Citeh Guilty
Surely they get same punishment as befell Leeds City?
Reply
(09-29-2026, 05:03 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: Surely this thread should be titled 'Citeh Guilteh', eh?

You’re twisting my melons, man.
Reply
It isn't exaggeration to state that the integrity of the game hangs on this punishment. Yes, the likes of Chelsea and others have already pushed it to breaking point, but as Josh said earlier in the thread, this wasn't clever accounting, or using loopholes. It was just old fashioned, brazen cheating. Falsifying accounts (could this not result in a criminal fraud case?), lying to auditors and regulators, hiding payments, inflating sponsorship deals and then having no remorse or repentence for their crimes, blocking the investigation whenever they could, actually forcing witnesses to lying during the investigation. The punishment should be no less than:

The enforced selling of the team. If this happens, then the punishments below can be eased somewhat, otherwise no-one will buy them.
Expulsion from the PL and no admittance to the EFL
All titles and cup wins stripped (and not awarding them to runners up, in the league at least. Cup comps could be seen differently)
Transfer embargo for at least 5 years, if not longer, including any and all youth players.
A fine of at least all of the prize money they received, preferably more, to be split and paid to all teams in the football league. If City can cheat their way around FFP rules, then the clubs actually suffering for complying/facing the consequences of not complying should receive some help to ease any problems they may have.
Compensation for the clubs directly affected by City's cheating - eg PL position payments. Tie this in to the punishment and we may save the process dragging on even longer.

Anything less than that isn't enough.
Reply
Good post AB. I’m not even sure they should be allowed in the conference. They should have to start again from the bottom of the pyramid under new ownership
Raw Sausage
Reply
https://x.com/matchdayben/status/2104996222536741240

This has tickled me more than it should, FFS.
Reply
I'm a bit late to the table on this.
However, I can't believe that only Man City have been doing this.

What about Villa? They had a sudden fire sale this summer. 
Was that to try and keep under the radar?
Like Chelsea they grossly exaggerated the value of their women's team.

No doubt other creative methods havee been used by them and others.

It would be a beautiful world where the jammy lot were automatically relegated.
Reply
(09-30-2026, 05:49 AM)Albionmad Wrote: I'm a bit late to the table on this.
However, I can't believe that only Man City have been doing this.

What about Villa? They had a sudden fire sale this summer. 
Was that to try and keep under the radar?
Like Chelsea they grossly exaggerated the value of their women's team.

No doubt other creative methods havee been used by them and others.

It would be a beautiful world where the jammy lot were automatically relegated.

The Villa 4 would be up in arms over this, frothing down their Warwickshire shirts in anger.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
What is overlooked in all this is the way the rules are constructed completely to ensure Liverpool, United and Arsenal can dominate the game.
In pre Prem days it was possible for clubs like us to challenge for the title.
Now we have an imbalance where a player can be bough for £150m, which was considered more than the complete valuation of our club when we were bought a couple of years ago.
For all the hype about Brentford, Brighton, Bournemouth etc, the chances of winning anything is still remote, bar one of these pointless European competitions where they play teams that we’ve never heard of from Romania and Albania for the most part.
Meanwhile the glory clubs continue their tradition with Real Madrid, Bayern, Barca etc whilst also playing Milan, Porto, Ajax etc.
The whole rotten system needs tearing up.
I personally hope it destroys the Prem.
I know my dreams are delusional in the extreme.
Reply
(09-30-2026, 05:49 AM)Albionmad Wrote: I'm a bit late to the table on this.
However, I can't believe that only Man City have been doing this.

What about Villa? They had a sudden fire sale this summer. 
Was that to try and keep under the radar?
Like Chelsea they grossly exaggerated the value of their women's team.

No doubt other creative methods havee been used by them and others.

It would be a beautiful world where the jammy lot were automatically relegated.

I wouldn't get against other teams having a go, however, I suspect Seals n Mags saw what was coming and pulled back. Hence their fire sales. Mags in particular could've put spunked City if they'd used the same non-rules, but they didn't. One can only assume they got wind if things and pulled back?

(09-30-2026, 06:40 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: What is overlooked in all this is the way the rules are constructed completely to ensure Liverpool, United and Arsenal can dominate the game.
In pre Prem days it was possible for clubs like us to challenge for the title.
Now we have an imbalance where a player can be bough for £150m, which was considered more than the complete valuation of our club when we were bought a couple of years ago.
For all the hype about Brentford, Brighton, Bournemouth etc, the chances of winning anything is still remote, bar one of these pointless European competitions where they play teams that we’ve never heard of from Romania and Albania for the most part.
Meanwhile the glory clubs continue their tradition with Real Madrid, Bayern, Barca etc whilst also playing Milan, Porto, Ajax etc.
The whole rotten system needs tearing up.
I personally hope it destroys the Prem.
I know my dreams are delusional in the extreme.

I don't think it does overlook it, pretty much every fan outside the bent 6 has been beating this drum for 20 years.
Reply
(09-30-2026, 05:49 AM)Albionmad Wrote: I'm a bit late to the table on this.
However, I can't believe that only Man City have been doing this.

What about Villa? They had a sudden fire sale this summer. 
Was that to try and keep under the radar?
Like Chelsea they grossly exaggerated the value of their women's team.


No doubt other creative methods have been used by them and others.

It would be a beautiful world where the jammy lot were automatically relegated.

I referred to this in my post. Chelsea and Villa have flown close to the sun with their methods but I think there is a crucial difference. They have at least seemingly made an effort to act within the rules, using loopholes such as the sale of the Women's team and real estate, and other "creative methods" like you say. Another key difference is that Chelsea's new owners held their hands up and said "look what we found that the previous owners did, our bad" and Villa through selling all their players have effectively done the same. Fair to question the sincerity of this, but at face value they've admitted fault. Newcastle is also another team that could have followed the exact same path that City did, given their state ownership, yet they've sold players as and when needed, to the detriment of their team.

Man City persistently, maliciously cheated by lying and hiding payments, paying people through other companies/contracts etc., and still to this very day, they claim there is "an extensive body of irrefutable evidence" showing they're innocent. The intention and hubris of them is very different.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: