Appy start...
#1
0-5 to Utd!

Did anyone go?
Reply
#2
(08-10-2019, 09:31 AM)Peachy Wrote: 0-5 to Utd!

Did anyone go?

Yes Peachy.

Just for some context, Manchester United have a really decent crop of youngsters coming through, especially Garner who played yesterday. Only Greenwood and Angel Gomes were missing. 

Assuming they will be part of the United squad on Sunday.

As for Albion, we were missing Palmer (on Loan), Wilson (on Loan), Ferguson, O’Shea, Harper, Field (on Loan), Leko (On Loan).

Interestingly Boaz Myhill was on the bench with Appleton. Some in attendance was saying he has been allowed to start training for his badges at Albion. Still lives in Sutton.

We played ok at times but weren’t clinical when the few chances did fall. Very sloppy at back too. Fitzwater is in a position whereby he has outgrown U23 football, but needed a higher level than League 1 to fully test him. Assuming no Championship teams came in for him on loan. Soule had the best of our chances.

We set up in a 4-2-3-1. United were the better team, but 5-0 was harsh on the boys.

With Tulloch and Nick Clayton Phillips wide. I think whilst Soule is decent. You worry about his build for English football.

Don’t want to judge on Appleton’s first game back as IMO results don’t really matter at U18/U23 level, for me it’s about pathway to first team and seeing individual improvements and how many players we are producing of first team quality.

Some rumours flying around that Academy staff morale is at an all time low due to the changes Dowling has made. The training ground isn’t the biggest and making it separate to first team has upset many it seems. I said if it was that bad would Appleton have joined? Counter argument was Appleton has joined because Dowling is succession planning if/when Bilic moves
Reply
#3
Cheers for the write up Super_Slav. You love your rumours though don't you haha.
Reply
#4
Decent write up Ziz.

Soule and Tulloch need to get out and play some football, and Fitz probably needs another year in L1, as his second spell at Walsall was a lot more hit and miss than previous.

It’s obvious that younger players, parents and staff will be disappointed with the changes at academy level, but Dowling’s changes make sense. Too many of our players seem to believe they’ve made it from day one, and anything to retain that hunger to succeed for a little longer is a positive step, but as with any environment, if you lose a privilege you feel you’re entitled to, your immediate response will always be negative.
Reply
#5
(08-10-2019, 10:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Decent write up Ziz.

Soule and Tulloch need to get out and play some football, and Fitz probably needs another year in L1, as his second spell at Walsall was a lot more hit and miss than previous.

It’s obvious that younger players, parents and staff will be disappointed with the changes at academy level, but Dowling’s changes make sense. Too many of our players seem to believe they’ve made it from day one, and anything to retain that hunger to succeed for a little longer is a positive step, but as with any environment, if you lose a privilege you feel you’re entitled to, your immediate response will always be negative.

Thanks SW4.

I think the main issue is that because our training ground is fairly small by Premier League standards. We are offering smaller alternatives to Academy. That’s what has irked Academy staff too. Also the way in which Dowling maybe comes across to Academy staff/players hasn’t gone done too well.

Now there always two side to a story. I’m v surprised the club has allowed Dowling to implement a different structure as Dowling will be judged by fans on the first team. If we are struggling come January he could quite easily come under pressure.

I’ve never visited the training ground personally, so I don’t know. But didn’t we shelve plans to extend the training ground two years ago due to relegation?
Reply
#6
(08-10-2019, 10:04 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(08-10-2019, 09:31 AM)Peachy Wrote: 0-5 to Utd!

Did anyone go?

Yes Peachy.

Just for some context, Manchester United have a really decent crop of youngsters coming through, especially Garner who played yesterday. Only Greenwood and Angel Gomes were missing. 

Assuming they will be part of the United squad on Sunday.

As for Albion, we were missing Palmer (on Loan), Wilson (on Loan), Ferguson, O’Shea, Harper, Field (on Loan), Leko (On Loan).

Interestingly Boaz Myhill was on the bench with Appleton. Some in attendance was saying he has been allowed to start training for his badges at Albion. Still lives in Sutton.

We played ok at times but weren’t clinical when the few chances did fall. Very sloppy at back too. Fitzwater is in a position whereby he has outgrown U23 football, but needed a higher level than League 1 to fully test him. Assuming no Championship teams came in for him on loan. Soule had the best of our chances.

We set up in a 4-2-3-1. United were the better team, but 5-0 was harsh on the boys.

With Tulloch and Nick Clayton Phillips wide. I think whilst Soule is decent. You worry about his build for English football.

Don’t want to judge on Appleton’s first game back as IMO results don’t really matter at U18/U23 level, for me it’s about pathway to first team and seeing individual improvements and how many players we are producing of first team quality.

Some rumours flying around that Academy staff morale is at an all time low due to the changes Dowling has made. The training ground isn’t the biggest and making it separate to first team has upset many it seems. I said if it was that bad would Appleton have joined? Counter argument was Appleton has joined because Dowling is succession planning if/when Bilic moves

Good balanced write up. Cheers. I saw Soule a few times last season. Very tidy player but yes a bit on the light weight side. Hasn't hindered other top players though. Just a bit of extra bulk and he'll be a good un.
Reply
#7
Boaz is going to be added to the staff, likely to replace Naylor in GK set up

Cuzer
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)