Radio 4 Extra
#11
The problem that Josh's generation will have is exemplified above. He doesn't need it so he doesn't want to pay for it. Reasonable enough as long as he stays at the age of doing exactly what he does today for the rest of his life, but some of us can give a bit of life experience in that 40 years ago I wouldn't have dreamed of listening to Radio 3 for the classical choice, or Radio 4 for some random discussion that I hadn't even realised I would be interested in, or Radio 6 for the chance of finding some music that I'd never have considered searching for on iTunes.

There will come a time in the future where you realise that the BBC make fantastic dramas, watched Time over the past couple of nights, and brilliant coverage of topics and music that would never have made it onto my playlist, and your future self will thank you for not switching it off permanently.
Reply
#12
(10-20-2026, 03:37 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't refuse to pay - I simply don't have to based on my TV habits. Not everyone watches TV religiously. As sad as it might sound, I prefer playing video games, reading a book, or listening to a podcast over watching television. The only TV I actually watch is US sports (NBA & NFL, which I pay separate subscriptions for), Star Wars or The Simpsons on Disney+, and the occasional non-BBC show like Bake Off or The Great Pottery Throwdown. Whether people believe me or not is up to them - I don't really care! Big Grin

Under the current rules, I know I don't need a TV licence, so I don't pay for one. It's really nothing deeper than that.

As for de-funding the BBC? Meh, I don't particularly care either way. Since I consume so little TV, it's no skin off my nose whether the channel/broadcaster exists or not. 

When it comes to radio, it probably still has a small place, but surely its audience shrinks every year with the rise of podcasts, audiobooks, and music streaming apps. Radio as a medium is fading, and the closure of radio stations is inevitable unless they adapt to on-demand habits. The BBC itself, has produced a lot of original podcasts for BBC Sounds (I believe) rather than relying on radio broadcasts. Radio stations will have to evolve with the digital age or risk becoming completely obsolete.

If you watch ITV/Channel 4/5 live or stream it you need to pay the license fee I’m afraid, otherwise you’re breaking the law. Naughty naughty.

I don't. I watch on demand. I can't make this point clear enough - my TV habits dictate that I simply don't need a licence. I am fully aware of what I can and can't legally watch. It's not as if I'm refusing to pay while secretly binge watching BBC iPlayer all day or tuning into live TV! I barely consume television, and when I do, it's on demand services that don't require a licence.

I really struggle to comprehend why people find this hard to grasp - If I don't use a service, I don't pay for it. As I said in another Fred, if I never watched Netflix but kept paying their monthly fee anyway, everyone would tell me to cancel it. So why is this any different?

Baggy - tastes change, but everything you've listed is readily available on platforms like Spotify or Apple Music. They offer endless avenues to discover new music, artists, and genres tailored to your taste. I appreciate the point you're making, but everything you've described about radio can easily be experienced digitally. 

I don't dispute the quality of BBC programming, but most of their shows eventually end up on DVDs or other streaming platforms anyway. If the BBC as a broadcaster closed tomorrow, quality television wouldn't just vanish. Creative producers, actors, and crew members wouldn't suddenly cease to exist - they would take their talent to other networks, or streamers. Look at Top Gear moving to Amazon Prime and rebranding as The Grand Tour - it's a clear example of how talent and content simply transition to modern platforms. 

I accept that the BBC produces great, ad free television for those who want it. But the world wouldn't stop spinning if it ceased to exist.
Reply
#13
(10-20-2026, 01:24 PM)Old Stroller Wrote: Canned, along with BBC Scotland and BBC Three. I don’t dip into the latter channels much but Radio 4 Extra has been one of my go-to stations since its inception as Radio 7 many years ago. 

Cheers, FF and Josh and everyone else refusing to pay their way. Defund the BBC indeed.

I think that serves you right for seeing something called "Extra" and expecting it to last forever. 

Poorest sob story ever.
Reply
#14
<plays ‘Our Tune’ theme music>
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#15
The wife likes radio 4 extra, I find it a bit rubbish with lots of older material but it has it's place. Given it just plays archived material I am not sure how much is to be saved there.
I'm not convinced radio is dying medium either. Radio 4 is probably the best place for news and current affairs, especially since newsnight seems to have dumbed itself down.
The joy of live broadcast, especially with radio is just stumbling on something that really engages you on a subject you would never think was worthwhile listening to if you saw it advertised as a podcast. I ended up listening to a fascinating program about mud the other week whilst out in the car.
Oh and fuck Spotify with it's spoon feed you more of the same algorithm whilst paying the content creators next to nothing.
Reply
#16
(10-20-2026, 04:02 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 03:37 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't refuse to pay - I simply don't have to based on my TV habits. Not everyone watches TV religiously. As sad as it might sound, I prefer playing video games, reading a book, or listening to a podcast over watching television. The only TV I actually watch is US sports (NBA & NFL, which I pay separate subscriptions for), Star Wars or The Simpsons on Disney+, and the occasional non-BBC show like Bake Off or The Great Pottery Throwdown. Whether people believe me or not is up to them - I don't really care! Big Grin

Under the current rules, I know I don't need a TV licence, so I don't pay for one. It's really nothing deeper than that.

As for de-funding the BBC? Meh, I don't particularly care either way. Since I consume so little TV, it's no skin off my nose whether the channel/broadcaster exists or not. 

When it comes to radio, it probably still has a small place, but surely its audience shrinks every year with the rise of podcasts, audiobooks, and music streaming apps. Radio as a medium is fading, and the closure of radio stations is inevitable unless they adapt to on-demand habits. The BBC itself, has produced a lot of original podcasts for BBC Sounds (I believe) rather than relying on radio broadcasts. Radio stations will have to evolve with the digital age or risk becoming completely obsolete.

If you watch ITV/Channel 4/5 live or stream it you need to pay the license fee I’m afraid, otherwise you’re breaking the law. Naughty naughty.

I don't. I watch on demand. I can't make this point clear enough - my TV habits dictate that I simply don't need a licence. I am fully aware of what I can and can't legally watch. It's not as if I'm refusing to pay while secretly binge watching BBC iPlayer all day or tuning into live TV! I barely consume television, and when I do, it's on demand services that don't require a licence.

I really struggle to comprehend why people find this hard to grasp - If I don't use a service, I don't pay for it. As I said in another Fred, if I never watched Netflix but kept paying their monthly fee anyway, everyone would tell me to cancel it. So why is this any different?

Baggy - tastes change, but everything you've listed is readily available on platforms like Spotify or Apple Music. They offer endless avenues to discover new music, artists, and genres tailored to your taste. I appreciate the point you're making, but everything you've described about radio can easily be experienced digitally. 

I don't dispute the quality of BBC programming, but most of their shows eventually end up on DVDs or other streaming platforms anyway. If the BBC as a broadcaster closed tomorrow, quality television wouldn't just vanish. Creative producers, actors, and crew members wouldn't suddenly cease to exist - they would take their talent to other networks, or streamers. Look at Top Gear moving to Amazon Prime and rebranding as The Grand Tour - it's a clear example of how talent and content simply transition to modern platforms. 

I accept that the BBC produces great, ad free television for those who want it. But the world wouldn't stop spinning if it ceased to exist.

Those are the key words Josh, it probably won't take you down completely undiscovered paths - try listening to Radio 6 every now and again. That will give you new music or more pertinently it will give you different music, it doesn't have to be new to have not been heard before. 

The example of Grand Tour makes a point you probably didn't mean it to. There is no way that would have started off on Prime because there was no market for it, no saleability. It started on the BBC because they could take that risk without worrying what the return would be. Same goes for so much comedy from the past - BBC will allow new tastes to be sampled and defined.
Reply
#17
(10-20-2026, 05:16 PM)Oscillator Wrote: The wife likes radio 4 extra, I find it a bit rubbish with lots of older material but it has it's place. Given it just plays archived material I am not sure how much is to be saved there.
I'm not convinced radio is dying medium either. Radio 4 is probably the best place for news and current affairs, especially since newsnight seems to have dumbed itself down.
The joy of live broadcast, especially with radio is just stumbling on something that really engages you on a subject you would never think was worthwhile listening to if you saw it advertised as a podcast. I ended up listening to a fascinating program about mud the other week whilst out in the car.
Oh and fuck Spotify with it's spoon feed you more of the same algorithm whilst paying the content creators next to nothing.

Yes. I'm puzzled exactly how much is going to be saved by scrapping R4 Extra?  It only repeats old programmes anyway? I fear this is just a headline and the real cuts are to come in programme making.
Reply
#18
There's a BBC4 extra? You learn something new every day
Reply
#19
(10-20-2026, 04:02 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 03:37 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-20-2026, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't refuse to pay - I simply don't have to based on my TV habits. Not everyone watches TV religiously. As sad as it might sound, I prefer playing video games, reading a book, or listening to a podcast over watching television. The only TV I actually watch is US sports (NBA & NFL, which I pay separate subscriptions for), Star Wars or The Simpsons on Disney+, and the occasional non-BBC show like Bake Off or The Great Pottery Throwdown. Whether people believe me or not is up to them - I don't really care! Big Grin

Under the current rules, I know I don't need a TV licence, so I don't pay for one. It's really nothing deeper than that.

As for de-funding the BBC? Meh, I don't particularly care either way. Since I consume so little TV, it's no skin off my nose whether the channel/broadcaster exists or not. 

When it comes to radio, it probably still has a small place, but surely its audience shrinks every year with the rise of podcasts, audiobooks, and music streaming apps. Radio as a medium is fading, and the closure of radio stations is inevitable unless they adapt to on-demand habits. The BBC itself, has produced a lot of original podcasts for BBC Sounds (I believe) rather than relying on radio broadcasts. Radio stations will have to evolve with the digital age or risk becoming completely obsolete.

If you watch ITV/Channel 4/5 live or stream it you need to pay the license fee I’m afraid, otherwise you’re breaking the law. Naughty naughty.

I don't. I watch on demand. I can't make this point clear enough - my TV habits dictate that I simply don't need a licence. I am fully aware of what I can and can't legally watch. It's not as if I'm refusing to pay while secretly binge watching BBC iPlayer all day or tuning into live TV! I barely consume television, and when I do, it's on demand services that don't require a licence.

I really struggle to comprehend why people find this hard to grasp - If I don't use a service, I don't pay for it. As I said in another Fred, if I never watched Netflix but kept paying their monthly fee anyway, everyone would tell me to cancel it. So why is this any different?

Baggy - tastes change, but everything you've listed is readily available on platforms like Spotify or Apple Music. They offer endless avenues to discover new music, artists, and genres tailored to your taste. I appreciate the point you're making, but everything you've described about radio can easily be experienced digitally. 

I don't dispute the quality of BBC programming, but most of their shows eventually end up on DVDs or other streaming platforms anyway. If the BBC as a broadcaster closed tomorrow, quality television wouldn't just vanish. Creative producers, actors, and crew members wouldn't suddenly cease to exist - they would take their talent to other networks, or streamers. Look at Top Gear moving to Amazon Prime and rebranding as The Grand Tour - it's a clear example of how talent and content simply transition to modern platforms. 

I accept that the BBC produces great, ad free television for those who want it. But the world wouldn't stop spinning if it ceased to exist.

You seriously never watched any World Cup match?
Reply
#20
I listen to Radio 4, Radio 4 Extra , Radio WM and sometimes to Radio 2.

Last year BBC blocked anyone living abroad from using BBC sounds catch up, which I liked as I can't always listen live, so now I miss things I wanted to hear.

I fully understand that living abroad I don't pay for them so why should I get these free -- and I don't expect to.

The issue with the BBC is its lack of commercial nous. It acts like a public sector department.

I pay a subscription to read some UK papers/magazines etc as I'm interested in them. So, why doesn't the BBC offer a subscription for those of us living abroad?

It could be a radio-only subscrption to BBC sounds, for example.

However, I agree that they could save money on some of the services and ridiculous salaries (when there is really no competition for the "talent") - along with the bi-annual works outing to Glastonbury, which these days is just a parody.

The BBC was set up to provide services that no one else would do. Instead they seem to be trying to compete on soaps and appalling "reality" programmes. As a former journalist and editor, the news coverage has lost its impartiality and credibilty. I'm not saying anyone else is better but they need to look at their editorial standards - the Trump fiasco infuriated me because it just handed more ammunition to supporters of this odious man.

(Sorry everyone, if this seems to have turned into a rant.)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)