Matty Phillips
#21
62 goal contributions in 225 appearances, across 8 seasons, some of those seasons he wasn't always first choice and he played in some honking teams.

He had injuries in 3 of those seasons. But the reason people have such a negative memory of Matty is 2 of those seasons are ones we struggled and needed him most. 17/18 we got relegated and he was injured most his first season and then was in an out of fitness and the team the year we went down. He then was part of our "dark years" which always leaves a sour taste, before having his other spell out under Bruce where the fan base was polarised anyway.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#22
(10-09-2026, 05:16 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: 62 goal contributions in 225 appearances, across seasons, some of those seasons he wasn't always first choice and he played in some honking teams.

He had injuries in 3 of those seasons. But the reason people have such a negative memory of Matty is 2 of those seasons are ones we struggled and needed him most. 17/18 we got relegated and he was injured most his first season and then was in an out of fitness and the team the year we went down. He then was part of our "dark years" which always leaves a sour taste, before having his other spell out under Bruce where the fan base was polarised anyway.

Have you got the stats for how many games he played between December and February in the 8 years he was with us?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#23
(10-09-2026, 05:21 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-09-2026, 05:16 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: 62 goal contributions in 225 appearances, across seasons, some of those seasons he wasn't always first choice and he played in some honking teams.

He had injuries in 3 of those seasons. But the reason people have such a negative memory of Matty is 2 of those seasons are ones we struggled and needed him most. 17/18 we got relegated and he was injured most his first season and then was in an out of fitness and the team the year we went down. He then was part of our "dark years" which always leaves a sour taste, before having his other spell out under Bruce where the fan base was polarised anyway.

Have you got the stats for how many games he played between December and February in the 8 years he was with us?

   

There is little doubting Mattys body/Wife didn't like him playing around Xmas.  Big Grin
4 seasons out of 8 he was unavailable for some length of time over Winter.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#24
Not actually as bad as my memory recalls it tbf
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#25
(10-09-2026, 05:50 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Not actually as bad as my memory recalls it tbf

I think the issue was that when he was first choice and we relied on him his body would break down when he played too much football. The seasons he was in and out of the team he tended to get nursed through. 

Again for the 4/5 million we spent on him as a prem team, we've had far worse.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#26
Was a good player for us, if it wasn't for his hamstring tear every Xmas time he could have been very good.
Reply
#27
A lot of natural ability combined with power, strength and speed.

Super fragile body and confidence however.

At his best he was amazing to watch, but his best wasn't shown that often and was often a very average player for us with periods of looking fantastic, before injury struck again.
Reply
#28
(10-09-2026, 07:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: A lot of natural ability combined with power, strength and speed.

Super fragile body and confidence however.

At his best he was amazing to watch, but his best wasn't shown that often and was often a very average player for us with periods of looking fantastic, before injury struck again.

Pretty perfectly summed up. .
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)