Posts: 410
Threads: 21
Joined: Feb 2026
(08-24-2026, 10:35 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (08-24-2026, 10:22 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-24-2026, 09:23 AM)Mullers Wrote: (08-24-2026, 08:06 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-23-2026, 02:31 PM)Mullers Wrote: Confused as to why fans are being blamed for turnstiles not working. FWIW, I got there at 10:30am when doors opened. Ticket was scanned by a steward outside the ground, and then when I scanned it at turnstile it said “Ticket already used”. Others told them they were at the wrong entrance. One steward said “Well this is new to us as well”.
After a whole summer, this simply shouldn’t be happening. Any new system in any business should be stress tested before go live, and something as important as turnstiles for a football stadium should be regularly checked regardless. Someone next to me said they ended up not having their ticket checked at all as gates were just opened to cope with the queues/crowds. This isn’t safe.
Having read all the posts, it wasn’t a system failure and therefore stating stress testing wasn’t performed is a wild guess. To stress test the system you’d want to scan tickets simultaneously using all the scanners the club has, to ensure the tickets can be read and validated on the hand held terminals and the back-end system updated that the ticket has been used. Was this performed? I don’t know and neither do you. But it wasn’t a system failure anyhow.
The problems were clearly all process related and not system related. All the stewards should have received sufficient training and the scanners in the turnstiles should have been temporarily disabled or masked over, so people couldn’t scan their ticket.
It may have been a case stewards realised people were joining the wrong queues and then went down the queues advising fans what queue they were in.
Why they need different queues for adults and concessions is beyond me, as they’d need to manually scan all of the tickets anyhow.
Genuine question if you don’t think it was a system failure - what is the point in the ticket scanner inside the turnstile? A lot of people have said they had no issue having their ticket scanned by a steward and being told to just walk through without scanning it at the gate (some have even said they didn’t have a ticket scanned at all). I would be amazed if this is the new entry system and that we’ve just made the turnstile scanners completely redundant while also making jibbing a lot easier.
I was told by a senior steward that I needed to get my ticket scanned by a steward first and then by the turnstile, and as the turnstile told me my ticket had already been used, I struggle to see how it wasn’t an error in the system.
As I mentioned, ideally they should have disabled the scanners in the turnstiles or covered them over to prevent people from scanning their ticket again. But maybe they want to see if this works or not and be able to revert to scanning at turnstiles if the new process doesn’t work.
They should have had signs outside the turnstiles stations “do not scan your ticket in the turnstiles”
They should have released the new process on the website, WhatsApp and X.
If the process had been followed…. and you didn’t scan your ticket in the turnstile, the process would have worked. But you didn’t follow the process. Maybe the steward said to go straight though and didn’t elaborate to you.
So the process wasn’t robust. Hence it’s a process issue and not a system issue.
Had I been tasked with designing a revised process and system change to catch people using concession tickets instead of adults, then I’d have suggested lights inside the concourse, above each turnstile. Lights green for adults and red for concession when a ticket is scanned. The stewards could then easily see if a person entering has used a concession ticket or not.
I could be mistaken but were such lights not already in place prior to this season? Also relying on such would require additional manpower within the concourse so a costly option.
Weren’t stewards previously next to each turnstile exit on the concourse, to frisk all those entering? If so, there wouldn’t be any additional manpower required.
For the fans, there wouldn’t be any change to entering the ground, except for those found abusing concession tickets.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(08-24-2026, 10:22 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-24-2026, 09:23 AM)Mullers Wrote: (08-24-2026, 08:06 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-23-2026, 02:31 PM)Mullers Wrote: Confused as to why fans are being blamed for turnstiles not working. FWIW, I got there at 10:30am when doors opened. Ticket was scanned by a steward outside the ground, and then when I scanned it at turnstile it said “Ticket already used”. Others told them they were at the wrong entrance. One steward said “Well this is new to us as well”.
After a whole summer, this simply shouldn’t be happening. Any new system in any business should be stress tested before go live, and something as important as turnstiles for a football stadium should be regularly checked regardless. Someone next to me said they ended up not having their ticket checked at all as gates were just opened to cope with the queues/crowds. This isn’t safe.
Having read all the posts, it wasn’t a system failure and therefore stating stress testing wasn’t performed is a wild guess. To stress test the system you’d want to scan tickets simultaneously using all the scanners the club has, to ensure the tickets can be read and validated on the hand held terminals and the back-end system updated that the ticket has been used. Was this performed? I don’t know and neither do you. But it wasn’t a system failure anyhow.
The problems were clearly all process related and not system related. All the stewards should have received sufficient training and the scanners in the turnstiles should have been temporarily disabled or masked over, so people couldn’t scan their ticket.
It may have been a case stewards realised people were joining the wrong queues and then went down the queues advising fans what queue they were in.
Why they need different queues for adults and concessions is beyond me, as they’d need to manually scan all of the tickets anyhow.
Genuine question if you don’t think it was a system failure - what is the point in the ticket scanner inside the turnstile? A lot of people have said they had no issue having their ticket scanned by a steward and being told to just walk through without scanning it at the gate (some have even said they didn’t have a ticket scanned at all). I would be amazed if this is the new entry system and that we’ve just made the turnstile scanners completely redundant while also making jibbing a lot easier.
I was told by a senior steward that I needed to get my ticket scanned by a steward first and then by the turnstile, and as the turnstile told me my ticket had already been used, I struggle to see how it wasn’t an error in the system.
As I mentioned, ideally they should have disabled the scanners in the turnstiles or covered them over to prevent people from scanning their ticket again. But maybe they want to see if this works or not and be able to revert to scanning at turnstiles if the new process doesn’t work.
They should have had signs outside the turnstiles stations “do not scan your ticket in the turnstiles”
They should have released the new process on the website, WhatsApp and X.
If the process had been followed…. and you didn’t scan your ticket in the turnstile, the process would have worked. But you didn’t follow the process. Maybe the steward said to go straight though and didn’t elaborate to you.
So the process wasn’t robust. Hence it’s a process issue and not a system issue.
Had I been tasked with designing a revised process and system change to catch people using concession tickets instead of adults, then I’d have suggested lights inside the concourse, above each turnstile. Lights green for adults and red for concession when a ticket is scanned. The stewards could then easily see if a person entering has used a concession ticket or not.
There is exactly this in place already. It requires a steward in the ground to watch the lights. The problem is, I suppose, you are already in the ground by then and would need physically removing g.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-24-2026, 11:28 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (08-24-2026, 10:22 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-24-2026, 09:23 AM)Mullers Wrote: (08-24-2026, 08:06 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-23-2026, 02:31 PM)Mullers Wrote: Confused as to why fans are being blamed for turnstiles not working. FWIW, I got there at 10:30am when doors opened. Ticket was scanned by a steward outside the ground, and then when I scanned it at turnstile it said “Ticket already used”. Others told them they were at the wrong entrance. One steward said “Well this is new to us as well”.
After a whole summer, this simply shouldn’t be happening. Any new system in any business should be stress tested before go live, and something as important as turnstiles for a football stadium should be regularly checked regardless. Someone next to me said they ended up not having their ticket checked at all as gates were just opened to cope with the queues/crowds. This isn’t safe.
Having read all the posts, it wasn’t a system failure and therefore stating stress testing wasn’t performed is a wild guess. To stress test the system you’d want to scan tickets simultaneously using all the scanners the club has, to ensure the tickets can be read and validated on the hand held terminals and the back-end system updated that the ticket has been used. Was this performed? I don’t know and neither do you. But it wasn’t a system failure anyhow.
The problems were clearly all process related and not system related. All the stewards should have received sufficient training and the scanners in the turnstiles should have been temporarily disabled or masked over, so people couldn’t scan their ticket.
It may have been a case stewards realised people were joining the wrong queues and then went down the queues advising fans what queue they were in.
Why they need different queues for adults and concessions is beyond me, as they’d need to manually scan all of the tickets anyhow.
Genuine question if you don’t think it was a system failure - what is the point in the ticket scanner inside the turnstile? A lot of people have said they had no issue having their ticket scanned by a steward and being told to just walk through without scanning it at the gate (some have even said they didn’t have a ticket scanned at all). I would be amazed if this is the new entry system and that we’ve just made the turnstile scanners completely redundant while also making jibbing a lot easier.
I was told by a senior steward that I needed to get my ticket scanned by a steward first and then by the turnstile, and as the turnstile told me my ticket had already been used, I struggle to see how it wasn’t an error in the system.
As I mentioned, ideally they should have disabled the scanners in the turnstiles or covered them over to prevent people from scanning their ticket again. But maybe they want to see if this works or not and be able to revert to scanning at turnstiles if the new process doesn’t work.
They should have had signs outside the turnstiles stations “do not scan your ticket in the turnstiles”
They should have released the new process on the website, WhatsApp and X.
If the process had been followed…. and you didn’t scan your ticket in the turnstile, the process would have worked. But you didn’t follow the process. Maybe the steward said to go straight though and didn’t elaborate to you.
So the process wasn’t robust. Hence it’s a process issue and not a system issue.
Had I been tasked with designing a revised process and system change to catch people using concession tickets instead of adults, then I’d have suggested lights inside the concourse, above each turnstile. Lights green for adults and red for concession when a ticket is scanned. The stewards could then easily see if a person entering has used a concession ticket or not.
There is exactly this in place already. It requires a steward in the ground to watch the lights. The problem is, I suppose, you are already in the ground by then and would need physically removing g.
And also the stewards are not bouncers, they are generally kids with jackets too big. If they see some coked up arsehole with attitude coming through as an child what are they likely to do? It was easier to stop them getting through the turnstiles before they are challenged
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Dunno what all the fuss is about. I walked up to the steward at about 11 bells, perfunctory barely there search, walked past, another steward insisted on scanning my ticket and told me to walk through the turnstile without scanning. Took about 10 seconds.
Posts: 410
Threads: 21
Joined: Feb 2026
08-24-2026, 06:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-24-2026, 06:14 PM by RamsAy it.)
(08-24-2026, 11:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-24-2026, 11:28 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (08-24-2026, 10:22 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (08-24-2026, 09:23 AM)Mullers Wrote: (08-24-2026, 08:06 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: Having read all the posts, it wasn’t a system failure and therefore stating stress testing wasn’t performed is a wild guess. To stress test the system you’d want to scan tickets simultaneously using all the scanners the club has, to ensure the tickets can be read and validated on the hand held terminals and the back-end system updated that the ticket has been used. Was this performed? I don’t know and neither do you. But it wasn’t a system failure anyhow.
The problems were clearly all process related and not system related. All the stewards should have received sufficient training and the scanners in the turnstiles should have been temporarily disabled or masked over, so people couldn’t scan their ticket.
It may have been a case stewards realised people were joining the wrong queues and then went down the queues advising fans what queue they were in.
Why they need different queues for adults and concessions is beyond me, as they’d need to manually scan all of the tickets anyhow.
Genuine question if you don’t think it was a system failure - what is the point in the ticket scanner inside the turnstile? A lot of people have said they had no issue having their ticket scanned by a steward and being told to just walk through without scanning it at the gate (some have even said they didn’t have a ticket scanned at all). I would be amazed if this is the new entry system and that we’ve just made the turnstile scanners completely redundant while also making jibbing a lot easier.
I was told by a senior steward that I needed to get my ticket scanned by a steward first and then by the turnstile, and as the turnstile told me my ticket had already been used, I struggle to see how it wasn’t an error in the system.
As I mentioned, ideally they should have disabled the scanners in the turnstiles or covered them over to prevent people from scanning their ticket again. But maybe they want to see if this works or not and be able to revert to scanning at turnstiles if the new process doesn’t work.
They should have had signs outside the turnstiles stations “do not scan your ticket in the turnstiles”
They should have released the new process on the website, WhatsApp and X.
If the process had been followed…. and you didn’t scan your ticket in the turnstile, the process would have worked. But you didn’t follow the process. Maybe the steward said to go straight though and didn’t elaborate to you.
So the process wasn’t robust. Hence it’s a process issue and not a system issue.
Had I been tasked with designing a revised process and system change to catch people using concession tickets instead of adults, then I’d have suggested lights inside the concourse, above each turnstile. Lights green for adults and red for concession when a ticket is scanned. The stewards could then easily see if a person entering has used a concession ticket or not.
There is exactly this in place already. It requires a steward in the ground to watch the lights. The problem is, I suppose, you are already in the ground by then and would need physically removing g.
And also the stewards are not bouncers, they are generally kids with jackets too big. If they see some coked up arsehole with attitude coming through as an child what are they likely to do? It was easier to stop them getting through the turnstiles before they are challenged
And neither are guards / revenue collectors bouncers on trains.
I’m sure the fans and more so the stewards will be totally fucked off with this new process, when it’s pissing down or sub zero temperatures and they are outside in it for a couple of hours. This clearly hasn’t been thought through very well.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
Surely you start with the checks outside? Prevent access rather than ejecting. I was late on Sunday (completely my fault, hungover, needed a shower, needed a greasy breakfast) and I went to the wrong entrance but was redirected and scanned in right away. Just made my seat in time. My only takeout was how loud the PA was walking up to the ground.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
What’s trains got to do with it and did anyone get caught up for two hours. I queued for 10 mins max at 11.45, went in, got a coffee and a chocolate and made it to the back of the Brummie before kick off
|