Which Baggies team was better?
#11
I’m not sure I’d have cared for watching MP playing relentless turgid triangles
Raw Sausage
Reply
#12
They were both good teams for different reasons. Bilic lacked a proper striker but with Pereira and Grady it didn't matter. The squad was well balanced with room to develop.

Moore had the experienced squad, had the strikers and had Harvey Barnes.
Reply
#13
The defence and how they were coached let Moore's team down. Too many 1 - 1's were our undoing. Had we been even slightly solid at the back (and we had the personnel to do so), we would have been easily promoted.

Slav's team though. *Sigh*. I have a question. When did people know that we were going to be in consideration for the automatics? QPR away for me, but I would be interested in the thoughts of others.
Reply
#14
(08-04-2026, 12:54 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not sure I’d have cared for watching MP playing relentless turgid triangles

Exactly. carlos did what he did with what he had, because it suited his ideas and the players he had... Could he have unleashed MP? I seriously doubt it.

(08-04-2026, 02:04 PM)Squid Wrote: The defence and how they were coached let Moore's team down. Too many 1 - 1's were our undoing. Had we been even slightly solid at the back (and we had the personnel to do so), we would have been easily promoted.

Slav's team though. *Sigh*. I have a question. When did people know that we were going to be in consideration for the automatics? QPR away for me, but I would be interested in the thoughts of others.

I actually can't remember when, but it was just such a joy to watch it had to lead to success, so probably November time would've been when I thought oh hang on a sec we can do this..
Reply
#15
(08-04-2026, 02:04 PM)Squid Wrote: The defence and how they were coached let Moore's team down. Too many 1 - 1's were our undoing. Had we been even slightly solid at the back (and we had the personnel to do so), we would have been easily promoted.

Slav's team though. *Sigh*. I have a question. When did people know that we were going to be in consideration for the automatics? QPR away for me, but I would be interested in the thoughts of others.

Was that the 2-3 last minute Livermore goal?

Probably Blues away for me scoring two late goals to win it 2-3.

Agree with the Big Dave stuff too. A back 4 of Holgate - Dawson - Hegazi - Gibbs should have been a lot more solid than it was.
Reply
#16
Re the defences, I just remember under Dave, then Slav and even Carlos we just always seemed to get punished for silly mistakes.
Reply
#17
(08-04-2026, 02:48 PM)MrBater Wrote: Re the defences, I just remember under Dave, then Slav and even Carlos we just always seemed to get punished for silly mistakes.

Big Dave fell off when he started letting Graham Jones tell him what to do.
Reply
#18
We don't know what CC would have done with a Pereira because he never ever had a player like that. It's worth noting he looked best on the prem under Big Sam where he was the one allowed to basically do what he liked while everyone else had to keep shape. I'd like to think CC would have done something similar, he wasn't a lazy player that would have left his teammates high and dry, but he was the type of talent you give a lot of freedom to.
Reply
#19
(08-04-2026, 02:46 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-04-2026, 02:04 PM)Squid Wrote: The defence and how they were coached let Moore's team down. Too many 1 - 1's were our undoing. Had we been even slightly solid at the back (and we had the personnel to do so), we would have been easily promoted.

Slav's team though. *Sigh*. I have a question. When did people know that we were going to be in consideration for the automatics? QPR away for me, but I would be interested in the thoughts of others.

Was that the 2-3 last minute Livermore goal?

Probably Blues away for me scoring two late goals to win it 2-3.

Agree with the Big Dave stuff too. A back 4 of Holgate - Dawson - Hegazi - Gibbs should have been a lot more solid than it was.

Think the 2-3 was under DM. Around the Villa away game. Slav won 2 0 at QPR early season

Thought we were decent bets for auto very early in Slavs reign. Even when we unluckily lost 1-0 at Leeds
Reply
#20
(08-04-2026, 06:28 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-04-2026, 02:46 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-04-2026, 02:04 PM)Squid Wrote: The defence and how they were coached let Moore's team down. Too many 1 - 1's were our undoing. Had we been even slightly solid at the back (and we had the personnel to do so), we would have been easily promoted.

Slav's team though. *Sigh*. I have a question. When did people know that we were going to be in consideration for the automatics? QPR away for me, but I would be interested in the thoughts of others.

Was that the 2-3 last minute Livermore goal?

Probably Blues away for me scoring two late goals to win it 2-3.

Agree with the Big Dave stuff too. A back 4 of Holgate - Dawson - Hegazi - Gibbs should have been a lot more solid than it was.

Think the 2-3 was under DM. Around the Villa away game. Slav won 2 0 at QPR early season

Thought we were decent bets for auto very early in Slavs reign. Even when we unluckily lost 1-0 at Leeds

Yes, the 2-3 was under Moore. The 2 - 0 at QPR was the sort of imperious performance that indicates that more is to come and they just couldn't deal with Pereira at all. However, I will argue that Austin played a key role at that season. Most of the goals he scored got us points we wouldn't have otherwise received.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: