Toby Collyer
#41
(08-18-2026, 08:44 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: On the twitter united fans are saying he shouldn’t be sold for anything less than, it’s a range, between £10M and £25M.  Others don’t want him sold at all and only offered out on loan.  They all seem to rate him based on a 45 minute performance against Leeds in Dublin.  If he does come here they’ll be v v disappointed with the fee, shades of us and Periera

Theyve sold Vittek for 14M (with about 8 of it upfront) - and he was the best goalie in the Championship last season.

Collyer is worth 1-2M tops for a Championship side. If Man Utd want to realise his full value, he needs to show he can play a full season without missing 6 months!
Reply
#42
Morgan Rogers was sold to Middlesbrough for about £1m, he was younger, had more experience in league football and wasn't a crock.

If Utd want 10x that, I'd expect to him to have a fair chunk of minutes in the Prem for them, let alone in the EFL.

Utd are going to be disappointed either way; either through selling him for less than they hope, or by seeing he's not worth that when he actually plays for them.
Reply
#43
(08-18-2026, 08:44 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: On the twitter united fans are saying he shouldn’t be sold for anything less than, it’s a range, between £10M and £25M.  Others don’t want him sold at all and only offered out on loan.  They all seem to rate him based on a 45 minute performance against Leeds in Dublin.  If he does come here they’ll be v v disappointed with the fee, shades of us and Periera

So there not basing it on his form of a couple of years ago. He appeared and made a terrific impact, so you are totally wrong saying it’s based on 45 min cameo v Leeds.
Me I would buy him stays fit and who knows on that, we would have a terrific player on our hands. Anyway if Mozza wants him I think he knows a midfielder when he sees one.
Reply
#44
Fugg me - the United fans really do talk a load of bollocks
Reply
#45
(08-18-2026, 12:35 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Fugg me - the United fans really do talk a load of bollocks
It's the West Country/Essex/East Anglian/Irish/Korean accents.
Reply
#46
I understand where they are coming from. Their central midfield has been shite (for where they believe it should be) so they see youngster have a decent 45 minutes and go overboard.

If United fans want 25 million then that’s about 24 million more than I think we should be paying given our current midfield options, how he performed on loan and the other positions we need to bring players in for.
Reply
#47
They sold McTominay for 25M.... based on that, Collyer should cost 500k
Reply
#48
TBF he was decent for them in 24/25. I have a colleague who actually goes who rates him. I could see why they would want a decent price. However, he was terribly ordinary in the Champ and we have better players so why would we pay above a million or two?
Reply
#49
Buy him for £2m, sell him back to them for £30m this time next year....
Reply
#50
(08-18-2026, 02:09 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: TBF he was decent for them in 24/25. I have a colleague who actually goes who rates him. I could see why they would want a decent price. However, he was terribly ordinary in the Champ and we have better players so why would we pay above a million or two?

In 24/25 he made six appearances all as a substitute, apologies I do not know at what point during those six games he came on. However, that seems insufficient evidence to rate him
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)