That Maguire goal - handball implications
#1
So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.
Reply
#2
Not seen it but Shirley, deception is deception?
Reply
#3
Nowt will happen, as it’s not EFL and it’s not West Brom.
Reply
#4
Man U is Man U and Albion is Albion. There's a world of difference.
Reply
#5
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

It is a complete and utter farce.

What fevered mind cogitated and came up with a rule that says: "If you, as an attacking player catch the ball on the edge of the box, shoot, and it flies in to the top corner but the ref misses the handball, VAR will rule it out as you have handled it and a free kick will be awarded to the defending team. 

However, if in a similar incident you catch the ball, shank your shot horibly towards the corner flag but it spanks off the back of the centre half's ankle and goes in, that's fine, VAR will say the goal stands because it wasn't you that scored it."

It is a bewildering, perplexing pile of utter elephant shit.

Makes me want to weep and swear in equal measure.
Reply
#6
Next game I propose we pick the ball up and throw it in off the back of the keepers head. Surely that is allowed on the same basis.

Also… to those calling for VAR this is why it’s STILL a no from me. Even with a VAR review you get bullshit decisions
Reply
#7
(08-30-2026, 05:41 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

It is a complete and utter farce.

What fevered mind cogitated and came up with a rule that says: "If you, as an attacking player catch the ball on the edge of the box, shoot, and it flies in to the top corner but the ref misses the handball, VAR will rule it out as you have handled it and a free kick will be awarded to the defending team. 

However, if in a similar incident you catch the ball, shank your shot horibly towards the corner flag but it spanks off the back of the centre half's ankle and goes in, that's fine, VAR will say the goal stands because it wasn't you that scored it."

It is a bewildering, perplexing pile of utter elephant shit.

Makes me want to weep and swear in equal measure.

Spot on. I turned off at that point. Utter fugging bollocks
Reply
#8
(08-30-2026, 06:04 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:41 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

It is a complete and utter farce.

What fevered mind cogitated and came up with a rule that says: "If you, as an attacking player catch the ball on the edge of the box, shoot, and it flies in to the top corner but the ref misses the handball, VAR will rule it out as you have handled it and a free kick will be awarded to the defending team. 

However, if in a similar incident you catch the ball, shank your shot horibly towards the corner flag but it spanks off the back of the centre half's ankle and goes in, that's fine, VAR will say the goal stands because it wasn't you that scored it."

It is a bewildering, perplexing pile of utter elephant shit.

Makes me want to weep and swear in equal measure.

Spot on. I turned off at that point. Utter fugging bollocks

What happened to the nonsense when a foul (which it definitely was) was committed in the build up to goal? On occasions VAR have gone back 3 or 4 passes to a supposed foul prior to a goal, obviously very much dependent on which team scored the goal (Egypt for example)
Reply
#9
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.
Reply
#10
(08-30-2026, 06:43 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2026, 05:25 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: So Maguire handles it (not "accidental", his hands are up to help control it), then shoots and scores but it's a goal because there is another touch by a defender en route to the net, so the handball is disregarded.

Would this mean that if Heggo's handball had hit the keeper and gone in, it would have been a legitimate goal and therefore no deceiving the ref and no retrospective ban?

What an utter farce.

If they didn't think it was accidental it would have been disallowed.

Still a mess of a law.
I may be mistaken but I thought accidental is still handball nowadays?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: