Sam Johnstone
#11
The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.

Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.
Reply
#12
(08-11-2019, 06:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Millwall getting Bialkowski on a season’s loan is a cracking bit of business. He’s one of the best keepers in this division.

Johnstone is a perfectly capable Champ keeper but he has big weaknesses, and those can easily be exploited.

The Forest goal was a one-off, that’s pretty much the first time he’s been caught out by a shot like that, but it happens. Yesterday’s goal however is a big concern, he’s been consistently poor in that type of scenario since he signed, and it’s something canny opposition managers will exploit.

This is about right. Johnston proved last season that he is an excellent shot stopper and has many good attributes. Dominating his area, unfortunately, isn't one of them. I really don't like to see public criticism of The Albion though. I'd much sooner see a thread singing the praises of our players. We maybe should all bear in mind that if t'internet had existed years before, Astle ,Regis, Cunningham, Bobby Hope and many more, may not have been the legends that we now love.
Reply
#13
(08-11-2019, 06:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.

Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.

Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#14
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.

Don't be daft but Bilic has to have the balls to give Bond a chance even though Sam cost 5m and Bond cost nothing.
Reply
#15
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.

Let's be honest, he's one of the best keepers in the division - by a distance.
Every time the opposition score a goal - why is it his fault. I for one are tired of the tirade of abuse thrown his way.
Foster was our best keeper for a decade and he dropped some almighty clangers, but also made some world class saves and he never IMO was treated like a criminal. It was accepted he was human and would make an error on occasions.
Some are not happy unless they are knocking our players, Johnstone, Bartley, Livermore are the 3 current targets.
Barry, Evans, Phillips, Dawson, Brunt, HRK, McClean even Peace have all been on the receiving end over the last few seasons and it does nobody any favours. 
Continual criticism of our players is what I would expect of Collymore, Goodman or any Dingle or Seal. Not a Baggies supporter.
Whinge over.
Reply
#16
(08-11-2019, 06:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.

Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.

The OP is a clown of course but pointing out weaknesses is not making him a scapegoat as you keep claiming in every thread. 

I've had concerns about SJ since day one. He spends far too much time rooted to his line when balls are within a couple of yards of him. He hasn't made any improvement in this area since he's been with us.
Reply
#17
(08-11-2019, 08:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.

Let's be honest, he's one of the best keepers in the division - by a distance.
Every time the opposition score a goal - why is it his fault. I for one are tired of the tirade of abuse thrown his way.
Foster was our best keeper for a decade and he dropped some almighty clangers, but also made some world class saves and he never IMO was treated like a criminal. It was accepted he was human and would make an error on occasions.
Some are not happy unless they are knocking our players, Johnstone, Bartley, Livermore are the 3 current targets.
Barry, Evans, Phillips, Dawson, Brunt, HRK, McClean even Peace have all been on the receiving end over the last few seasons and it does nobody any favours. 
Continual criticism of our players is what I would expect of Collymore, Goodman or any Dingle or Seal. Not a Baggies supporter.
Whinge over.

I think being a keeper is the most thankless role anyone could ever have. My son was a promising keeper, played for the school and was asked to trial for Solihull Moors by the youth manager, but he just jacked it all in last year. I'm glad.
Johnstone seems decent, just he is unfortunate to be following the best keeper we've probably ever had. As long as he is picked I'll support him.

(08-11-2019, 08:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.

Let's be honest, he's one of the best keepers in the division - by a distance.
Every time the opposition score a goal - why is it his fault. I for one are tired of the tirade of abuse thrown his way.
Foster was our best keeper for a decade and he dropped some almighty clangers, but also made some world class saves and he never IMO was treated like a criminal. It was accepted he was human and would make an error on occasions.
Some are not happy unless they are knocking our players, Johnstone, Bartley, Livermore are the 3 current targets.
Barry, Evans, Phillips, Dawson, Brunt, HRK, McClean even Peace have all been on the receiving end over the last few seasons and it does nobody any favours. 
Continual criticism of our players is what I would expect of Collymore, Goodman or any Dingle or Seal. Not a Baggies supporter.
Whinge over.

I think being a keeper is the most thankless role anyone could ever have. May son was a promising keeper, played for the school and was asked to trial for Solihull Moors by the youth manager, but he just jacked it all in last year. I'm glad.
Johnstone seems decent, just he is unfortunate to be following the best keeper we've probably ever had. As long as he is picked I'll support him.
Reply
#18
He was excellent against Villa in the play off second leg.
Reply
#19
(08-11-2019, 08:34 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(08-11-2019, 06:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: The latest in the Spacegoat Sweeps sees Johnstone way out in front. Livermore is second but a fair distance back with Bartley close behind.

Keep an eye out for Zohore though who could make considerable ground up in the coming weeks.

The OP is a clown of course but pointing out weaknesses is not making him a scapegoat as you keep claiming in every thread. 

I've had concerns about SJ since day one. He spends far too much time rooted to his line when balls are within a couple of yards of him. He hasn't made any improvement in this area since he's been with us.

The scapegoating has been happening since the day he got here. After his debut he was described as “the worst since Crichton” and it has continued from there. There has been a constant, low level noise around him. Every goal we concede it seems someone is there saying he should do better or it was his fault in some way. That goes beyond expressing concerns, it has become an agenda.
Reply
#20
(08-11-2019, 05:43 PM)Moore Than Wrote: Let's be honest, he's the worst keeper in the division. By a distance.

Fuck me. Josh has not ever been able to post such compete drivel.

Board idiot, is now you.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: