they've done their job well and were applauded for it.
5. I don't think any fan was criticising him because of that ridiculous set of tactics. Everyone could see it wasn't going to work because he was passing to people who couldn't trap a bag of cement.
Simply put it was blindly obvious that a good keeper would have just come and punched that ball away as it looped into the 6 yard box right on the back post line. He had to travel no more than 4 foot to get it. He's a protected species so any player obstructing him would have given a free kick away. Taking pressure off the defence immediately.
All players make mistakes and a goalkeeper's are right in the spot light. But it's no coincidence for me that with Johnston in goal our ability to defend balls into the box has decreased.
He needs to learn that's all and if he does then he will be great. He's played 47 times for us and we've conceded at more than a goal a game so it's not an ideal start but he needs to start coming for balls and dominating his area.
PS. His wikipedia page say he's 6'4". If he's 6'4 then I'm 7'2". If he's 6' then that's being generous I really don't get how people can get heights so far off and you're one of them. It can be difficult to assess anyone's height from a distance, but Johnstone is quite clearly a tall bloke.
Look at the team photo's he is taller than Rodriguez, who is 6 1, and looks about the same as Myhill. I'd say 6 3 is bang on.
People can make sweeping generalizations when they've never even met these guys. For instance people used to think Godden was shorter than he was, because he had a large head and stocky kind of build. However, I saw him loads of times in the 80s, as he used to live round Quinton, and he was very close/if not the same as my height, and I'm bang on 6 1 according to the gym last month, 1 86 in new money.
He had the flat above KFC on the Hagley Road at one stage.
My Mum's mate used to manage the KFC and said he could have done with a revolving door with the number of different women!!
Was he a leg or breast man?
He kept that recipe secret.
|