Jesus de Miguel
#21
(11-03-2026, 10:58 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.

Momentum is a huge factor, you've got two players running at each other at pace.

As I said further up because it took place on the half way line that keeper must have sprinted 20-30 yards before launching himself into the striker. He clearly goes up to try and head the ball but his momentum absolutely wipes the striker out.

It's reckless, stupid and clearly a red card offence. Whether it's worthy of anything further legally is a whole other can of worms.
Reply
#22
Tragic news. R.I.P
Does not appear on viewing to be Malicious.

Thoughts out to everyone involved, not nice for the keeper having to live with what has happened either.
Reply
#23
I agree that there should not be legal action against the Keeper, because he didn’t mean to happen what did.
But this type of challenge has to be outlawed.
Reply
#24
Hard to see what the keeper was trying to do, almost as if he was going to catch it. Think he panicked because he was so far out of position. Cleary didn’t mean harm, so agree no legal intervention.
Terrible, terrible accident.
RIP
Reply
#25
(11-03-2026, 11:13 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:58 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.

Momentum is a huge factor, you've got two players running at each other at pace.

As I said further up because it took place on the half way line that keeper must have sprinted 20-30 yards before launching himself into the striker. He clearly goes up to try and head the ball but his momentum absolutely wipes the striker out.

It's reckless, stupid and clearly a red card offence. Whether it's worthy of anything further legally is a whole other can of worms.

Yup, that's where I'm at too. The keeper is a big bloke and hits him at speed with a lot of momentum behind him, but in game where physical attributes are pursued, it would be wrong to expect him not to use them. It's reckless, and I think he intentionally goes in to either take the man or the ball, but it doesn't make him a murderer. 

Whilst he's arguably not the most immediate in need of sympathy, this cannot be easy for the goalkeeper either! Not sure if / how he comes back from this.
Reply
#26
(11-03-2026, 10:45 AM)Squid Wrote: The closest example I can think of is the Nottingham ice hockey player who was stabbed in the neck with a skate blade. Equally reckless behaviour but the CPS ruled there was no realistic prospect of conviction:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cly2wkl17d7o

IMO the ice hockey thing was worse. The player seemed to lose his balance and try to stop his opponent by kicking out, wearing a blade. I’m absolutely stunned that there was no conviction.

It’s a shocking challenge in Tenerife but also a really unfortunate outcome. People saying he’s a murderer are exaggerating.
Reply
#27
(11-03-2026, 12:37 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:45 AM)Squid Wrote: The closest example I can think of is the Nottingham ice hockey player who was stabbed in the neck with a skate blade. Equally reckless behaviour but the CPS ruled there was no realistic prospect of conviction:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cly2wkl17d7o

IMO the ice hockey thing was worse. The player seemed to lose his balance and try to stop his opponent by kicking out, wearing a blade. I’m absolutely stunned that there was no conviction.

It’s a shocking challenge in Tenerife but also a really unfortunate outcome. People saying he’s a murderer are exaggerating.

Likewise, that seemed at the very least a manslaughter case.

This challenge definitely isn't at that level, but I guess the punishment of him living with his actions for the rest of his life will be bad enough.
Reply
#28
I wonder how many people who are asking for legal action (not just on here, but SM as a whole) have also criticised a player for backing out of a challenge, or not being physical enough?
Reply
#29
(11-03-2026, 09:45 AM)KRO Wrote: Tragic. Awful news. RIP

Good grief.  RIP
Reply
#30
(11-03-2026, 12:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 12:37 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:45 AM)Squid Wrote: The closest example I can think of is the Nottingham ice hockey player who was stabbed in the neck with a skate blade. Equally reckless behaviour but the CPS ruled there was no realistic prospect of conviction:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cly2wkl17d7o

IMO the ice hockey thing was worse. The player seemed to lose his balance and try to stop his opponent by kicking out, wearing a blade. I’m absolutely stunned that there was no conviction.

It’s a shocking challenge in Tenerife but also a really unfortunate outcome. People saying he’s a murderer are exaggerating.

Likewise, that seemed at the very least a manslaughter case.

This challenge definitely isn't at that level, but I guess the punishment of him living with his actions for the rest of his life will be bad enough.

It's hard not to feel a degree of sympathy for the keeper in all of this. He's done nothing malicious, simply had a rush of blood (purely in a footballing sense) and suddenly a man is dead. Not sure how you come back from that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)