Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-04-2026, 09:17 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-04-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The reason we were going sideways and playing in front of them was because Charlton were so well organised, particularly in the first half. At times they had 8-9 players in their own box and were happy to clear their lines when the ball was crossed into the 18 yard area.
There have been far, far better teams than us, when we used to park the bus under Pulis who struggled and failed to break us down, when we did similar. Sometimes you have to doff your hat to the oppositions resilience.
I personally think that against teams like Charlton we need to be prepared to shoot from outside the area more, and bring in or play from the start some of our more creative players, a fit and functioning Bany would perhaps in the first half offered more than trying to attack down the flanks with overlaps, because he may have been able to doing something ‘different’ to other players we have.
The problem coaches seem to have these days is they rely on stats to the point it actually hinders tactics, don’t shoot from outside the area, because statistically not as many goals are scored, get the ball into zone one or two in the box because statically more goals are scored in those areas. That becomes predictable, formulaic and really easy to combat. Having the courage and freedom to do something different is not as easily coached and needs players with more guile to make happen.
We are going to have more teams come and park the bus, how we combat that is now going to be a problem for Morrison and Co.
Again, shooting from distance. Do you want the ball falling on the edge of the box to Diakite and Molumby, or FHM, Rabby, Price, Whitwell or Collyer. It remains a question of balancing the side.
I never said it didn’t.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(09-04-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The reason we were going sideways and playing in front of them was because Charlton were so well organised, particularly in the first half. At times they had 8-9 players in their own box and were happy to clear their lines when the ball was crossed into the 18 yard area.
There have been far, far better teams than us, when we used to park the bus under Pulis who struggled and failed to break us down, when we did similar. Sometimes you have to doff your hat to the oppositions resilience.
I personally think that against teams like Charlton we need to be prepared to shoot from outside the area more, and bring in or play from the start some of our more creative players, a fit and functioning Bany would perhaps in the first half offered more than trying to attack down the flanks with overlaps, because he may have been able to doing something ‘different’ to other players we have.
The problem coaches seem to have these days is they rely on stats to the point it actually hinders tactics, don’t shoot from outside the area, because statistically not as many goals are scored, get the ball into zone one or two in the box because statically more goals are scored in those areas. That becomes predictable, formulaic and really easy to combat. Having the courage and freedom to do something different is not as easily coached and needs players with more guile to make happen.
We are going to have more teams come and park the bus, how we combat that is now going to be a problem for Morrison and Co.
Agree Derek.
Wednesday night was frustrating but not unexpected. Charlton came and did what Nathan Jones sides have done for years, and executed a game plan that led to them beating West Ham away the previous week.
We have struggled to break teams down at home for a while, and even in the run-in at the end of last season the victories over Hull and Watford still came during a period where we drew 6 and lost 1 of the other 7 games.
I was against us keeping the same team that did so well against Burnley away to Boro, and absolutely wanted us to return Heggebo to the line up for Charlton as I felt the 4-4-1-1 we were using with FHM was killing Morgan's threat from open play. I really hope we end this experiment against a Watford side that will no doubt look to shore up and do likewise. They started their season with 2 very robust performances before opening up a little at Swansea and getting torn a new one so I expect them to attempt a rinse and repeat performance of shithousing in the middle and parking 2 buses in front of our goal.
It'll take a little time for Mozza and co. to work out what our best team is. We still have 5-6 of our summer signings yet to start a league game, and I still think we lack squad balance. We are still lacking pace and genuine creativity - especially whilst Bany and MJ are injured - so until we can at least get one of those into the XI, find a way to best use Tunde, Collyer and Rabby, and get either Pereira or Galves settled as our fullback - I expect we will be somewhat hit and miss as a team - probably until the international break at the end of the month.
Hopefully come October, when we face the 'noses we will have a clearer idea of how we are going to line-up.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(09-02-2026, 08:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Diakate lost his man there, it happens, well worked by them.
Just watched the highlights. Worrying thing about the goal is that there was no overload of Charlton players. Molumby could maybe have stopped the cross (he was always behind and would have risked a yellow if he got it wrong), Diakite could maybe have sprinted back a bit harder, but - -
- - there were two Charlton attackers and three Albion defenders. George Campbell was beaten a little too easily in the air, Tyreece Campbell was Nat Phillips' man to mark. Phillips got himself into no-man's land watching the ball, then wasn't sharp enough to close the scorer down. It's exactly the sort of day-dreaming moment that characterised Semi Ajayi's game. Our CBs are performing better than last season's shitshow, but they are still pretty fragile. We won't be keeping many clean sheets unless they sharpen up.
Or we could follow Jacko's lead and blame Molumby
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Finally seen the goal back this morning. Maybe I'm being overly critical, but it's yet another goal conceded where we haven't dealt with the second ball defensively.
We're definitely conceding the same type of goal over and over again.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-04-2026, 11:27 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Finally seen the goal back this morning. Maybe I'm being overly critical, but it's yet another goal conceded where we haven't dealt with the second ball defensively.
We're definitely conceding the same type of goal over and over again.
Yep. I wouldn't be criticizing Campbell to much for not getting the jump on someone five inches taller.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(09-04-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The reason we were going sideways and playing in front of them was because Charlton were so well organised, particularly in the first half. At times they had 8-9 players in their own box and were happy to clear their lines when the ball was crossed into the 18 yard area.
There have been far, far better teams than us, when we used to park the bus under Pulis who struggled and failed to break us down, when we did similar. Sometimes you have to doff your hat to the oppositions resilience.
I personally think that against teams like Charlton we need to be prepared to shoot from outside the area more, and bring in or play from the start some of our more creative players, a fit and functioning Bany would perhaps in the first half offered more than trying to attack down the flanks with overlaps, because he may have been able to doing something ‘different’ to other players we have.
The problem coaches seem to have these days is they rely on stats to the point it actually hinders tactics, don’t shoot from outside the area, because statistically not as many goals are scored, get the ball into zone one or two in the box because statically more goals are scored in those areas. That becomes predictable, formulaic and really easy to combat. Having the courage and freedom to do something different is not as easily coached and needs players with more guile to make happen.
We are going to have more teams come and park the bus, how we combat that is now going to be a problem for Morrison and Co.
There's not much i would disagree with here.
What i would say is once we got the goal, it was disappointing to concede a goal to a team who didn't look like scoring.
Posts: 3,622
Threads: 253
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation:
1
Looks like Charltons defensive tactics aren't working against Stoke who, unlike us, aren't having too much trouble breaking them down today
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Early goal makes a massive difference against sides like that.
Posts: 624
Threads: 42
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
0
And playing 2 up front would have helped ,xant still believe we only played 1 striker at home to Charlton .
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
Now 4-0 to Stoke after 40 minutes. Who knows what an increased tempo and more clinical forward passing might have done for us on Wednesday? We showed Charlton way too much respect.
|