Toby Collyer
#61
(08-19-2026, 11:39 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Clark went to RB Salzburg (not Leipzig) but agree he was younger, a better prospect and a better player and he flopped there and ended up at Derby on loan, but the point is that he left Liverpool for £10m. Man U really aren’t going to sell Collyer for £1m when you consider that fee, the one for Vittek, Lankshear etc. I think last summer they would have looked for around £10m given that he was a regular on their bench in the second half of the season. The fact that he had such a poor season in the championship has likely led to a revaluation but I doubt down to a level that would make the deal worthwhile.

Easy mistake to make Big Grin

I mean United will only sell him for what someone is willing to pay... if he moves for 5M elsewhere, I'll be more than happy to see us miss out, even if he turns out fantastic.
Reply
#62
(08-19-2026, 11:07 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 11:03 AM)Cornflake Wrote: Reported by a guy from the Athletic our bid is £750k with add ons up to £1.3m.

That’s a spoof account unfortunately. Claims to write for the Athletic but there is no evidence that he does or ever has.

Yeah I saw that tweet and thought “bullshitter” immediately.
Reply
#63
(08-19-2026, 11:42 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 11:39 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Clark went to RB Salzburg (not Leipzig) but agree he was younger, a better prospect and a better player and he flopped there and ended up at Derby on loan, but the point is that he left Liverpool for £10m. Man U really aren’t going to sell Collyer for £1m when you consider that fee, the one for Vittek, Lankshear etc. I think last summer they would have looked for around £10m given that he was a regular on their bench in the second half of the season. The fact that he had such a poor season in the championship has likely led to a revaluation but I doubt down to a level that would make the deal worthwhile.

Easy mistake to make Big Grin

I mean United will only sell him for what someone is willing to pay... if he moves for 5M elsewhere, I'll be more than happy to see us miss out, even if he turns out fantastic.
I’d be happy to miss out if he goes for £500k! Far prefer Diakite and Molumby.
Reply
#64
lots of noise on twatter this is a done deal, not sure if any is reliable.

not sure how i feel, depends on the fee i guess.

injury record is poor for his age
Reply
#65
I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.
Reply
#66
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come with something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

I agree, when he did play I thought he looked like he could get going and be very decent. Seemed to have a talent for finding a pass, being available and decent movement - exactly what we want from a midfielder. 

The loan was frustrating as injuries hit just as I felt as though he was about to get going. Time well tell whether this is Banny V2 - I guess one birth has been vacated by Dike so we have room in the pool if needed.
Reply
#67
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.
Reply
#68
I’d add to that BF Morrison has obviously seen him a fair bit at close quarters so you can be sure that’s in the mix here
Raw Sausage
Reply
#69
You’d also like to think having had him for 4-5 months, our medical and conditioning teams have confidence that they can get games out of him.
Reply
#70
(08-19-2026, 08:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-19-2026, 08:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’d be happy with the signing, when he did play he seemed to be the player who can keep possession well and keep the ball moving when needed. We are going to have to accept that the players we now sign are not going to come without something to prove, be it inexperience, injury or a drop in form from previous promise. The club seem to have adopted the ABBA approach to signings… ‘take a chance on me’.

Inexperience and form are different to multiple injuries.
There is basically no consistent form for anyone to warrant going for this guy, so it is a pure hunch, combined with everything crossed that he can stay fit and if he does he fulfils potential. Because that’s all it is, potential. 
There’s a fear that we are being bedazzled by the “highly rated” rhetoric that surrounds players with limited minutes coming out of rich clubs. 
Big, big risk.

Expectations regarding who we are going to be able to buy need to be adjusted. We are now back at the taking chances on players stage. Think pre-Megson rather than Mowbray being able to buy the best players in the Championship.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: