‘Helping are own’
#51
Next you'll be telling me that we have a progressive Council Tax system when the household occupying a two bed terrace in Washington Tyne & Wear pays more than the King for the royal residence at Buckingham Palace. Surely you have something better to do?
Reply
#52
Seeing as I support replacing CT with an LVT, and you know that, no I wouldn't. And you're the person who defended the fucking poll tax.

And you're analogy doesn't work when a poll tax is more regressive than CT. A family of 4 in Westminster in a flat would pay more than Clarence House with a poll tax.
Reply
#53
I'll add "defended the poll tax" to the list of ludicrous misrepresentations on here then.

Well done. You can jog on now.
Reply
#54
Ah, I see. Literally quoting you defending Thatcher's poll tax is misrepresentation and somehow not defending the poll tax but you claiming that I think that CT is progressive (and not more progressive than the most regressive form of tax, as I put) with everything in writing is fair game. Jog on yourself.
Reply
#55
I think you're entirely missing the point that a Poll Tax would be clear and accountable. And, because of those features it would be revealed for the wretched approach it is. Local government finance would have been reformed decades ago.

As it is, we have its knee jerk replacement which will cost me £4,300 this year. If I lived in Westminster I'd be paying £1,700 for the same Band.

I know for a fact that generations of useless Civil Servants have steered governments away from addressing this because it's such a political nightmare.
Reply
#56
You are aware that the Liberals already brought in an LVT for local taxation with no opposition from the Civil Service at the time, right? And that the Tories got rid of it in the 1920s? The reason why no government has tried to bring it back in is because other than between 2010 and 2015 no party of government supported reintroducing it and even in that period of government it was blocked by the senior partner within that government. Fundamentally it doesn't suit Labour's political interests to tax land and it actively undermines the Conservatives' political interests to do it. It's nowt to do with the Civil Service, it's pure politics. If anything the Civil Service would love an LVT as it would centralise tax management and require bureaucratic input to ascertain what the land values are, even with Land Registry being digitised that's more bureaucracy than just allocating a new property to a band based on something from 1993 and leaving it. Why do you think the Tories decided to replace the poll tax with Council Tax instead of a LVT? Because the Tories do not want an LVT.

And your anecdote fails to take into consideration the disparities in local vs national tax policy, a house share of 6 professionals in Bayswater pays less than Clarence House in CT but would pay 3 times more than Clarence House under a Poll Tax, and I would be liable in my mid-terrace rental for the same tax rate as landed gentry with their country retreat in rural Warwickshire under poll tax.
Reply
#57
(08-24-2026, 03:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And your anecdote fails to take into consideration the disparities in local vs national tax policy, a house share of 6 professionals in Bayswater pays less than Clarence House in CT but would pay 3 times more than Clarence House under a Poll Tax, and I would be liable in my mid-terrace rental for the same tax rate as landed gentry with their country retreat in rural Warwickshire under poll tax.

Isn't that exactly why it would have been thrown decades ago? As I stated in my last post.

And whilst we're on the subject of you not reading what I've posted - I didn't mention Civil Servants & LVT. I was referring in general to local government finance. Apologies if I didn't make myself clear. I shall self-flagellate later. 

Given that we're actually on the same side on this one I do find you attempting to pick a fight somewhat tiresome.
Reply
#58
It was thrown out decades ago, and replaced by Council Tax. The reason - as I've tried to make blunt - that we don't have an LVT has nothing to do with how shit the poll tax was, it's because the two parties of government in our two party system do not want it as it suits neither of them to have it in spite of fringe mutterings from people irrelevant to the machinations of the parties they are tied to. When we moved to a Land Value Tax in 1909 it was because the party of government at the time actively wanted it.

And you mentioned the Civil Service obstructing local government finance which makes no sense as any move to an LVT would empower the central Civil Service over local government compared to Council Tax. The various academic bodies tied to the CS and public policy (like the Martin School) are obsessed by introducing an LVT.
Reply
#59
I shan't bother posting again on this subject until it's evident that you actually read what I posted.
Reply
#60
Evidence where it's Civil Servants and not Ministers that have obstructed local government finance reforms, you made the claim and I'm challenging it
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: