Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(09-11-2026, 07:23 PM)Jerry Wrote: The law was badly written, the checks and balances were not in place, and it allowed the government to expand the scope. Write a better law and put it to the vote. A bad law is worse than no law at all.
This is a good post, and a great point.
I accept the need for any law to be rightly guarded and avoid loopholes by unscrupulous relatives. But a law needs to exist that gives an individual the option to die on their terms when they can no longer lead a dignified pain free life. A balance needs to be struck.
Far too many people are living their last days, months, even years, in excruciating pain with no freedom, individuality or dignity. Simply put people wouldn't treat animals the way we do people at the end of their lives.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
Everyone has a story to tell about this. People who died ‘a good death’, people who didn’t. The good thing with this approach is- and the approach taken by MPs - is they listen to genuinely emotive stories about sad/great deaths. Where they are severely wrong is that they apply that storytelling - ultimately the lowest form of acceptable scientific evidence - to huge, highly variable populations.
If nothing else, all of us who have experienced more than one death will know that all deaths are all different. Those differences are not just in clinical presentation but the beliefs of the loved one, their family, their religion (I’m a flag waving agnostic yet still believe in religious freedom at death).
And within that confusing messiness there is only individuality that rises above all else. Legislating in black and white was risky, robbing people of choice was an unsophisticated response - one which strengthens my view that not all decisions should be democratic
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
A fucking disgrace Imo.
1 they voted it down
2 it had a last 6 months of your life time limit
I want to go when I want to go. It should be up to me. We treat cats and dogs better.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(09-11-2026, 07:29 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: (09-11-2026, 07:23 PM)Jerry Wrote: The law was badly written, the checks and balances were not in place, and it allowed the government to expand the scope. Write a better law and put it to the vote. A bad law is worse than no law at all.
This is a good post, and a great point.
I accept the need for any law to be rightly guarded and avoid loopholes by unscrupulous relatives. But a law needs to exist that gives an individual the option to die on their terms when they can no longer lead a dignified pain free life. A balance needs to be struck.
Far too many people are living their last days, months, even years, in excruciating pain with no freedom, individuality or dignity. Simply put people wouldn't treat animals the way we do people at the end of their lives.
Being cynical, do you think it was deliberately badly written? This of course means MPs can avoid making a decision, something they are very good at.
Seems to be a lot of abstentions which is annoying
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I doubt that's the case, I sincerely hope MPs are genuine in their writing of bills. That being said, nothing would surprise me with politicians.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
As ever, the reason for the collapse of the legislation is less simple than the blow hards would have you believe.
I asked ChatGPT to look at the Commons voting on the assisted dying bill, compare the first successful vote with the later failed vote on essentially the same legislation, and then look at some of the better commentary around it.
Short answer:
It doesn’t really look as though Parliament suddenly turned against assisted dying.
The big change was that a lot of MPs who had previously voted for the bill simply didn’t vote for it the second time. The No vote barely increased at all — in fact it actually fell slightly.
At the June 2025 Third Reading the vote was:
314 Yes / 291 No
On 11 September 2026 it was:
270 Yes / 286 No
So Yes lost 44 votes, while No lost 5.
That strongly suggests the bill was defeated mainly because its previous coalition of supporters fractured — through abstentions/absences and a relatively small number of actual conversions from Yes to No.
Long answer:
There seems to have been a gradual erosion of support rather than a sudden reversal.
The original Second Reading in November 2024 passed 330–275.
By Third Reading in June 2025, after months of detailed scrutiny, that had narrowed to 314–291.
Then yesterday it fell again to 270–286.
So the direction of travel had been there for quite a while.
What seems to have happened is that some MPs who support assisted dying in principle became increasingly uncomfortable with this particular bill, its safeguards and how it would work in practice.
That distinction matters. An MP can quite reasonably say:
“I support the principle of assisted dying, but I’m not convinced this legislation is safe or workable enough.”
There were continuing concerns around coercion, mental capacity, psychiatric assessment, prognosis, pressure on vulnerable people, availability of palliative care and the ability of already stretched services to operate the system properly.
There was also a very important procedural issue this time.
The new bill was deliberately brought back in essentially the same form as the previous one, partly so supporters could potentially use the Parliament Acts if the House of Lords blocked it again.
That meant supporters were reluctant to amend it.
So although technically MPs were voting at Second Reading, it wasn’t really the normal situation where an MP can think:
“I support the principle, I’ll vote Yes now and we can fix the problems later.”
For some wavering MPs it was much closer to:
“Are you prepared to back this exact version again, potentially with very little prospect of changing it?”
That probably made abstention much easier.
The political atmosphere had changed as well.
The government still treated it as a free vote, but Andy Burnham did not personally endorse the bill and abstained, arguing that palliative care and social care needed improving first.
That doesn’t amount to the government whipping against assisted dying, but it probably gave Labour MPs who had doubts a lot more political space to sit it out.
And this is perhaps the most interesting bit:
The evidence doesn’t suggest that dozens of MPs actively moved from Yes to No.
Among Labour MPs, for example, only a handful of previous Yes voters actually switched to No. Far more simply abstained or were absent.
So I think the fairest summary is:
The Commons did not suddenly become anti-assisted-dying. The pro-bill coalition lost enough of its softer supporters that it no longer had the numbers.
Some were probably worried about safeguards. Some thought palliative care should come first. Some disliked the attempt to bring back effectively identical legislation and potentially use the Parliament Acts. Some were simply less enthusiastic after nearly two years of scrutiny and argument.
The irony is that the strategy designed to overcome opposition in the Lords may actually have helped lose votes in the Commons.
By trying to preserve an “identical bill” route, supporters made it harder to tell wavering MPs:
“Vote for the principle now — we can sort out the details later.”
And with a final result of 270–286, they only needed another 17 Yes votes to get it through.
So this wasn’t a landslide rejection of assisted dying.
It was a fairly narrow defeat caused mainly by previous supporters no longer being willing to vote for this particular bill again.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
When my gran was taken ill earlier this year, she wasn't terminally I'll other than being old but she knew she would never be able to live at home and walk her dog again, she said within days of being in hospital that she wanted to die and we all accepted and understood her wishes. If she could have brought all the family into her hospital room (and the dog), said goodbye and taken a tablet that meant she didn't wake up from her sleep she would have done.
Instead we had to endure 12 weeks of her refusing to eat, being hoisted out of bed onto a commode and shunted from bed to bed to make room for people who needed hospital care more than her as they actually had a will to live. People dying is sad but at that stage it's worse when the days go by and you don't receive the phone call. She had minimal dignity in the end and some sort of start with assisted dying would have helped in our situation.
There has to be dignity in death, these are all people who've mostly lived full lives and want to do things in their terms, reducing them to vegetables on some phony quest to preserve life, when there isn't any left gives no one the dignity they deserve.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-12-2026, 07:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: When my gran was taken ill earlier this year, she wasn't terminally I'll other than being old but she knew she would never be able to live at home and walk her dog again, she said within days of being in hospital that she wanted to die and we all accepted and understood her wishes. If she could have brought all the family into her hospital room (and the dog), said goodbye and taken a tablet that meant she didn't wake up from her sleep she would have done.
Instead we had to endure 12 weeks of her refusing to eat, being hoisted out of bed onto a commode and shunted from bed to bed to make room for people who needed hospital care more than her as they actually had a will to live. People dying is sad but at that stage it's worse when the days go by and you don't receive the phone call. She had minimal dignity in the end and some sort of start with assisted dying would have helped in our situation.
There has to be dignity in death, these are all people who've mostly lived full lives and want to do things in their terms, reducing them to vegetables on some phony quest to preserve life, when there isn't any left gives no one the dignity they deserve.
100%. I'm frankly appalled by someone writing a bill than proposes this choice is available without the guardrails in place that would allow MPs to vote for it. It's fuggin incompetent, IMVHO onions.
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
It's a horrible feeling to receive a call that a relative has died, but somehow feel a sense of relief and happiness that they're at peace.
Rather than having a dignified goodbye with my nan, I had to watch her suffer in pain for days on end, whilst watching my mom and auntie endure hours of shifts being with my nan in hospital so she didn't die alone.
It's a situation that should not be allowed to happen. It's cruel on the person suffering during their last days of 'life', it's cruel for relatives who just want their loved on to be at peace, and it's cruel on patients who aren't receiving the care they need as resources are being used to care for someone that noone wants to be cared for.
The system is completely wrong, and anyone with an ounce of compassion can see that. There needs to be a law to allow people to end their life on their terms in a situation where they've no dignity, individuality and there's a terminal prognosis. I completely understand the need for any law to be watertight and not allow foul play, but surely this is achievable, FFS.
Posts: 7,717
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Lauren Edwards explicitly refused to allow amendments when asked directly in the chamber yesterday. Torpedoed her own bill.
|