That Maguire goal - handball implications
#11
(08-30-2026, 06:43 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.

Hegg's was ball to hand, after the keeper got a touch, but that didn't stop a weeks worth of wailing and gnashing of teeth from Naaarrge fans.
Reply
#12
(08-30-2026, 05:41 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

It is a complete and utter farce.

What fevered mind cogitated and came up with a rule that says: "If you, as an attacking player catch the ball on the edge of the box, shoot, and it flies in to the top corner but the ref misses the handball, VAR will rule it out as you have handled it and a free kick will be awarded to the defending team. 

However, if in a similar incident you catch the ball, shank your shot horibly towards the corner flag but it spanks off the back of the centre half's ankle and goes in, that's fine, VAR will say the goal stands because it wasn't you that scored it."

It is a bewildering, perplexing pile of utter elephant shit.

Makes me want to weep and swear in equal measure.

It's VAR at its very worst and again highlights why I never want to see it in the Championship. They just make shit up! It was a proper old Trafford decision.

So what happens if that happens again but the ball looks like it's heading towards the post before being deflected in? How would they know if it was going in or it wasgoing wide and an own goal? It's an utter, utter bollocks rule that needs throwing out.
Reply
#13
(08-30-2026, 06:43 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.
He part controlled it with his hands. It was deliberate. Mind, if he had caught it and performed a drop kick it would be the same bent outcome. Edit Just seen again. He throws both arms to get at the ball!
Reply
#14
(08-30-2026, 07:00 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 06:43 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.
He part controlled it with his hands. It was deliberate. Mind, if he had caught it and performed a drop kick it would be the same bent outcome. Edit  Just seen again. He throws both arms to get at the ball!

But crucially that's not the verdict of the officials, if they thought it was a deliberate handball they would have disallowed it.
Reply
#15
(08-30-2026, 07:11 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 07:00 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 06:43 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.
He part controlled it with his hands. It was deliberate. Mind, if he had caught it and performed a drop kick it would be the same bent outcome. Edit  Just seen again. He throws both arms to get at the ball!

But crucially that's not the verdict of the officials, if they thought it was a deliberate handball they would have disallowed it.

Call me a cynic but if it had been an Albion player (or Ipswich) it would have been deliberate on one quick review. If they could not see that was deliberate they have never kicked a ball ™ and/or they have worse eyesight than I, sans specs.  It stinks.
Reply
#16
Hudds would not have his gauntlet down if he didn't know it was a bad decision. He could argue this to The Hague. Be told.
Do it mon!
Reply
#17
I defy anyone to explain to me how our bloke got a two game retrospective suspension, and they didn't even have the goal disallowed.

VAR is just another tool for ensuring rich teams win as it can be selectively applied. It's a mirror of our judicial system. There's no way that stands if Ipswich scored it.

They do a good job of putting you off the beautiful game.
Reply
#18
(08-31-2026, 05:54 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: I defy anyone to explain to me how our bloke got a two game retrospective suspension, and they didn't even have the goal disallowed.

VAR is just another tool for ensuring rich teams win as it can be selectively applied. It's a mirror of our judicial system. There's no way that stands if Ipswich scored it.

They do a good job of putting you off the beautiful game.

It reminds me of the Kai Havertz on in our game against Chelsea to make it 3-3 in the dying minutes. The commentator said and I quote “After the handball VAR deemed that West Brom had the chance to clear it”

I hate injustices like the weekend, but give me those over reviewed and frankly confusing injustices that are given with VAR.

They ALWAYS seem to favour the “right” teams too.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: