Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
What a mess this thread is and shows the issues up. From the information we know it appears that Arday should never have got to the level he did and had academics been listened to earlier this would have probably been dealt with quietly and efficiently.
Instead Arday was used by the liberal institutions as a poster boy for black progression in academia, which is hugely under represented and does need addressing. By defending him and allowing both accusations of racism, police interference and threats of litigation to support their poster boy, they’ve actually thrown him to the wolves and allowed every gammon and right wing press association to go in even harder. Do the media give us the news they know sells, it is a product, or do they set the agenda?
It’s a sad case of someone struggling with their mental health being used firstly by white liberals and secondly by white racists as a flag for the good/bad extremes of wokeness. Both sides have forgotten there’s a human life at stake with friends and family.
So I agree I don’t very much this would have happened to a white professor, but then he would be have been lauded and pushed to the forefront and made into a celebrity in the first place. Something which Arday was happy to accept because he was mentally incapable of not doing so.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
08-16-2026, 08:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-16-2026, 08:23 AM by Squid.)
(08-16-2026, 06:59 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: “And you are indeed judging” was a question rather than an accusation, although I accept it can be read that way.
My point is simple - in the rush to pick a side, people are being selective about the evidence they use to form their opinions. I suspect that many of them are doing it to fit a pre existing view on wokeness or even race but that point is moot (in relation to the point I’m making at least): if they were armed with the breadth of knowledge needed to properly inform an opinion on the matter (an in depth understanding of the hiring process, a doctorate in sociology, the biases that exist within academia, the political agenda around DEI etc etc) they would - if truly unbiased - find it very difficult to be so absolutist in their viewpoints.
That is very condescending and basically, claiming nobody knows enough to comment is just a mechanism to shut down conversation which could be used on any topic ever, frankly. Yet strangely you've only decided to use this now. For all your claims of "not wanting to pick a side", I suspect you've pulled out the "nobody knows enough to discuss this card", because the Bluesky version of events is wrong and shock, horror, Proth actually does have a point, particularly about the use of Carter Ruck.
Finally, you have absolutely no idea of my academic background or employment history and I intend to keep it that way, but I find the assumptions you are making very telling.
Posts: 11,931
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
It's not a mechanism to shut down the conversation at all. It's virtually impossible to "shut down" a conversation on the internet. It's a cautionary word to warn that the internet is a) full of people with gaps in their knowledge b) people begin to fill those gaps with partial knowledge but rarely complete the picture c) that evidence selection is often biased towards pre-existing belief frameworks d) the confidence shown in those opinions rarely reflect the level of competence in arriving at those viewpoints. I don't do Bluesky, twitter, facebook - mainly because it's full of people who meet criteria a, b, c and d.
I have no interest in your academic background unless, for the purposes of this thread, you are a Professor of sociology in a leading University with recruitment responsibilities.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-15-2026, 01:14 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:28 AM)baggy1 Wrote: All fair points squid, but then get him to step down through different channels, don't hound him to his grave. They fucked up, no doubt about that, should he have been vilified as he was, i don't think so.
Are my sentiments on the matter. I get Squid’s point that publicity cuts both ways but a man is dead due to it.
I did have another thought later on about the publicity angle, which I agree with that it does cut both ways. But I’d never heard of him before he started getting called out in the nationals, so the publicity and promotion that he received when he was appointed and subsequently was nothing near the publicity when he was getting torn down.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-16-2026, 09:20 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It's not a mechanism to shut down the conversation at all. It's virtually impossible to "shut down" a conversation on the internet. It's a cautionary word to warn that the internet is a) full of people with gaps in their knowledge b) people begin to fill those gaps with partial knowledge but rarely complete the picture c) that evidence selection is often biased towards pre-existing belief frameworks d) the confidence shown in those opinions rarely reflect the level of competence in arriving at those viewpoints. I don't do Bluesky, twitter, facebook - mainly because it's full of people who meet criteria a, b, c and d.
I have no interest in your academic background unless, for the purposes of this thread, you are a Professor of sociology in a leading University with recruitment responsibilities.
And you wish to give this warning right now, rather then on any other previous thread discussing current affairs, including the ones you happily participate in, because..?
Posts: 7,473
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Maybe because he’s right in that this is a thread where the points he’s made are particularly poignant
Raw Sausage
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(08-16-2026, 08:20 AM)Squid Wrote: (08-16-2026, 06:59 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: “And you are indeed judging” was a question rather than an accusation, although I accept it can be read that way.
My point is simple - in the rush to pick a side, people are being selective about the evidence they use to form their opinions. I suspect that many of them are doing it to fit a pre existing view on wokeness or even race but that point is moot (in relation to the point I’m making at least): if they were armed with the breadth of knowledge needed to properly inform an opinion on the matter (an in depth understanding of the hiring process, a doctorate in sociology, the biases that exist within academia, the political agenda around DEI etc etc) they would - if truly unbiased - find it very difficult to be so absolutist in their viewpoints.
That is very condescending and basically, claiming nobody knows enough to comment is just a mechanism to shut down conversation which could be used on any topic ever, frankly. Yet strangely you've only decided to use this now. For all your claims of "not wanting to pick a side", I suspect you've pulled out the "nobody knows enough to discuss this card", because the Bluesky version of events is wrong and shock, horror, Proth actually does have a point, particularly about the use of Carter Ruck.
Finally, you have absolutely no idea of my academic background or employment history and I intend to keep it that way, but I find the assumptions you are making very telling.
I only got involved in this thread, because a post you wrote implied that the plagiarism accusation against Arday had been definitively settled.
It has not.
You are entitled to your opinion that he is guilty of plagiarism. You are entitled to your opinion that the John Moore investigation into whether Arday was guilty of plagiarism was flawed. I don't know what your credentials are into coming to this conclusion are and I'm not interested. I know that I'm not in a position to have a view one way or the other, so I don't hold an opinion.
But I do know that no official investigation have found Arday guilty of plagiarism.
Probably appropriate to reveal my favourit film is 12 Angry Men and I am a self confessed pedant.
Posts: 7,473
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
As I said a while back, everyone has to have an “opinion” on Arday, and not being able to step back and see the wider thing for what it is, is being blind to the actual important stuff that is going on.
Raw Sausage
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-16-2026, 09:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I said a while back, everyone has to have an “opinion” on Arday, and not being able to step back and see the wider thing for what it is, is being blind to the actual important stuff that is going on.
Again, this is a claim that could be made about any thread discussing current affairs, so why make it here?
FWIW, the higher education sector is in massive financial trouble and if any university collapses, it will have an economic and societal impact far beyond the students and staff. The very last thing the sector needs is a scandal like this, but pretending there's nothing to see here and it's all the fault of the wicked, nasty media is the very last response that needs to happen. Both Cambridge and LJMU have significant questions to answer.
|