VAR debate - the decisions even themselves out across a season.
#1
Let's see... I'll keep a record here in this post.

+ Norwich away: handball goal
+ Preston away: Diakité kung fu kick in pelanty area

- Burnley at home: goal conceded after foul in build-up

- Middlesbrough away: offside goal conceded
- Middlesbrough away: should have had a penalty for handball.

Overall: For 2 Against 3
Reply
#2
I’d argue two goals today were offside for Boro (if I were being picky).
Reply
#3
Under no circumstances do I want VAR creeping into this division.

I'm more than willing to take the inconsistent referee decisions over the game destroying VAR.
Reply
#4
This is VAR through the back door. It's happening next season at this level imo.
Reply
#5
(08-29-2026, 07:04 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Under no circumstances do I want VAR creeping into this division.

I'm more than willing to take the inconsistent referee decisions over the game destroying VAR.

Same, but the 2 game ban is definitely overreaching
Reply
#6
Interesting that when Brunt and Schwartzer were being interviewed after, the Boro ex keeper said about people losing jobs due to such decisions.
However, as is said, luck does even itself pretty much.
VAR takes away from the spontaneity where you wait a minute and it’s an emotional con when you’re denied.
Despite today, I’d never want VAR.
I do feel though the powers that be will bring it in soon enough.
Reply
#7
There is no actual evidence these things "even out over a season".
1st and 3rd goals were offside, lino should look for another job.
That pull back just before half time should've been a card.
VAR will be in the Champ next season. Inevitably.
Reply
#8
Things do not ‘even themselves out’ over the season. If you flip a coin you wouldn’t expect it to land 50 times tails and 50 times heads in a hundred goes. That said, VAR is the worst thing to happen to football in my lifetime. Decisions still wrong, offside by a gnats gonad and the feeling its used for bias toward bigger clubs when some decisions are looked at and others aren’t. I’d take crap reffing over VAR.
https://www.strava.com/clubs/1030893 - WBA Unofficial Strava Running Club
Reply
#9
(08-29-2026, 09:42 PM)BeijingBaggie Wrote: Things do not ‘even themselves out’ over the season. If you flip a coin you wouldn’t expect it to land 50 times tails and 50 times heads in a hundred goes. That said, VAR is the worst thing to happen to football in my lifetime. Decisions still wrong, offside by a gnats gonad and the feeling its used for bias toward bigger clubs when some decisions are looked at and others aren’t. I’d take crap reffing over VAR.

This. Excellent post.
Reply
#10
The old chestnut of things "evening themselves out" is not intended to be statistically accurate. It's more about a principle which alludes to refereeing being neutral, and that mistakes are honest.
If we ever lose that (see Infantino and the WC) then we've lost football.
I'm against VAR, but accept that honest errors happen.
I'm sure Millwall or Blackpool fans can remember when they were unfairly treated too, but we just have to accept and move on. Or accept VAR.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)