Posts: 9,606
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
08-10-2026, 10:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-10-2026, 10:19 AM by Lurker#3.)
(08-10-2026, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-10-2026, 08:58 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (08-10-2026, 08:50 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (08-10-2026, 07:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: What gets lost when discussing Molumby and the positive things he does bring to our team is that pretty much every side that finishes towards the top end of the league will have a player with his tenacity that can also play a bit. When Lurker and the rest of us say we need an upgrade, that's what we mean, we don't want to lose his attitude and athleticism we just need to add a more technical player who also does the dirty work into his place.
Well, Chelsea will listen to offers for Enzo Fernandez.
I like the look of that lad Bellingham at Real Madrid. Brilliant going forward but also not afraid to put himself about and get stuck in. From the area as well so may fancy coming back to the West Midlands.
I was resistant to letting Molumby go but now an expert has floated the idea of bringing a better quality player in instead to replace him I'm all for it. Football actually really is such a simple game.
If it wasn't for the many geniuses on here that talk as though Molumby is the only player in the league who puts himself about a bit then I wouldn't have to point out the blatantly fuggin' obvious would I?! 
It's not rocket science...
Molumby wins possession high up and makes a lot of ball recoveries. They are his biggest traits.
BUT...
He is in the top 25% in the league for xG and xA, but is not better than half way for actual assists and goals scored. He also doesn't really contribute defensively being in the bottom 25% for defensive contributions for midfielders.
And whilst he in the top 25% in the league for successful passes, he's no better than half way again for chances created and big chances created.
Whereas, Mowatt, who many seem to think can't contribute anymore was in the top 10% for, created chances, big chances created, successful crosses, xA (and in top 15% in the league for assists). So he gets the creative role in there over Molumby.
Then Diakite out performs him defensively in all areas apart from ball recoveries in the attacking third, whilst being in the top 1% for aerial fuels won in the league.
So as has been said for too long. Molumby is great if you're up against it later in games against a good team and you need a yard dog to run around and pick second balls up higher up the pitch. But will never contribute enough in the final third when he does get it and can't be relied upon defensively. When you look at Mehres stats he is the perfect Molumby replacement. Last year (2025 season in Norway) he was as efficient at recovering the ball and retaining possession in the final third as Jays and also created a shit load.
If he stays he will be a valuable member of the squad for certain situations. But if he leaves he has nothing that can't be replaced pretty easily.
(All stats per/90)
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(08-10-2026, 10:13 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (08-10-2026, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-10-2026, 08:58 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (08-10-2026, 08:50 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (08-10-2026, 07:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: What gets lost when discussing Molumby and the positive things he does bring to our team is that pretty much every side that finishes towards the top end of the league will have a player with his tenacity that can also play a bit. When Lurker and the rest of us say we need an upgrade, that's what we mean, we don't want to lose his attitude and athleticism we just need to add a more technical player who also does the dirty work into his place.
Well, Chelsea will listen to offers for Enzo Fernandez.
I like the look of that lad Bellingham at Real Madrid. Brilliant going forward but also not afraid to put himself about and get stuck in. From the area as well so may fancy coming back to the West Midlands.
I was resistant to letting Molumby go but now an expert has floated the idea of bringing a better quality player in instead to replace him I'm all for it. Football actually really is such a simple game.
If it wasn't for the many geniuses on here that talk as though Molumby is the only player in the league who puts himself about a bit then I wouldn't have to point out the blatantly fuggin' obvious would I?! 
It's not rocket science...
Molumby wins possession high up and makes a lot of ball recoveries. They are his biggest traits.
BUT...
He is in the top 25% in the league for xG and xA, but is not better than half way for actual assists and goals scored. He also doesn't really contribute defensively being in the bottom 25% for defensive contributions for midfielders.
And whilst he in the top 25% in the league for successful passes, he's no better than half way again for chances created and big chances created.
Whereas, Mowatt, who many seem to think can't contribute anymore was in the top 10% for, created chances, big chances created, successful crosses, xA (and in top 15% in the league for assists). So he gets the creative role in there over Molumby.
Then Diakite out performs him defensively in all areas apart from ball recoveries in the attacking third, whilst being in the top 1% for aerial fuels won in the league.
So as has been said for too long. Molumby is great if you're up against it later in games against a good team and you need a yard dog to run around and pick second balls up higher up the pitch. But will never contribute enough in the final third when he does get it and can't be relied upon defensively. When you look at Mehres stats he is the perfect Molumby replacement. Last year (2025 season in Norway) he was as efficient at recovering the ball and retaining possession in the final third as Jays and also created a shit load.
If he stays he will be a valuable member of the squad for certain situations. But if he leaves he has nothing that can't be replaced pretty easily.
(All stats per/90) Is that a new technical term? I like it, my sort of stat that
Posts: 1,801
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
In a thread full of stating the obvious... this goes for any player we move on when operating under our current model.
Lurker's post highlights why the qualities that Molumby brings to the team should be very replaceable and also give us an opportunity to improve.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(08-10-2026, 10:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
In a thread full of stating the obvious... this goes for any player we move on when operating under our current model.
Lurker's post highlights why the qualities that Molumby brings to the team should be very replaceable and also give us an opportunity to improve.
Yes, but Vinebaggie's post talks about immeasurable qualities which galvanise the performance of those around him - how certain can we be of replacing those? Mowatt seems to have a new wave of popularity on here (people forgetting how quickly he runs out of steam these days), but have we ever seen him geeing up his team-mates when the side were struggling? It's that Darren Fletcher, Paul Scharner type drive that I don't see in any of the other midfielders. Replacing Fletcher with Gareth Barry was a fine example of bringing in equivalent skills and fitness but missing out on the leadership qualities.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-10-2026, 10:56 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
In a thread full of stating the obvious... this goes for any player we move on when operating under our current model.
Lurker's post highlights why the qualities that Molumby brings to the team should be very replaceable and also give us an opportunity to improve.
Yes, but Vinebaggie's post talks about immeasurable qualities which galvanise the performance of those around him - how certain can we be of replacing those? Mowatt seems to have a new wave of popularity on here (people forgetting how quickly he runs out of steam these days), but have we ever seen him geeing up his team-mates when the side were struggling? It's that Darren Fletcher, Paul Scharner type drive that I don't see in any of the other midfielders. Replacing Fletcher with Gareth Barry was a fine example of bringing in equivalent skills and fitness but missing out on the leadership qualities.
Correct. And the impossible to measure quality of “pain in the ass to play against” (see Andy Johnson in 2 Meggo promotions)
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-10-2026, 10:56 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
In a thread full of stating the obvious... this goes for any player we move on when operating under our current model.
Lurker's post highlights why the qualities that Molumby brings to the team should be very replaceable and also give us an opportunity to improve.
Yes, but Vinebaggie's post talks about immeasurable qualities which galvanise the performance of those around him - how certain can we be of replacing those? Mowatt seems to have a new wave of popularity on here (people forgetting how quickly he runs out of steam these days), but have we ever seen him geeing up his team-mates when the side were struggling? It's that Darren Fletcher, Paul Scharner type drive that I don't see in any of the other midfielders. Replacing Fletcher with Gareth Barry was a fine example of bringing in equivalent skills and fitness but missing out on the leadership qualities.
Please never mention Molumby alongside Scharner or Fletcher again.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
We were garbage with him for plenty of last season too.
We became a better side last season when Diakite was brought in to do the defensive work that Molumby wasn’t contributing… our best run last season came when Molumby was put wide!
I like him, I hope he stays, but it’s no coincidence the one season we’ve finished in the top 6 since he joined was the one where he missed half of it with injury and played his fewest games.
As Lurker’s stats show, he’s all action, all energy, but he doesn’t build on his good work as he doesn’t have that final bit of quality.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-10-2026, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-10-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Some good stats as always from Lurker, but I think what can't be measured is the impact he has on team mates, particularly when the going gets tough. How do you use stats to quantify character and the motivational impact on the rest if the team. This IMO in the championship is vital, when you get into the dead of winter and the players need something / someone to give them a boost when they are physically and mentally weary. This is the value we get from Molumby and I think a lot of his work is actually done in the dressing room. It won't be a disaster if he leaves but I really do hope that he stays.
This.
We had all this stat shit with Molumby last year. The one that counts is points when he played vs points when he didn’t. We were garbage without him.
If we’re gonna sell him, we best replace him.
We were garbage with him for plenty of last season too.
We became a better side last season when Diakite was brought in to do the defensive work that Molumby wasn’t contributing… our best run last season came when Molumby was put wide!
I like him, I hope he stays, but it’s no coincidence the one season we’ve finished in the top 6 since he joined was the one where he missed half of it with injury and played his fewest games.
As Lurker’s stats show, he’s all action, all energy, but he doesn’t build on his good work as he doesn’t have that final bit of quality.
Molumby was played wide for the later games of our good run, not all.
We picked up miles more points with him playing than when he wasn’t. He’s better than Diakite, although I think both are better than Mowatt.
He’ll be a good signing for someone higher up the table than us IMO. We’ll see if we replace him with someone as effective…..
|