The view from the opposition - Karlan Grant
#11
Karlan Grant is probably one of, if not the highest earner at Charlton. If he can't be arsed to run around in a game (and we have seen that on occasion, although admittedly in his latter seasons far less whilst here), a fan has every right to rant about him online.

I'm glad we didn't keep him this summer. There's a player in Grant when he wants to play, but we now have far more exciting and effective options.

Had Grant decided to stay, we'd arguably have not signed FHM!!
Reply
#12
(11-09-2026, 10:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Isn't this just football fans at their worst? Getting all outraged because a player doesn't "acknowledge the fans" after a match during which they've no doubt been abusing him because his team are crap and getting tonked away from home in a distant and shitty corner of the country. Sparked off by an angry tweet which was then deleted because the tweeter admitted it was "a mistake" to be so critical.

And then some fan from a previous club, who maybe shouted abuse at said player every week for several years, re-posts this trivia to achieve what exactly?

Are we going to spend the next 5 years or so trying to reinforce our view that Karlan Grant is a disgrace, or shall we move on as a club and fan base to better players and better things? Just askin'.

Calm down! It was meant to be a jokey parody of Squid’s threads, although the quotes are genuine. And no I never gave Grant any abuse during games as I don’t to any Albion player.
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#13
(11-09-2026, 10:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Isn't this just football fans at their worst? Getting all outraged because a player doesn't "acknowledge the fans" after a match during which they've no doubt been abusing him because his team are crap and getting tonked away from home in a distant and shitty corner of the country. Sparked off by an angry tweet which was then deleted because the tweeter admitted it was "a mistake" to be so critical.

And then some fan from a previous club, who maybe shouted abuse at said player every week for several years, re-posts this trivia to achieve what exactly?

Are we going to spend the next 5 years or so trying to reinforce our view that Karlan Grant is a disgrace, or shall we move on as a club and fan base to better players and better things? Just askin'.
Aren't you just outraged at the outrage though?   Huh Big Grin
Reply
#14
Can’t respect the opinions of someone who didn’t give Luke Moore dogs abuse
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#15
(11-09-2026, 10:47 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(11-09-2026, 10:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Isn't this just football fans at their worst? Getting all outraged because a player doesn't "acknowledge the fans" after a match during which they've no doubt been abusing him because his team are crap and getting tonked away from home in a distant and shitty corner of the country. Sparked off by an angry tweet which was then deleted because the tweeter admitted it was "a mistake" to be so critical.

And then some fan from a previous club, who maybe shouted abuse at said player every week for several years, re-posts this trivia to achieve what exactly?

Are we going to spend the next 5 years or so trying to reinforce our view that Karlan Grant is a disgrace, or shall we move on as a club and fan base to better players and better things? Just askin'.

Crikey

Whatever you do, don't suggest a better manager than Atkinson would have won something.
The website will crash. Big Grin
Reply
#16
I was a fan of Grant in the last year of his stay here.  I thought he came back from being on loan with a better attitude and put 100% effort in most games and was certainly as good as those around him. 

I'm delighted to say that if he was still here, he would not be good enough to get on the bench, such has been the improvement in the quality of the squad.  

It's easy to forget how average we were with a lot of average players  when he was a regular.
Reply
#17
Players come, players go. Fans get their knickers in a twist when players don’t ’show them respect’, some fans defend players, some don’t. Twas ever thus..
Reply
#18
(11-09-2026, 06:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Players come, players go. Fans get their knickers in a twist when players don’t ’show them respect’, some fans defend players, some don’t. Twas ever thus..

I always love how fans demand loyalty and respect from players, but if they have a few bad games, they are shit, should be sold or released as soon as possible and sadly often abused.
Reply
#19
As much as I love Albion I respect the players as professionals who are doing a job and I shake my head at the number of utter morons who support our club, as is the case with all clubs.
There’s a certain type of football fan, and they’re on this board, who get so emotionally invested that they lose all their senses, decorum and act like utter pond life. Be it the people booing our less than stellar goalkeepers of recent years like Button or Wildsmith, or the moron who threw a coin that hit Chris Brunt, we have them.
On the lesser scale of brain dead people are just those who hurl pure poison via social media.
Karlan Grant was a decent player who we paid too much for at a time when recruitment was poor and the club was on the slide. He’s a product of that Lai era.
Every time he pulled on a shirt I never once abused him, even though he made mistakes.
I’m glad we no longer need him but for him to have forged a career at a level that 99 percent of pros never have shows he has something.
Lest we forget that Morrison would have kept him too.
It seems Charlton have the same problem with stupid fans.
This post will only help cement the mindset of similarly stupid fans here in the W Mids.
Reply
#20
Grant looked brilliant under threat for a place, and his shitness was inversely proportional to the competition for one.

FWIW I’d have kept him for the right money, as we are lacking both at set pieces and sometimes wide play. But if that was too much, then it was right to let him go, regret his big decision on spending money the Addicks don’t have for his many shit neck tattoos, and say goodbye, thanks and all the best.

Oh that, and Jimmy Moz didn’t need a billy big bollocks in the side on a bumper contract lauding it over the others. So the way I see it, with he and Mowatt now tearing up the lower league, that is most (if not all) of the deck cleared of shit. Shit I only associate with regressive times. It doesn’t mean that we don’t lack what he can bring, but would he bring it often enough for the money? Especially with latter concerns over fitness? I doubt it.

He’s part of the old, shit Albion, that Carlos could only paper over. Mozza has a chance to build from the ground up, and I don’t see him as that sort of player. Shit as he’s been for a couple of matches, JJ is probably a much better (and more malleable, manageable) asset.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)