Labour lose half their membership
#21
(08-09-2026, 07:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Proth and B1, proving once again that there is nothing politically that really separates them.

I've pointed that out many times
A love story for our time "The grown up and the libertarian" Big Grin
Reply
#22
(08-08-2026, 08:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It really is yawn now. Dekka clearly likes unelectable populists be that Corbyn or Polanski. I’m guessing this is because it gives him the opportunity to moan without responsibility. Starmer for all his failures turned the party round from unelectable to having power. I’m leased Burnham has the opportunity to build on that.

There was also the overestimation of how Reform would perform in the long term am we are. Ow here still talking about blue Labour. Yawn indeed

Yep. Kier was the Hodgson to the Steve Clark Burnham will be. The way I see it. 

Labour were unelectable when he took over.
Reply
#23
(08-09-2026, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You’re going to have to hope Burnham can ensure a Labour victory at the next election then, because the alternative is an ungovernable hung parliament. When you say realism, many would argue apathy brought about by the knowledge you’ll be fine regardless of outcome.

I think we’d benefit from an extended period of being ungovernable. Governance since 2008 has been risible. If Parliament was unable to pass any legislation at least things wouldn’t get any worse.
Reply
#24
(08-08-2026, 08:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It really is yawn now. Dekka clearly likes unelectable populists be that Corbyn or Polanski. I’m guessing this is because it gives him the opportunity to moan without responsibility. Starmer for all his failures turned the party round from unelectable to having power. I’m leased Burnham has the opportunity to build on that.

There was also the overestimation of how Reform would perform in the long term am we are. Ow here still talking about blue Labour. Yawn indeed

In the process of making labour electable, he lost around half a million Labour voters, it's a little spoken fact that in winning a landslide Starmer received less votes than the unelectable Corbyn in Labour's 'worst ever electoral performance!!'

For this to have happened turnout had to decline sharply, suggests a substantial disengagement with politics by many of the electorate. Never a healthy position for a democracy to be in, especially where there is a threat from an authoritarian party, that has potentially enough support to win a majority, but by no means majority support.
Reply
#25
(08-09-2026, 11:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-08-2026, 08:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It really is yawn now. Dekka clearly likes unelectable populists be that Corbyn or Polanski. I’m guessing this is because it gives him the opportunity to moan without responsibility. Starmer for all his failures turned the party round from unelectable to having power. I’m leased Burnham has the opportunity to build on that.

There was also the overestimation of how Reform would perform in the long term am we are. Ow here still talking about blue Labour. Yawn indeed

In the process of making labour electable, he lost around half a million Labour voters, it's a little spoken fact that in winning a landslide Starmer received less votes than the unelectable Corbyn in Labour's 'worst ever electoral performance!!'

For this to have happened turnout had to decline sharply, suggests a substantial disengagement with politics by many of the electorate. Never a healthy position for a democracy to be in, especially where there is a threat from an authoritarian party, that has potentially enough support to win a majority, but by no means majority support.

Labour won the last election because they were the only viable alternative to a despised, incompetent and risible government. It was not an endorsement of Labour policies or Starmerism (or an empty vase as it’s more accurately described). Chasing Daily Mail types at the expense of Labour left of centre support was and is idiotic, the party has gone from a broad church to a tiny chapel in a lovely part of Islington.
Reply
#26
Would you suggest that mass membership under Corbyn represented a “broad church” Dekka? Amongst a raft of bizarre contentions that would be right up there.
Reply
#27
(08-09-2026, 11:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-08-2026, 08:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It really is yawn now. Dekka clearly likes unelectable populists be that Corbyn or Polanski. I’m guessing this is because it gives him the opportunity to moan without responsibility. Starmer for all his failures turned the party round from unelectable to having power. I’m leased Burnham has the opportunity to build on that.

There was also the overestimation of how Reform would perform in the long term am we are. Ow here still talking about blue Labour. Yawn indeed

In the process of making labour electable, he lost around half a million Labour voters, it's a little spoken fact that in winning a landslide Starmer received less votes than the unelectable Corbyn in Labour's 'worst ever electoral performance!!'

For this to have happened turnout had to decline sharply, suggests a substantial disengagement with politics by many of the electorate. Never a healthy position for a democracy to be in, especially where there is a threat from an authoritarian party, that has potentially enough support to win a majority, but by no means majority support.

The 2024 election was possibly the FPTP system delivering its final landslide, which may be a good thing, or a bad, or possibly the first step on the road to electoral reform. Although it's not inconceivable that, come the next election, FPTP might deliver an electorally proportionate outcome by accident.

Democracy by serendipity, if you like...
Reply
#28
(08-07-2026, 07:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I’m more concerned with Britain’s mental health crisis if over 200,000 people have signed up for the Greens.

The Greens in many respects seem to attract alot of socially lost souls 
The ones who dont feel they fit in or belong 

So joining the greens or these militant transactivists groups gives them a sense of belonging
 
Dye you hair green blue red get a bull ring through your nose & shout facist to anyone who doesnt agree with you
Im sure theyve no idea what facism means

Years ago people followed types of music groups such as rockers mods punks etc as a sense of identity, leathers shaved heads etc etc 

BTW Im not a green hater as think they stand for some decent stuff 
Back in the 80s they would be labelled as the Loony Left
Reply
#29
(08-09-2026, 01:33 PM)Pipkins Wrote:
(08-07-2026, 07:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I’m more concerned with Britain’s mental health crisis if over 200,000 people have signed up for the Greens.

The Greens in many respects seem to attract alot of socially lost souls 
The ones who dont feel they fit in or belong 

So joining the greens or these militant transactivists groups gives them a sense of belonging
 
Dye you hair green blue red get a bull ring through your nose & shout facist to anyone who doesnt agree with you
Im sure theyve no idea what facism means

Years ago people followed types of music groups such as rockers mods punks etc as a sense of identity, leathers shaved heads etc etc 

BTW Im not a green hater as think they stand for some decent stuff 
Back in the 80s they would be labelled as the Loony Left

Bet you're the kind of person who (rightly) gets upset when brexit voters are described as stupid and/or racist
Reply
#30
(08-09-2026, 02:10 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-09-2026, 01:33 PM)Pipkins Wrote:
(08-07-2026, 07:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I’m more concerned with Britain’s mental health crisis if over 200,000 people have signed up for the Greens.

The Greens in many respects seem to attract alot of socially lost souls 
The ones who dont feel they fit in or belong 

So joining the greens or these militant transactivists groups gives them a sense of belonging
 
Dye you hair green blue red get a bull ring through your nose & shout facist to anyone who doesnt agree with you
Im sure theyve no idea what facism means

Years ago people followed types of music groups such as rockers mods punks etc as a sense of identity, leathers shaved heads etc etc 

BTW Im not a green hater as think they stand for some decent stuff 
Back in the 80s they would be labelled as the Loony Left

Bet you're the kind of person who (rightly) gets upset when brexit voters are described as stupid and/or racist
Can't even dye your hair or get a piercing these days
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)