Posts: 11,317
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
The problem is BB, you’re describing exceptionally expensive solutions which may in all likelihood have zero effect on problem on global scale. It is going to take a very brave politician to suggest that to voters, particularly when so many people are only just waking up to how much this is already costing them.
Posts: 13,576
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Ah right then, let's not replace or upgrade any infrastructure ever then if you want to make that argument. Let's not bother replacing the UK's GT fleet that's approaching eol over the next 15 years. Let's not upgrade our grid to manage increased demand. Let's not upgrade and maintain our railways that can't operate in the heat and rely on road freight that uses our pothole-ridden roads that are worsened by more frequent floods and hot weather. Let's not bother insulating buildings and introduce HVAC systems while hotter summers with temperatures in excess of 35 degrees for long periods are more common and we're in the 4th major gas price crunch this millennium driving up energy bills. Let's continue to lose tens of millions of hours of work in the summer. And we should let one of the strongest performing economic sectors that we've spent decades building a comparative advantage move to other countries, not bothering to use our position as a fucking windy island with a huge coastline for sea-cooled nuclear, wind and tidal power for electricity exports and to massively expand the energy supply side to onshore energy demand applications and export power to Europe and North Africa.
Talking about people "waking up" when your eyes are welded shut is a good oxymoron though.
Posts: 11,317
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Ok. Let me ask the question another way. What would you rather the state DIDN’T spend money on?
It’s pretty clear everyone’s at the end of their tether with taxation, and we can hardly borrow any more - we’re borrowing to pay debt interest already.
Posts: 13,576
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
That's not the problem, you're presenting a false dichotomy. The state doesn't get to ignore building infrastructure for 50 years and then not have to spend on infrastructure renewal. Much as the state doesn't get to choose to not have to spend money on huge climate change mitigation programmes. What the state gets to choose is do we spend a medium amount of money now or something unaffordable in both money and human costs 45 years later, because things built 80-years ago is going to be significantly less fit-for-purpose than things built 40-years ago especially when the situation on the ground is in flux and rapidly changing due to climate change, and the cost of infrastructure is increasing every year at a rate higher than inflation.
Need I remind you that if people putting forward your exact argument in 1980 about nuclear power and 1990 on electric and water utility infrastructure investment costing too much at a time with high interest rates and economic challenge were ignored and we ploughed ahead with building it we'd be in a significantly better place now? It cost a lot of money in the 1980s and 1990s, but it costs a hell of a lot more now and I'm sure as hell people are at their tether with our energy bills and the southwest of England being in a fucking drought in mid-November.
Now once you accept that then we can start having a conversation on what the country needs to do to maximise the return of investment from infrastructure renewal both through regulatory reform, mixed-sector financing, taxation reform and the impact of economies-of-scale on materials and labour costs and supply. Because supply-side economics is not just about tax cuts.