Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
08-18-2026, 03:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-18-2026, 03:08 PM by SW4Baggie.)
(08-18-2026, 03:02 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-18-2026, 02:09 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: TBF he was decent for them in 24/25. I have a colleague who actually goes who rates him. I could see why they would want a decent price. However, he was terribly ordinary in the Champ and we have better players so why would we pay above a million or two?
In 24/25 he made six appearances all as a substitute, apologies I do not know at what point during those six games he came on. However, that seems insufficient evidence to rate him
In 24/25 he played:
45 mins in a 3-0 H defeat to Liverpool in September
36 mins in a 3-1 H win against Southampton
26 mins in a 3-1 H defeat to Brighton
14 mins in a 1-0 A win at Fulham (all 3 in January)
14 mins in a 1-1 H draw with Arsenal
and 39 mins in a 3-0 A win at Leicester (both in March)
Hardly 25m quid's worth of experience is it!?
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Ornstein reporting that United are about to sign Baleba from Brighton, which may in turn open the door to Collyer to move.
Personally I'd say the best way to approach this would be a loan with an option to buy at an agreed price if conditions are met.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(08-18-2026, 03:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-18-2026, 03:02 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-18-2026, 02:09 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: TBF he was decent for them in 24/25. I have a colleague who actually goes who rates him. I could see why they would want a decent price. However, he was terribly ordinary in the Champ and we have better players so why would we pay above a million or two?
In 24/25 he made six appearances all as a substitute, apologies I do not know at what point during those six games he came on. However, that seems insufficient evidence to rate him
In 24/25 he played:
45 mins in a 3-0 H defeat to Liverpool in September
36 mins in a 3-1 H win against Southampton
26 mins in a 3-1 H defeat to Brighton
14 mins in a 1-0 A win at Fulham (all 3 in January)
14 mins in a 1-1 H draw with Arsenal
and 39 mins in a 3-0 A win at Leicester (both in March)
Hardly 25m quid's worth of experience is it!? Totally agree but a young reserve who has done ok for a team like that would be expected to fetch a £5-£10m. Just look at the crazy figures that the likes of Bobby Clark (admittedly much better), Imray, Lankshear etc have left the Prem for. Admittedly the latter two had successful loans but had not featured as much as Collyer in the top flight.
Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Reported by a guy from the Athletic our bid is £750k with add ons up to £1.3m.
Posts: 306
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2026
Reputation:
1
I think I'm a no on it. Too much of a gamble given the situation we're in.
This is a 22 year old who has featured in a total of 23 games in his whole career.
Too risky.
Posts: 341
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(08-19-2026, 11:03 AM)Cornflake Wrote: Reported by a guy from the Athletic our bid is £750k with add ons up to £1.3m.
That’s a spoof account unfortunately. Claims to write for the Athletic but there is no evidence that he does or ever has.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-19-2026, 11:03 AM)Cornflake Wrote: Reported by a guy from the Athletic our bid is £750k with add ons up to £1.3m.
Sounds like what we’d bid
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(08-19-2026, 11:07 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: (08-19-2026, 11:03 AM)Cornflake Wrote: Reported by a guy from the Athletic our bid is £750k with add ons up to £1.3m.
That’s a spoof account unfortunately. Claims to write for the Athletic but there is no evidence that he does or ever has.
Whatever the credibility of the supposed reporter, those are the sort of figures I would hope to see should we do make a bid. Unlikely methinks, but if so then it's a gamble I would like us to take.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-19-2026, 09:25 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (08-18-2026, 03:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-18-2026, 03:02 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (08-18-2026, 02:09 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: TBF he was decent for them in 24/25. I have a colleague who actually goes who rates him. I could see why they would want a decent price. However, he was terribly ordinary in the Champ and we have better players so why would we pay above a million or two?
In 24/25 he made six appearances all as a substitute, apologies I do not know at what point during those six games he came on. However, that seems insufficient evidence to rate him
In 24/25 he played:
45 mins in a 3-0 H defeat to Liverpool in September
36 mins in a 3-1 H win against Southampton
26 mins in a 3-1 H defeat to Brighton
14 mins in a 1-0 A win at Fulham (all 3 in January)
14 mins in a 1-1 H draw with Arsenal
and 39 mins in a 3-0 A win at Leicester (both in March)
Hardly 25m quid's worth of experience is it!? Totally agree but a young reserve who has done ok for a team like that would be expected to fetch a £5-£10m. Just look at the crazy figures that the likes of Bobby Clark (admittedly much better), Imray, Lankshear etc have left the Prem for. Admittedly the latter two had successful loans but had not featured as much as Collyer in the top flight.
Clark moved to Leipzig for £10M but was I think 4 years younger than Collyer is now, having had the same amount of game time for a better Liverpool team. He also didn’t come with all the injury baggage that Collyer does.
After being Derby’s POTY last year they paid £6M for him - he’s now 21 with a full year excelling in the Champ, a season of semi regular Bundesliga and Euro football experience and his Liverpool experience
Collyer may well have potential, but talk of anything over 1-2M, given his injury track record is silly IMO.
I’d offer them an outright purchase of around £1M with some add-ons plus 30% sell on - similar to the Morgan deal… or offer to loan him with a 3-4M price if he makes 25-30 league starts.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
Clark went to RB Salzburg (not Leipzig) but agree he was younger, a better prospect and a better player and he flopped there and ended up at Derby on loan, but the point is that he left Liverpool for £10m. Man U really aren’t going to sell Collyer for £1m when you consider that fee, the one for Vittek, Lankshear etc. I think last summer they would have looked for around £10m given that he was a regular on their bench in the second half of the season. The fact that he had such a poor season in the championship has likely led to a revaluation but I doubt down to a level that would make the deal worthwhile.
|