Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(08-11-2019, 09:06 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-11-2019, 08:34 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.
Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.
The OP is a clown of course but pointing out weaknesses is not making him a scapegoat as you keep claiming in every thread.
I've had concerns about SJ since day one. He spends far too much time rooted to his line when balls are within a couple of yards of him. He hasn't made any improvement in this area since he's been with us.
The scapegoating has been happening since the day he got here. After his debut he was described as “the worst since Crichton” and it has continued from there. There has been a constant, low level noise around him. Every goal we concede it seems someone is there saying he should do better or it was his fault in some way. That goes beyond expressing concerns, it has become an agenda.
I wouldn't class "scapegoating" as one morons opinion. Or any others who just says "he's fucking shit". There's a medium here, and it's that Johnstone has been found wanting more than a handful of times in certain "goalkeeping" situations. He also makes some brilliant saves, and has had some dodgy, like any goalkeeper. He's not shit, but he has a serious shortfall to his game. There'll always be morons who have their boo boys. Try and look at the situation in a balanced way.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
I didn't see the away match at Brighton, but I haven't seen anything otherwise from Bond that would indicate that he's better than Johnstone, so I think people are only clamouring for him because he's better looking.
Albion pigeon - I see your point, but the constant whining about certain players is very wearing, especially when it's devoid of fact.
Last season, Johnstone got far more right than he did wrong. Someone was one here saying he wasn't a good shot-stopper - he's an excellent shot stopper. He also gets blamed for the sort of worldies that are seen as complete genius when it's one of our players who scores them.
Likewise, I'm bored of reading people complain about Livermore. Five managers have picked him for the first eleven, people need to get over it.
Posts: 986
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
08-11-2019, 11:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-11-2019, 11:26 PM by Statto.)
(08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
Posts: 18
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(08-11-2019, 11:25 PM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
With your background, I tend to appreciate your opinion on keepers. How do you rate Johnstone?
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(08-11-2019, 09:06 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-11-2019, 08:34 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.
Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.
The OP is a clown of course but pointing out weaknesses is not making him a scapegoat as you keep claiming in every thread.
I've had concerns about SJ since day one. He spends far too much time rooted to his line when balls are within a couple of yards of him. He hasn't made any improvement in this area since he's been with us.
The scapegoating has been happening since the day he got here. After his debut he was described as “the worst since Crichton” and it has continued from there. There has been a constant, low level noise around him. Every goal we concede it seems someone is there saying he should do better or it was his fault in some way. That goes beyond expressing concerns, it has become an agenda.
Firstly I haven't seen any games this season, or any highlights due to hols, so I cant pass an opinion.
Duffers always reminds us of the "worst since Crighton" which was my remark.
During last season he made some good saves and cost us some points. He cant command his area and is beaten way too easily from distance. This is why the opposition always have a pop from distance. He does have good reflexes though, which has seen some good saves.
My last comment on him was that he was "bang average" and thats where I sit with him I haven't seen any improvements in his weaknesses. If we had paid a couple of mill for him I would call that fair. Based on evidence so far though, I think we have overpaid. JT carried the whole Villa defence in his last season there.
Posts: 986
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(08-11-2019, 11:42 PM)Wimatum Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:25 PM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
With your background, I tend to appreciate your opinion on keepers. How do you rate Johnstone?
He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
Posts: 1,961
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(08-12-2019, 12:55 AM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:42 PM)Wimatum Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:25 PM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
With your background, I tend to appreciate your opinion on keepers. How do you rate Johnstone?
He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
Excellent post Statto. I think Saturday proves that a lot of fans have made their mind up on Sam and will try and justify this by analysing everything he does to try and find something to beat him with.
He does need to improve. He needs to command better, talk more and move his feet better when getting down to shots. But he had a solid game Saturday and certainly wasn't at fault for the goal.
Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-12-2019, 12:55 AM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:42 PM)Wimatum Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:25 PM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
With your background, I tend to appreciate your opinion on keepers. How do you rate Johnstone?
He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
This is a much more eloquent summary than I can manage.
Posts: 582
Threads: 16
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.
What utter garbage. How long til you go back to school?
Posts: 18
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(08-12-2019, 07:08 AM)Duffers Wrote: (08-12-2019, 12:55 AM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:42 PM)Wimatum Wrote: (08-11-2019, 11:25 PM)Statto Wrote: (08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.
I don’t disagree, but if Sam Johnstone concedes our goal yesterday he’s getting hammered from all angles.
With your background, I tend to appreciate your opinion on keepers. How do you rate Johnstone?
He’s as good a prospect as any in the league. He’s not there yet and needs to work on areas, but he can be a very good keeper for us. However, as a spacegoat been got a few things going agaisnt him:
1 he signed after being at Villa
I hate Villa with an absolute passion, but this complex about their ex players is utterly pathetic. I heard it so many times in vocal criticism of SJ all season, e.g “just fuggin kick it you useless Villa prick”
2 he followed Ben Foster
Best Albion keeper in my supporting lifetime, by a distance. Will always suffer by comparison, but some forget we are a division lower and Fozzie didn’t mature properly until 30. He was also written off after he should apparently have thrown his cap on Rooney’s shot on his debut. “No better than Carson” being the classic.
3 our fanbase loves to destroy goalkeepers
If any keeper were to ask me whether WBA was a good career move, hand on heart I’d have to say don’t touch the place with a barge pole.
4 he started shakily
He had a nervous debut and some wrote him off after day one, probably linked to all three above. Some, not all, will leap on anything and everything to justify that opinion.
5 Jones’ tactics
His passing range is good. Look at Blades analytics video clips on Twitter showing it at Forest. Asking him to do what he was last season heaped unnecessary pressure on him and an intolerant fanbase jumped on his back at every opportunity, despite it being crystal clear he was playing to instruction. This hampered his ability to build confidence, but he visibly lifted after the management change.
We are in real danger of being in Carson territory where every single goal conceded being his fault. The standout for me was Blackburn. When Somen Tchoyi ducked out of a header defending a corner and that was Carson’s fault because it’s his job to organise the defence, despite those roles being allocated and practiced on the training field.
Sam Johnstone is our number one until at least January. What is the point of trying to destroy him and pin everything on him. He may have done better at Forest, but Bartley was indecisive whether to close, unsighting SJ in the process. The shot was an awkward one with the bounce and a combination of those factors and seeming to be slightly in mid air as it was hit, meant it beat him.
I’ve watched yesterday’s goal and the camera angle cut in build up doesn’t help to see clearly, but I can’t see what he’s being blamed for.
Bartley should win the header from the long free kick. That’s not SJ’s ball out there, it’s CB header all day. They have a man pinning him on the corner which means he won’t ever get to that ball which is outside the six yard box, right where our zonal markers set. The ball back in is beyond the far post and should be headed behind by HRK. The position of delivery is key. It wasn’t out on the touchline and floated in, it was just outside the box. It was also above the height of the bar as it cleared the far post. If we are saying that SJ is expected to cover a full 8 yards, given his starting position should be central but slightly favouring the near post, in the time it takes the ball to to travel around 30 yards, he’s in the wrong sport. He should be doing the 100m.
What I will say is that after the free kick, there was a big debate and as a unit we lost concentration before the corner. This contributed to the goal IMHO. Whover instigated that bears some responsibilty and that may have been SJ, it may have been Bartley.
This is a much more eloquent summary than I can manage.
Point 5 is the one for me. New, young keeper comes to the club and follows his Managers instructions, to the letter. With more experience, he would have made his own decisions on occasions and ignored the Management.
|