Citeh Guilty
(09-29-2026, 10:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 08:09 AM)MGalea Wrote: Maybe a bit Foster to Watford - but some talk of prize money compensation for everyone.

The chargers line up nicely with our long stint in the Prem.... could be a nice £7m for us.

What a colossal waste of time that would be.

Yes. Just strengthens everyone and it'll all end up in the pockets of players and agents. I'd like to see the titles voided though, but not given to runners up. Is that possible?
Reply
(09-29-2026, 10:14 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 10:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 08:09 AM)MGalea Wrote: Maybe a bit Foster to Watford - but some talk of prize money compensation for everyone.

The chargers line up nicely with our long stint in the Prem.... could be a nice £7m for us.

What a colossal waste of time that would be.

Yes. Just strengthens everyone and it'll all end up in the pockets of players and agents. I'd like to see the titles voided though, but not given to runners up. Is that possible?

We'd get significantly more than most of the teams currently in the Championship as we were in the league during the period more than most. 

Wrexham would get fuck all for example.
Reply
I’d sooner see the outcome focused on sporting integrity and them fully removed from professional football to start again. They took the piss for over a decade. Anything less is just a giant fudge.
Raw Sausage
Reply
I know I’m a minority on this and what Man City have done is totally wrong and deserve to be punished with a massive points deduction over a few years and a massive fine.
But why should the players be blamed and have titles and cup wins taken of them. They weren’t the ones inthe background doing the cheating it was the owners , accountants and the cheating scum bags in the background. To be honest they should ban the owners from taking part in anything to do with football and kick them out I know this can’t and won’t happen but should.
As for the players they are bought in to play football and how they were bought in is no business of there’s and the did what they were bought in to do. As for players and clubs saying they should lose there titles it’s just sour grapes that they weren’t good enough to win those titles.
I’m not trying to be controversial but I just cannot see why players should be penalised for doing what they’re bought to do.
Reply
(09-29-2026, 09:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 08:31 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 08:09 AM)MGalea Wrote: Maybe a bit Foster to Watford - but some talk of prize money compensation for everyone.

The chargers line up nicely with our long stint in the Prem.... could be a nice £7m for us.

I made it 9 seasons at £3m a place? Shame we never got relegated from 18th position really

I don't think it was £3m until the last one or two seasons... more like £700k a place.  I think I had it as 8 seasons 7 x 700k + 1 x £3m

Fair points.  I'll wait for the finance experts to resolve this as I can't even be arsed to ask ChatGPT!
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(09-29-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: I know I’m a minority on this and what Man City have done is totally wrong and deserve to be punished with a massive points deduction over a few years and a massive fine.
But why should the players be blamed and have titles and cup wins taken of them. They weren’t the ones inthe background doing the cheating it was the owners , accountants and the cheating scum bags in the background. To be honest they should ban the owners from taking part in anything to do with football and kick them out I know this can’t and won’t happen but should.
As for the players they are bought in to play football and how they were bought in is no business of there’s and the did what they were bought in to do. As for players and clubs saying they should lose there titles it’s just sour grapes that they weren’t good enough to win those titles.
I’m not trying to be controversial but I just cannot see why players should be penalised for doing what they’re bought to do.

But they've earned a ton of money in a team where they may not have been employed otherwise if the club had stuck to the rules. There are just so many transgressions that I'm with GD, they should pretty much just have to start from scratch. Appeals by other clubs will just delay the whole thing.
Reply
(09-29-2026, 10:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: I know I’m a minority on this and what Man City have done is totally wrong and deserve to be punished with a massive points deduction over a few years and a massive fine.
But why should the players be blamed and have titles and cup wins taken of them. They weren’t the ones inthe background doing the cheating it was the owners , accountants and the cheating scum bags in the background. To be honest they should ban the owners from taking part in anything to do with football and kick them out I know this can’t and won’t happen but should.
As for the players they are bought in to play football and how they were bought in is no business of there’s and the did what they were bought in to do. As for players and clubs saying they should lose there titles it’s just sour grapes that they weren’t good enough to win those titles.
I’m not trying to be controversial but I just cannot see why players should be penalised for doing what they’re bought to do.

But they've earned a ton of money in a team where they may not have been employed otherwise if the club had stuck to the rules. There are just so many transgressions that I'm with GD, they should pretty much just have to start from scratch. Appeals by other clubs will just delay the whole thing.

But that is not their fault, they just play football and couldn’t care less about boardroom and financial stuff.
Reply
(09-29-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: I know I’m a minority on this and what Man City have done is totally wrong and deserve to be punished with a massive points deduction over a few years and a massive fine.
But why should the players be blamed and have titles and cup wins taken of them. They weren’t the ones inthe background doing the cheating it was the owners , accountants and the cheating scum bags in the background. To be honest they should ban the owners from taking part in anything to do with football and kick them out I know this can’t and won’t happen but should.
As for the players they are bought in to play football and how they were bought in is no business of there’s and the did what they were bought in to do. As for players and clubs saying they should lose there titles it’s just sour grapes that they weren’t good enough to win those titles.
I’m not trying to be controversial but I just cannot see why players should be penalised for doing what they’re bought to do.

The management and some players were being paid by two contracts, the official declared contract and another contract for the extra pay. The players and agents would have know about this and would have been a driver for them to sign. If these top players didn’t get the money they would have gone elsewhere and city would have been weaker and may not have won anything. This would have a knock on effect year after year.
Reply
(09-29-2026, 10:47 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 10:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: I know I’m a minority on this and what Man City have done is totally wrong and deserve to be punished with a massive points deduction over a few years and a massive fine.
But why should the players be blamed and have titles and cup wins taken of them. They weren’t the ones inthe background doing the cheating it was the owners , accountants and the cheating scum bags in the background. To be honest they should ban the owners from taking part in anything to do with football and kick them out I know this can’t and won’t happen but should.
As for the players they are bought in to play football and how they were bought in is no business of there’s and the did what they were bought in to do. As for players and clubs saying they should lose there titles it’s just sour grapes that they weren’t good enough to win those titles.
I’m not trying to be controversial but I just cannot see why players should be penalised for doing what they’re bought to do.

But they've earned a ton of money in a team where they may not have been employed otherwise if the club had stuck to the rules. There are just so many transgressions that I'm with GD, they should pretty much just have to start from scratch. Appeals by other clubs will just delay the whole thing.

But that is not their fault, they just play football and couldn’t care less about boardroom and financial stuff.
Sorry but that is naive in the extreme. 
In nearly every situation their primary concern is ''what's the money like''.
Reply
Can't see too many players going to Manc for the weather
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)