HMRC
#11
Just over a month ago, I added this as part of a post...

" Incidentally, I owe HMRC a relatively small amount arising from a fixed bond maturing during the 2024/25 tax year, which took me over the £1,000 allowance. I waited, and waited, for the assessment and coding change to arrive until eventually, in December 2025, I called them (because, notwithstanding the system, the ultimate responsibility remains with me). I was assured that I owed no tax as the account in question was closed: I tried multiple times to explain that the account had matured with interest, but was informed - also multiple times - that my file had been assessed and no tax was due. I have a record of the date, time and name of HMRC employee (who has probably already left). Did make me wonder though."

We're now into September and the same situation is being repeated. Some online sites are now suggesting that HMRC are so far behind that recovery via an adjusted tax code is becoming unworkable and that assessments will be issued with a settlement date specified. We'll see: that would be fine for me, maybe less so for others.

In reality I feel another phone conversation is looming.
Reply
#12
(09-14-2026, 07:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 8.30AM and already tearing my head out with HMRC...

Received a penalty for a late assessment filing which came as a surprise to me given I don't need to file one and it's been accruing interest as the letter was sent out over 2 months ago with a 30 day appeal window, but went via Saudi Arabia (no idea how or why but it has Riyadh franking on the envelope) so only reached me Saturday!

It's taken 3 attempts this morning to get through the fucking phone system - first time they tell me to go via the digital assistant and hang up, only for the digital assistant to tell me to phone them, second time needing to verfiy my identity only for my passport to be rejected by the app, and now third time I'm left shouting at a system that refuses to accept my Spanish postcode saying it's not a known format.

This is a sheer battle of wills now.

There is new law from May that requires all advisers not registered previously under an Agent Services Account to be registered under the mandatory tax adviser scheme (having to be passed "fit and proper").  For me, needing to be so registered by August, was a painful, Kafkaesque process - the verification via passport made me nearly weep!  I made it eventually, got my registration number and needed a few pints and a bottle of scotch to relax!!!

Anyroad, I had to meet with a client's gaffers and HMRC last week.  After introductions, I asked if the HMRC officers wished to note my agent registration number.  "What's that?", they asked.....
Reply
#13
(09-14-2026, 09:12 AM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 07:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 8.30AM and already tearing my head out with HMRC...

Received a penalty for a late assessment filing which came as a surprise to me given I don't need to file one and it's been accruing interest as the letter was sent out over 2 months ago with a 30 day appeal window, but went via Saudi Arabia (no idea how or why but it has Riyadh franking on the envelope) so only reached me Saturday!

It's taken 3 attempts this morning to get through the fucking phone system - first time they tell me to go via the digital assistant and hang up, only for the digital assistant to tell me to phone them, second time needing to verfiy my identity only for my passport to be rejected by the app, and now third time I'm left shouting at a system that refuses to accept my Spanish postcode saying it's not a known format.

This is a sheer battle of wills now.

There is new law from May that requires all advisers not registered previously under an Agent Services Account to be registered under the mandatory tax adviser scheme (having to be passed "fit and proper").  For me, needing to be so registered by August, was a painful, Kafkaesque process - the verification via passport made me nearly weep!  I made it eventually, got my registration number and needed a few pints and a bottle of scotch to relax!!!

Anyroad, I had to meet with a client's gaffers and HMRC last week.  After introductions, I asked if the HMRC officers wished to note my agent registration number.  "What's that?", they asked.....

I do wonder if so many people would be in such a rush to nationalise things if they had to deal with HMRC regularly.
Reply
#14
(09-14-2026, 09:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 09:12 AM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 07:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 8.30AM and already tearing my head out with HMRC...

Received a penalty for a late assessment filing which came as a surprise to me given I don't need to file one and it's been accruing interest as the letter was sent out over 2 months ago with a 30 day appeal window, but went via Saudi Arabia (no idea how or why but it has Riyadh franking on the envelope) so only reached me Saturday!

It's taken 3 attempts this morning to get through the fucking phone system - first time they tell me to go via the digital assistant and hang up, only for the digital assistant to tell me to phone them, second time needing to verfiy my identity only for my passport to be rejected by the app, and now third time I'm left shouting at a system that refuses to accept my Spanish postcode saying it's not a known format.

This is a sheer battle of wills now.

There is new law from May that requires all advisers not registered previously under an Agent Services Account to be registered under the mandatory tax adviser scheme (having to be passed "fit and proper").  For me, needing to be so registered by August, was a painful, Kafkaesque process - the verification via passport made me nearly weep!  I made it eventually, got my registration number and needed a few pints and a bottle of scotch to relax!!!

Anyroad, I had to meet with a client's gaffers and HMRC last week.  After introductions, I asked if the HMRC officers wished to note my agent registration number.  "What's that?", they asked.....

I do wonder if so many people would be in such a rush to nationalise things if they had to deal with HMRC regularly.
To be fair, there are private businesses one has to deal with that make you pull your hair out!  HMRC makes you pull your beard out, though.
Reply
#15
(09-14-2026, 09:37 AM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 09:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 09:12 AM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(09-14-2026, 07:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 8.30AM and already tearing my head out with HMRC...

Received a penalty for a late assessment filing which came as a surprise to me given I don't need to file one and it's been accruing interest as the letter was sent out over 2 months ago with a 30 day appeal window, but went via Saudi Arabia (no idea how or why but it has Riyadh franking on the envelope) so only reached me Saturday!

It's taken 3 attempts this morning to get through the fucking phone system - first time they tell me to go via the digital assistant and hang up, only for the digital assistant to tell me to phone them, second time needing to verfiy my identity only for my passport to be rejected by the app, and now third time I'm left shouting at a system that refuses to accept my Spanish postcode saying it's not a known format.

This is a sheer battle of wills now.

There is new law from May that requires all advisers not registered previously under an Agent Services Account to be registered under the mandatory tax adviser scheme (having to be passed "fit and proper").  For me, needing to be so registered by August, was a painful, Kafkaesque process - the verification via passport made me nearly weep!  I made it eventually, got my registration number and needed a few pints and a bottle of scotch to relax!!!

Anyroad, I had to meet with a client's gaffers and HMRC last week.  After introductions, I asked if the HMRC officers wished to note my agent registration number.  "What's that?", they asked.....

I do wonder if so many people would be in such a rush to nationalise things if they had to deal with HMRC regularly.
To be fair, there are private businesses one has to deal with that make you pull your hair out!  HMRC makes you pull your beard out, though.

Yes, and they also tend to be the monopolistic type that don't have to worry too much about customer service.
Reply
#16
My lad works for HMRC, mainly dealing with business men who 'accidentally forgot to pay' or whose accountant 'mistakenly thought he'd sorted it'. As far as I am aware, the lad is polite and courteous with callers.
However, he gets frustrated as HMRC can spend a lot of money on new furniture, while still using a telephone system from 30 years ago, which often cuts out, and are still using the same system that caused the Post Office scandal.
Reply
#17
(09-18-2026, 09:38 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: My lad works for HMRC, mainly dealing with business men who  'accidentally forgot to pay' or whose accountant 'mistakenly thought he'd sorted it'. As far as I am aware, the lad is polite and courteous with callers.
However, he gets frustrated as HMRC can spend a lot of money on new furniture, while still using a telephone system from 30 years ago, which often cuts out, and are still using the same system that caused the Post Office scandal.
There are civil penalty regimes for such matters and the sort of excuses like the above don't wash.  I have no problem with HMRC acting efficiently to "enhance" compliance and of course HMRC should enforce debts accrued (esp before matters get out of hand).

The problem is that in my experience (and that of most professional practitioners I work with in other taxes and in committees I sit on) is that HMRC is almost invariably inept, badly (if ever) supervised, ignorant of the law, incompetent, unaccountable, unmotivated, complacent, and its processes - to use an adjective commonly used by exasperated clients - Kafkaesque.  I constantly have to get a resolution to the machinations of what is a "Blob".  

I was posted to HMCE HQ Policy in August 1988.  I left end of 1997 just before I was 40 and have been a consultant since.  I didn't leave for better money.  A sane, reasonably competent individual can only stand so much and I could (and still can) do more on the outside than from the inside.  It was bad enough at the time I left but at least some officials had some education and intelligence, but were almost invariably lazy and worked the system.  The standard I see now would be shocking if HMRC's antics hadn't long ceased to shock me.  This isn't a blowhard whinge: I say this to relevant senior officials now face to face (and emails) to try to shame them and said so to (Sir) Jim Harra as then boss of HMRC on several occasions. (I have also on a few rare occasions sent letters of commendation to senior staff to note where their officers have actually provided good service.  In one case, astonishingly good and unexpected service, way beyond their pay grade.  But rare as hens' teeth.)

One thing that might improve matters is if HMRC staff were subject to the same level of penalty for delays and errors that their "customers" face.  Based on the "wrongdoing" penalties of schedule 24 to FA 2007 and schedule 41 to FA 2008, say 100% of a month's pay as a penalty, mitigatable according to behaviours and reasonable excuse and subject to appeal at their own cost.  A lot of us keep mooting such "sauce for the goose" equality of arms.  Not that it will happen but I WOULD LOVE IT if it was even flown as a kite by Politicians.  HMRC has it far too easy.  The fuggers should JUMP!

Grrrrrr
Reply
#18
I agree with Hudds.

Local authority planners should also be surcharged for delaying applications beyond terms.
Reply
#19
Thankfully, by the third call I reached an advisor that was at least helpful.

I had informed them I'm an non-resident landlord to start from April 2025 in line with 25/26 tax year but for whatever reason they'd decided I needed an SA for 24/25. I informed them there were 2 months rental income that fell into 24/25, but this was about 1,500 due to move in dates, and there were multiple allowable expenses and mortgage relief that brought the overall tax down to 100 quid roughly.

At first they still pushed for me to complete an SA and declare the income for appropriate tax which seemed crazy given the low amount. I said I could do it, but their own regulations say I am below both the income threshold, the profit threshold and close enough to the tax threshold where it'll cost them more to administer it than collect it, and that I am sure I can get an accoutant to charge me exactly the amount of tax due as a cost to process it meaning my bill will be zero.

Eventually they agreed to waive the fine and put I don't need to pay anything which at least shows some common sense, but I shudder to think how much has been spent in resources from their side get to that outcome. It must have taken 45 minutes on the phone between the agent and myself, her going off to speak to a supervisor, and all the ancillary costs of writing to me etc.

Multiply that up to the no doubt thousands of people going through similar, all because of an avoidable mistake their side and it must be costing tens of millions. The sooner AI does it all, the better Big Grin

Oh, one positive was this reminded me I didn't make a claim on my 24/25 PAYE tax where they'd wrongly charged me for a company car I did not have access to for several months, so at least there's a few hundred quid rebate coming my way as compensation for this Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)