Molumby
#31
(11-08-2026, 05:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 05:08 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 05:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 04:52 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: You don’t always see the best bits of Molumby’s play from the telly often.

He was underperforming at his most prolific when he was carrying Mowatt. But since Mowatt was so many fans’ man-crush (not just Josh, just Josh’s), no-one dared say it. If you dared question the mighty Mowatt, many on this board would have you committed. Derby really seeming to benefit from him though.

This post perfectly sums up football opinions I guess. If you rate Molumby to the extent he could shag your wife and you'd high five him you will find excuses for his underperformance across the years. If you don't rate him you will naturally see him as part of the wider problem and should be shot at dawn.

Either way it's nice to see him playing well, because he's easy to like as a player and with more output regardless of the reason why, he's an asset. 

Regarding Mowatt. His legs had started falling off last year everyone knew it. That's what happens to a midfielder who's been a first team regular since he was 17/18 and had a few injuries over the years.

And I think this post epitomises the short-termism of internet debate.

I’ve given Molumby dog’s abuse over the years. I’m choosing not to now because a) he doesn’t deserve it and b) I’ve no vendetta against him. Which many - outside the ground - do.

Conversely, Mowatt’s legs went years ago and many were still sucking him off with almost routine enjoyment.

Fwiw, Hawks. It wasn't a dig. It was more of a reflection that football opinions differ and people see dynamics differently. 

Your second line is spot on. Your third, no some much IMO. But as I say football opinions are like arseholes, that why I like data  Big Grin

Point taken, and not seen as a dig as a result. But data only matters to an extent. There is only one metric that matters. 

That’s not me writing off the importance of data in sports science and application to get the best out of players. Just me saying that, very often, a peripheral view counts above all else.

The telly and data don’t tell you who does the covering when it matters most, how well energy is spent/expended, nor how the crowd feel. And the sentiment of a crowd cannot be ignored.
Reply
#32
(11-08-2026, 03:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 03:52 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 02:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 01:53 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 09:50 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Since the international break he's been great. Still at the centre of a couple of cock ups in our box, but his contribution in the final third is getting so much better.

If he keeps that output along with all the stuff he does naturally, he is a shoe in. Fair play to him and Mozza for getting it right in the last few games.

Want another shovel, Lurk? You've worn that one out on this dig. Molumby has always been one of (or more likely, THE) the most consistent players. Fact is, he has better options around him now and like all the others is under better management. And his goal yesrday could only have been scored by Molumby-not giving up on a wayward pass, tackled the ball from the keepers hand, stayed on his feet for the tap in. Not many of our others would've ticked those 3 boxes.
40 Ireland caps now, many as captain. Just sayin

No shovel needed, TJ. I only ever give opinions I can back up.

I don't doubt that Molumby is consistent. Unfortunately, for large parts of his time with us his output hasn't been good enough. It is now, and has been a big  part of the upturn in our recent performances so he deserves all the plaudits he gets. 

I am happy to blow the Jayson Molumby whistle which is easy to do when you don't hold emotional opinions about things.

Like I say, for a long time he's been a crucial part of the team. Fact is he has better options and better mobility around him now. He does the ugly stuff, someone always had to.

But, but, but the stats! As Jacky said, ‘I’m not seeing it lads’.

As ever Dekka, context is your friend (and completely absent from your posts).
Reply
#33
(11-08-2026, 05:15 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Point taken, and not seen as a dig as a result. But data only matters to an extent. There is only one metric that matters. 

That’s not me writing off the importance of data in sports science and application to get the best out of players. Just me saying that, very often, a peripheral view counts above all else.

The telly and data don’t tell you who does the covering when it matters most, how well energy is spent/expended, now how the crowd feel.

I completely agree. I am not sure why, but some people seem to think I watch a game of football through a spreadsheet. I don't look at any data untill after the match as to not obscure my view of the match.

I have always praised Molumby for much of what you talk about in your last sentence. I have also pointed out his flaws over the years. I am now praising him for improving on those flaws which is great. I am interested to see if he can keep that up, or if he can't, can we find that threat from elsewhere in in the team to balance it out.

Either way, for now we should all just be enjoying what's been a really positive run of performances after, for me, a concerning spell.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#34
Indeed, Lurker. For instance, I once wrote him off as useful, but never a player we’d achieve promotion with.

I hope that comment comes back to haunt me.
Reply
#35
The rendition of his song when he scored was something to behold. It nearly blew the BRE roof off!
Reply
#36
Molumby is very nearly box to box atm.
He and Diakite are arguably the best CM pairing in the Championship.

If JM can keep his head and maintain his current form he could be POTS.

But atm it's a high bar
Reply
#37
Molumby is a player who cannot be wholly defined by stats due to much of his influence being nebulous.  Stats don't reflect every corner we have where he's pissing off the keeper and at least one defender, or all the niggles further up the pitch where he buys us a free kick or time with a bit of gamesmanship, nor do they reflect his desire and passion that the rest of the team feed off and take inspiration from.  Of all our players he is absolutely, the most self aware, he knows his limitations and his role, when he does it well and it works, the results are plain to see, along with a growth in his confidence which makes him a better player in terms of tackles, passes, shots, assists, goals and us a better team.  He still has his detractors and I totally get why, but for me Jayson Molumby will be the driving force behind any success we may have this season, Mozzas post match interview yesterday suggested that too.
Reply
#38
I loved the bit in the price interview on Albion tv - Molumby is an angry man!!
Reply
#39
(11-08-2026, 06:08 PM)Celebrity cruise baggie Wrote: I loved the bit in the price interview on Albion tv - Molumby is an angry man!!

That creased me up and made my above post more pertinent!!  Our most skillful player paying a backhanded compliment to our most influencial!!
Reply
#40
(11-08-2026, 06:08 PM)Celebrity cruise baggie Wrote: I loved the bit in the price interview on Albion tv - Molumby is an angry man!!

Well he's Irish as is Roy Keane.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)