Toby Collyer
#71
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.

Like Ryan Donk and Shelton Martis, you mean?
Reply
#72
(08-19-2026, 09:19 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.

Like Ryan Donk and Shelton Martis, you mean?

Yeah, yeah he performed a miracle…
Reply
#73
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.
That was more about players stepping up in level, can’t remember us signing players with limited minutes AND poor injury records. I stand to be corrected.

There are different levels of risk. Bany should be a warning.
Reply
#74
(08-19-2026, 09:28 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.
That was more about players stepping up in level, can’t remember us signing players with limited minutes AND poor injury records. I stand to be corrected.

There are different levels of risk. Bany should be a warning.

But as has been discussed about Bany previously, he didn’t have a bad injury record when we signed him, he’d been pretty much permanently available in Denmark.

His former coach said he’d need to work on his physicality and conditioning as it’s a big jump from Denmark to the Championship, especially as he’d only just come from their second tier too, but he wasn’t a crock.
Reply
#75
(08-19-2026, 09:02 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: You’d also like to think having had him for 4-5 months, our medical and conditioning teams have confidence that they can get games out of him.

Our medical and conditioning teams have such a great track record in terms of getting players fit and keeping them fit. What could possibly go wrong?
Reply
#76
(08-19-2026, 09:19 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.

Like Ryan Donk and Shelton Martis, you mean?

Donk was a loan signing in a Premier League season and Shelton Martis was a 50k backup the same season we spent 17 million on the likes of Brunt, Morrison and Bednar. 

It’s like saying Guardiola couldn’t spend money because he brought in Scott Carson on a free.

Other than that, good post.
Reply
#77
You can bookmark this post.

If we sign Collyer we will sell him for £20m minimum within 2 seasons. Lest we forget Jimmy was out for 14 months with what started with a blister. Players get injured.

Everyone I know in Manchester believes the kid has something special. Some times you have to take risk to get reward.
Reply
#78
(08-19-2026, 09:28 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.
That was more about players stepping up in level, can’t remember us signing players with limited minutes AND poor injury records. I stand to be corrected.

There are different levels of risk. Bany should be a warning.

Kean Bryan? Martin Kelly? Both given two year contracts
Reply
#79
(08-19-2026, 11:51 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: You can bookmark this post.

If we sign Collyer we will sell him for £20m minimum within 2 seasons. Lest we forget Jimmy was out for 14 months with what started with a blister. Players get injured.

Everyone I know in Manchester believes the kid has something special. Some times you have to take risk to get reward.

If that’s the case you’d imagine the deal would contain a buy back well below that
Raw Sausage
Reply
#80
(08-20-2026, 06:04 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 11:51 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: You can bookmark this post.

If we sign Collyer we will sell him for £20m minimum within 2 seasons. Lest we forget Jimmy was out for 14 months with what started with a blister. Players get injured.

Everyone I know in Manchester believes the kid has something special. Some times you have to take risk to get reward.

If that’s the case you’d imagine the deal would contain a buy back well below that

Sounds like there’ll be a hefty sell on clause instead.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)