Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-15-2026, 11:24 AM)Squid Wrote: Arday's appointment to the role was national news. Cambridge publicised it for all it was worth. All the cries about "What about other academics??", other academics don't have their memoirs published by a leading publishing house.
The people on here and elsewhere blaming this entirely on media coverage are missing the point. Arday had built (and indeed been actively helped to build) a massive house of cards. There is no way that it wasn't going to collapse and collapse very messily. Plagiarism and research fraud are one thing, Walter Mitty tales are another, but very rarely do you get both and at such a high profile institution. In addition to all that, Arday/Cambridge had tried to squash the story using the combined might of Carter-Ruck and the police, seemingly without any thought of the impact that might have to those on the receiving end.
Other academics tried to raise concerns about his work via academic means. Arday publicly accused them of racist harassment:
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/c...exclusive/
For those wanting to point the finger entirely at the media. What do you think should have happened instead? As on the balance of things, a pattern of such consistent plagiarism and research fraud plus the fantastical claims about his life means that he would have at the very least been asked to step down and would have had his memoir cancelled.
I agree with Squid. Jason Arday is as much a creation of Cambridge, the BBC and liberal academia as the stories he told them and himself. Cambridge obviously loved his story so much they chose not to question it. It’s almost colonial, it’s that bad.
I might have even more sympathy with him had he not played both the race and legal cards himself.
Posts: 8,079
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
(08-15-2026, 11:28 AM)baggy1 Wrote: All fair points squid, but then get him to step down through different channels, don't hound him to his grave. They fucked up, no doubt about that, should he have been vilified as he was, i don't think so.
Are my sentiments on the matter. I get Squid’s point that publicity cuts both ways but a man is dead due to it.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-15-2026, 01:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:24 AM)Squid Wrote: Arday's appointment to the role was national news. Cambridge publicised it for all it was worth. All the cries about "What about other academics??", other academics don't have their memoirs published by a leading publishing house.
The people on here and elsewhere blaming this entirely on media coverage are missing the point. Arday had built (and indeed been actively helped to build) a massive house of cards. There is no way that it wasn't going to collapse and collapse very messily. Plagiarism and research fraud are one thing, Walter Mitty tales are another, but very rarely do you get both and at such a high profile institution. In addition to all that, Arday/Cambridge had tried to squash the story using the combined might of Carter-Ruck and the police, seemingly without any thought of the impact that might have to those on the receiving end.
Other academics tried to raise concerns about his work via academic means. Arday publicly accused them of racist harassment:
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/c...exclusive/
For those wanting to point the finger entirely at the media. What do you think should have happened instead? As on the balance of things, a pattern of such consistent plagiarism and research fraud plus the fantastical claims about his life means that he would have at the very least been asked to step down and would have had his memoir cancelled.
I agree with Squid. Jason Arday is as much a creation of Cambridge, the BBC and liberal academia as the stories he told them and himself. Cambridge obviously loved his story so much they chose not to question it. It’s almost colonial, it’s that bad.
I might have even more sympathy with him had he not played both the race and legal cards himself.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/15/world...=url-share
The above is a very good overview by the NYT.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(08-15-2026, 12:10 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:24 AM)Squid Wrote: Arday's appointment to the role was national news. Cambridge publicised it for all it was worth. All the cries about "What about other academics??", other academics don't have their memoirs published by a leading publishing house.
The people on here and elsewhere blaming this entirely on media coverage are missing the point. Arday had built (and indeed been actively helped to build) a massive house of cards. There is no way that it wasn't going to collapse and collapse very messily. Plagiarism and research fraud are one thing, Walter Mitty tales are another, but very rarely do you get both and at such a high profile institution. In addition to all that, Arday/Cambridge had tried to squash the story using the combined might of Carter-Ruck and the police, seemingly without any thought of the impact that might have to those on the receiving end.
Other academics tried to raise concerns about his work via academic means. Arday publicly accused them of racist harassment:
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/c...exclusive/
For those wanting to point the finger entirely at the media. What do you think should have happened instead? As on the balance of things, a pattern of such consistent plagiarism and research fraud plus the fantastical claims about his life means that he would have at the very least been asked to step down and would have had his memoir cancelled.
At last. Great post Squid. Not just the media though, don't forget all the racists.
Although you do need to take into account that he was cleared of plagiarism by the University who awarded him his doctorate, who did an investigation into the validity of the award.
I've seen the actual Turnitin report of his thesis and I have no idea how Liverpool John Moore's University came to that conclusion, nor have they shared their reasoning. It seems to have been motivated by a desire to avoid negative publicity and reputational damage as opposed to upholding academic standards. They were certainly swift to delete their page praising him in the wake of the scandal: https://archive.md/IdtRD
It is a very sad case. Reading this Guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday
he genuinely does seem to have lost his grip on reality, but neither side of the argument wants to concede that.
My comments are solely based on the plagiarism accusation, which so far as I am aware have yet to be proved.
What would concern me would be the identity of his chief accuser.. Nathan Cofnas who believed that under a true meritocracy black people would disappear from almost all high profile positions outside of sports and entertainment.
Not sure I see him as a neutral player.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
08-15-2026, 01:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-15-2026, 01:49 PM by Squid.)
(08-15-2026, 01:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 12:10 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:24 AM)Squid Wrote: Arday's appointment to the role was national news. Cambridge publicised it for all it was worth. All the cries about "What about other academics??", other academics don't have their memoirs published by a leading publishing house.
The people on here and elsewhere blaming this entirely on media coverage are missing the point. Arday had built (and indeed been actively helped to build) a massive house of cards. There is no way that it wasn't going to collapse and collapse very messily. Plagiarism and research fraud are one thing, Walter Mitty tales are another, but very rarely do you get both and at such a high profile institution. In addition to all that, Arday/Cambridge had tried to squash the story using the combined might of Carter-Ruck and the police, seemingly without any thought of the impact that might have to those on the receiving end.
Other academics tried to raise concerns about his work via academic means. Arday publicly accused them of racist harassment:
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/c...exclusive/
For those wanting to point the finger entirely at the media. What do you think should have happened instead? As on the balance of things, a pattern of such consistent plagiarism and research fraud plus the fantastical claims about his life means that he would have at the very least been asked to step down and would have had his memoir cancelled.
At last. Great post Squid. Not just the media though, don't forget all the racists.
Although you do need to take into account that he was cleared of plagiarism by the University who awarded him his doctorate, who did an investigation into the validity of the award.
I've seen the actual Turnitin report of his thesis and I have no idea how Liverpool John Moore's University came to that conclusion, nor have they shared their reasoning. It seems to have been motivated by a desire to avoid negative publicity and reputational damage as opposed to upholding academic standards. They were certainly swift to delete their page praising him in the wake of the scandal: https://archive.md/IdtRD
It is a very sad case. Reading this Guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday
he genuinely does seem to have lost his grip on reality, but neither side of the argument wants to concede that.
My comments are solely based on the plagiarism accusation, which so far as I am aware have yet to be proved.
What would concern me would be the identity of his chief accuser.. Nathan Cofnas who believed that under a true meritocracy black people would disappear from almost all high profile positions outside of sports and entertainment.
Not sure I see him as a neutral player.
If you had read the Retraction Watch article linked in my post, you would see that several academics had raised concerns way before Cofnas.
Quote:
Harris wanted to know if Arday could explain some “puzzling similarities” between sentences in that article and a BMJ Open study from epidemiologist Anjum Memon about mental health services in Black and minority communities. Arday ignored his first email, but when Harris followed up several days later, Arday was blunt. “Instead of spending your time trying to dismantle racism and ableism, you have spent what I assume is hours combing through my work looking for mistakes,” he wrote. Arday told Harris not to contact him again: “Anything further from you will be considered bullying and harassment.”
Harris soon recruited a colleague, Martyn Hammersley, a sociologist at Open University, to review the Social Sciences article himself, and he, too, was concerned. On May 19, 2023, Hammersley sent an email to Hilary Cremin, the Head of the Faculty of Education at Cambridge, and to Rhys Morgan, the university’s Head of Policy, Governance, and Integrity
So both academics (and Martyn Hammersley, btw is an avowed Marxist) tried the correct, collegial academic route to raise their concerns and got nowhere.
Then Times Higher Education also tried to break the story and got the journalist was threatened with Carter Ruck and reported to the police for harassment. So they dropped the story.
This left the path clear for the deeply unpleasant Cofnas to break the story.
There are lessons to be learned here and people taking snippets of a long series of events aren't going to be learning them.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-15-2026, 01:47 PM)Squid Wrote: If you had read the Retraction Watch article linked in my post, you would see that several academics had raised concerns way before Cofnas.
Quote:
Harris wanted to know if Arday could explain some “puzzling similarities” between sentences in that article and a BMJ Open study from epidemiologist Anjum Memon about mental health services in Black and minority communities. Arday ignored his first email, but when Harris followed up several days later, Arday was blunt. “Instead of spending your time trying to dismantle racism and ableism, you have spent what I assume is hours combing through my work looking for mistakes,” he wrote. Arday told Harris not to contact him again: “Anything further from you will be considered bullying and harassment.”
Harris soon recruited a colleague, Martyn Hammersley, a sociologist at Open University, to review the Social Sciences article himself, and he, too, was concerned. On May 19, 2023, Hammersley sent an email to Hilary Cremin, the Head of the Faculty of Education at Cambridge, and to Rhys Morgan, the university’s Head of Policy, Governance, and Integrity
So both academics (and Martyn Hammersley, btw is an avowed Marxist) tried the correct, collegial academic route to raise their concerns and got nowhere.
Then Times Higher Education also tried to break the story and got the journalist was threatened with Carter Ruck and reported to the police for harassment. So they dropped the story.
This left the path clear for the deeply unpleasant Cofnas to break the story.
There are lessons to be learned here and people taking snippets of a long series of events aren't going to be learning them.
This. Playing the race card and especially the legal card is straight of the populist playbooks most on here rail against.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(08-15-2026, 01:47 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 01:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 12:10 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: At last. Great post Squid. Not just the media though, don't forget all the racists.
Although you do need to take into account that he was cleared of plagiarism by the University who awarded him his doctorate, who did an investigation into the validity of the award.
I've seen the actual Turnitin report of his thesis and I have no idea how Liverpool John Moore's University came to that conclusion, nor have they shared their reasoning. It seems to have been motivated by a desire to avoid negative publicity and reputational damage as opposed to upholding academic standards. They were certainly swift to delete their page praising him in the wake of the scandal: https://archive.md/IdtRD
It is a very sad case. Reading this Guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday
he genuinely does seem to have lost his grip on reality, but neither side of the argument wants to concede that.
My comments are solely based on the plagiarism accusation, which so far as I am aware have yet to be proved.
What would concern me would be the identity of his chief accuser.. Nathan Cofnas who believed that under a true meritocracy black people would disappear from almost all high profile positions outside of sports and entertainment.
Not sure I see him as a neutral player.
If you had read the Retraction Watch article linked in my post, you would see that several academics had raised concerns way before Cofnas.
Quote:
Harris wanted to know if Arday could explain some “puzzling similarities” between sentences in that article and a BMJ Open study from epidemiologist Anjum Memon about mental health services in Black and minority communities. Arday ignored his first email, but when Harris followed up several days later, Arday was blunt. “Instead of spending your time trying to dismantle racism and ableism, you have spent what I assume is hours combing through my work looking for mistakes,” he wrote. Arday told Harris not to contact him again: “Anything further from you will be considered bullying and harassment.”
Harris soon recruited a colleague, Martyn Hammersley, a sociologist at Open University, to review the Social Sciences article himself, and he, too, was concerned. On May 19, 2023, Hammersley sent an email to Hilary Cremin, the Head of the Faculty of Education at Cambridge, and to Rhys Morgan, the university’s Head of Policy, Governance, and Integrity
So both academics (and Martyn Hammersley, btw is an avowed Marxist) tried the correct, collegial academic route to raise their concerns and got nowhere.
Then Times Higher Education also tried to break the story and got the journalist was threatened with Carter Ruck and reported to the police for harassment. So they dropped the story.
This left the path clear for the deeply unpleasant Cofnas to break the story.
There are lessons to be learned here and people taking snippets of a long series of events aren't going to be learning them.
But it still remains the case that these remain opinions. The investigation by John Moore did not uphold these allegations of plagiarism.
You might be right, John Moore might have brushed the accusations under the carpet to avoid embarrassment, or alternatively given Arday's relative prominence they would want to get their ducks in a row and ensure the investigation was thorough.
I have no idea, I haven't read report and if I had I would be almost certainly none the wiser.
And I'm certainly in no position to judge whether he had the competence to be given the academic position Cambridge gave him.
But the truth of the matter is that the accusations of plagiarism are just that, accusations.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-15-2026, 02:08 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 01:47 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 01:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-15-2026, 12:10 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-15-2026, 11:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Although you do need to take into account that he was cleared of plagiarism by the University who awarded him his doctorate, who did an investigation into the validity of the award.
I've seen the actual Turnitin report of his thesis and I have no idea how Liverpool John Moore's University came to that conclusion, nor have they shared their reasoning. It seems to have been motivated by a desire to avoid negative publicity and reputational damage as opposed to upholding academic standards. They were certainly swift to delete their page praising him in the wake of the scandal: https://archive.md/IdtRD
It is a very sad case. Reading this Guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday
he genuinely does seem to have lost his grip on reality, but neither side of the argument wants to concede that.
My comments are solely based on the plagiarism accusation, which so far as I am aware have yet to be proved.
What would concern me would be the identity of his chief accuser.. Nathan Cofnas who believed that under a true meritocracy black people would disappear from almost all high profile positions outside of sports and entertainment.
Not sure I see him as a neutral player.
If you had read the Retraction Watch article linked in my post, you would see that several academics had raised concerns way before Cofnas.
Quote:
Harris wanted to know if Arday could explain some “puzzling similarities” between sentences in that article and a BMJ Open study from epidemiologist Anjum Memon about mental health services in Black and minority communities. Arday ignored his first email, but when Harris followed up several days later, Arday was blunt. “Instead of spending your time trying to dismantle racism and ableism, you have spent what I assume is hours combing through my work looking for mistakes,” he wrote. Arday told Harris not to contact him again: “Anything further from you will be considered bullying and harassment.”
Harris soon recruited a colleague, Martyn Hammersley, a sociologist at Open University, to review the Social Sciences article himself, and he, too, was concerned. On May 19, 2023, Hammersley sent an email to Hilary Cremin, the Head of the Faculty of Education at Cambridge, and to Rhys Morgan, the university’s Head of Policy, Governance, and Integrity
So both academics (and Martyn Hammersley, btw is an avowed Marxist) tried the correct, collegial academic route to raise their concerns and got nowhere.
Then Times Higher Education also tried to break the story and got the journalist was threatened with Carter Ruck and reported to the police for harassment. So they dropped the story.
This left the path clear for the deeply unpleasant Cofnas to break the story.
There are lessons to be learned here and people taking snippets of a long series of events aren't going to be learning them.
But it still remains the case that these remain opinions. The investigation by John Moore did not uphold these allegations of plagiarism.
You might be right, John Moore might have brushed the accusations under the carpet to avoid embarrassment, or alternatively given Arday's relative prominence they would want to get their ducks in a row and ensure the investigation was thorough.
I have no idea, I haven't read report and if I had I would be almost certainly none the wiser.
And I'm certainly in no position to judge whether he had the competence to be given the academic position Cambridge gave him.
But the truth of the matter is that the accusations of plagiarism are just that, accusations.
You can look up the comparisons. It's absolutely damning and it looks very poorly upon Cambridge that they 1. Didn't investigate them properly and 2. Allowed a staff member to use a law firm and the police to silence academic concerns.
However, as I've already pointed out. The issue isn't just plagiarism. It's the web of increasingly outrageous lies that Arday has told about his life, again the NYT article, I've provided in a free link outlines them in significant detail. Arday was about to release a memoir, so again this would have definitely been in the public realm. Look at the Salt Path scandal - that was international news too. So was James Frey when it was found that he'd made his memoir up wholesale.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Wild thing about this story is how quickly the news cycle went.
I was out of the country on holiday last week and completely missed the initial story breaking, the subsequent media pile on and the story’s tragic end. It all happened that quickly.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
There are many things to ponder over this sad episode. Mistakes made of both ‘sides’ (do we have to pick a side?). But I think we should always be wary of people who know too much about a specific matter when it comes to divisive subjects. A predetermined position goes in search of evidence to support their world view and it’s then presented as fact by people who have little concept of Dunning or, indeed, Kruger.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
|