One or two up top?
#31
Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#32
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

I think it is perhaps in this regard worse than last season. Chance creation was OK last season.

The irony is we do have players who can take chances this season, unlike last season where we were comfortably under performed on xg.

I would ask who  do you think will score our goals this season. When you've worked that out you want to make sure they're on the pitch. For me Morgan, Price and Heggebo are the players I think are capable of getting into double figures this season. Whenever possible I would want them on the pitch.

There are a few players who might also be capable of reaching that total, but we have not evidence to come to any conclusion.

But there are signs we are still a bit goal shy, after a bright start.
Reply
#33
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

My suggestion of adding Rabby to the midfield was to give us more bodies where we were being over-run by Wolves. Most of the time we don't need Diakite and Molumby, so I'd prefer Collyer to replace Molumby ahead of Rabby. That's if Collyer turns out to be as good as Mozza thinks. Longer term, Nzingoula could play pretty much anywhere and I guess his best position will evolve in time.

Whitwell and Price weren't finding any space so there was no "out ball" for our beleaguered midfield. Heggebo has been rightly criticised, but JJ hardly had a touch in the first 30 mins as I recall. FHM might have been better as a 10 in the circumstances.

I'm not on board with the spacegoating of Townsend, his only fault is not being as good as Styles. Pereira needs to play so we can get the balance back with Styles in his best position. Funny how we're now missing Galves. Posters were screaming for him to make way for Pereira. Be careful what you wish for - - -  Big Grin
Reply
#34
(11-09-2025, 03:57 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-16-2025, 08:00 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: There has been some really good discussions the last couple of days about what is causing our lack of goals; Tactics? Personnel? Individuals? Game Management? Lets see what our stats suggest. 


Team Statistics: 

Possession:

Progressive Passes - 204 (3rd) (11th)
Progressive Carries - 94 (2nd) (5th)

Total passes attempted - 2681 (1st) (1st)
Total passes completed % - 82.9 (1st) (1st)

Short passes attempted - 1007 (2nd) (3rd)
* Completed % - 92.7 (1st) (2nd)

Medium passes attempted - 1200 (1st) (2nd)
* Completed % - 88.1 (1st) (3rd)

Long passes attempted - 389 (13th) (4th)
* Completed % - 53.9 (3rd) (3rd)

Key Passes (assisted shot) - 58 (2nd) (5th)
Passes into the final third - 172 (3rd) (7th)
Passes into the penalty area - 44 (5th) (19th)
Crosses into penalty area - 14 (8th) (11th)
Take ons - 72 (12th) (5th)

Total touches - 3227 (1st) (1st)
* Defensive penalty area - 316 (11th) (7th)
* Defensive third - 1104 (3rd) (1st)
* Midfield third - 1449 (1st) (2nd)
* Attacking third - 714 (9th) (11th)
* Attacking penalty area - 114 (9th) (12th)

Total Carries - 1881 (1st) (2nd)
* Into the final third - 73 (2nd) (3rd)
* Into attacking penalty area - 20 (8th) (10th)

Attacking:

Shot creating actions - 137 (4th) (5th)
* Live pass - 101 (3rd) (8th)
* Dead ball - 15th (=2nd) (6th)
* Foul drawn - 10 (=3rd) (10th)
* Take ons - 3 (22nd) (9th)
* Shot - 7 (10th) (4th)
* Defensive action - 1 (Joint second lowest) (11th)

Shots - 73 (=4th) (8th)
* On target % - 26 (14th) (20th)

xG - 5.5 (17th) (20th)

Seen some debate about stats on t'other freds. So thought I would update this. red indicates a worsening of the metric, yellow for no change, green for an improvement in the numbers.

Grim reading, frankly.

The stats suggest we've started going much more direct, but still leave our players isolated and we are relying on them to do something special, which is how it has felt.

So rather than us changing the balance of the team to improve the attacking instinct of the players in the team picking the ball up in the final third, when we were doing pretty well getting it there regularly, we've dropped off in terms of our progressive play into the final third, but we haven't improved the quality up there either.

The result? Less shots, less shots on target and worryingly even fewer high quality chances, fewer goals and less hope.

This was my post from last year under Mason. There are some really worrying parallels. Except we've gone from more direct to more short passing, so the opposite in terms of our approach.

I just hope Chesh doesn't shout at me for mentioning patterns *winky face thing*
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#35
I think it's worth giving Tunde a go on the left given he's left footed and can have Price behind the #9 to run in (and maybe someone else too who is so inclined).
Reply
#36
(09-22-2026, 10:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

I think it is perhaps in this regard worse than last season. Chance creation was OK last season.

The irony is we do have players who can take chances this season, unlike last season where we were comfortably under performed on xg.

I would ask who  do you think will score our goals this season. When you've worked that out you want to make sure they're on the pitch. For me Morgan, Price and Heggebo are the players I think are capable of getting into double figures this season. Whenever possible I would want them on the pitch.

There are a few players who might also be capable of reaching that total, but we have not evidence to come to any conclusion.

But there are signs we are still a bit goal shy, after a bright start.

Our chance creation improved under Mozza (and Ramsay - But I have to whisper that). But at this time last year it was about as bad. Last year was had MJ, Heggebo and Price at that time. We have JJ, Heggebo and Price now. It's worrying that we have left ourselves so short in those areas and was why I was disappointed from the outset with the Tunde signing and the lack of another forward/wide player on deadline day. 

But I think that's even more reason to get that balance right across the midfield and defensive lines. I would have no problem us playing 5, but it's the balance of those 5 and then the defence too.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#37
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

Personally, I don't see Collyer as just a holder, I'm expecting his vision and ability on the ball will transform a central midfield two that quite frankly can't play incisive forward passes, and a through ball when Price and Morgan make those superb runs into one that can. Simple as that really.
Reply
#38
(09-22-2026, 12:27 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

Personally, I don't see Collyer as just a holder, I'm expecting his vision and ability on the ball will transform a central midfield two that quite frankly can't play incisive forward passes, and a through ball when Price and Morgan make those superb runs into one that can. Simple as that really.

This. In no way is Collyer a better than like for like replacement of Molumby as seems to have been stated before. The problem with forwards making good runs is if they constantly fail to get the ball delivered then they tend to stop making them.
Reply
#39
I think you’ve all been having dreams about what Toby Collyer can do. I’ve not seen anything to suggest he does anything other than pass the ball 5 yards sideways relatively slowly, most of the time accurately.
Reply
#40
(09-22-2026, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:
(09-22-2026, 12:27 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-22-2026, 10:32 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Genuine question for those suggesting an extra midfielder as well as 2 holders.

Where do we create from?

We are back to this time last year where we are having loads of the ball already (2nd) with the players in the team. We are having lots of that possession in the final third (8th). But we have hardly any chances (22nd), hardly any crosses (23rd), hardly any touches in the box (16th).

We need more attacking players in team. We are missing Galvez' attacking running and passing and in the absence of that threat we need it to come from elsewhere.

Personally, I don't see Collyer as just a holder, I'm expecting his vision and ability on the ball will transform a central midfield two that quite frankly can't play incisive forward passes, and a through ball when Price and Morgan make those superb runs into one that can. Simple as that really.

This. In no way is Collyer a better than like for like replacement of Molumby as seems to have been stated before. The problem with forwards making good runs is if they constantly fail to get the ball delivered then they tend to stop making them.

Not what I was saying. He's a Molumby upgrade because he has more to his game - if he's as good as we want to believe.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: