Bany
#21
I can't criticise the club or player for injuries. No one wants this.

It's still a disastrous signing, however. It's just unfortunate.
Reply
#22
(08-02-2026, 04:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I checked on wiki to see if he does exist. 

93 games in six years.  15.5 games a year. 

Victor Anichebe managed 19.5 over 11 years

and 18.5 during his three year vacation with us.

That's not entirely fair OF.

21-22 - he played 17/32 games (but was an 18yo that came into the team during the season - he played 15 of the last 17 when he came into the side) 
22-23 - 25/32 games - but missed 2 games due to suspension 
23-24 - 14/18 games - 1 game due to suspension - before transferring to Randers and played 8/15 - missing the last 7 games due to injury
24-25 - 15/17 games before transferring to us.

It's a little harsh to say he was a crock when we signed him - since coming into the team aged 18 he had the opportunity to feature in 101 games missing 20 games, 3 of which were due to suspensions.  Of the 17 games he missed, they were usually just 1 game here or there which isn't unusual for such a young player, and may have been rotation given what his ex coach said... He only missed more than 2 successive games on 1 occasion, an ankle injury at the end of the 23/24 season which he then came back from and played regularly until his move to us.

I have no idea how good Bany is, and I have no idea if his body is made of breadsticks or what, but given how successful the scouting was for Heggem, Campbell, Price, Heggebo, Diakite etc... I am sure we must have seen something to justify the outlay. All I do know is that he has been desperately, desperately unlucky since he arrived.
Reply
#23
(08-03-2026, 12:53 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2026, 04:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I checked on wiki to see if he does exist. 

93 games in six years.  15.5 games a year. 

Victor Anichebe managed 19.5 over 11 years

and 18.5 during his three year vacation with us.

That's not entirely fair OF.

21-22 - he played 17/32 games (but was an 18yo that came into the team during the season - he played 15 of the last 17 when he came into the side) 
22-23 - 25/32 games - but missed 2 games due to suspension 
23-24 - 14/18 games - 1 game due to suspension - before transferring to Randers and played 8/15 - missing the last 7 games due to injury
24-25 - 15/17 games before transferring to us.

It's a little harsh to say he was a crock when we signed him - since coming into the team aged 18 he had the opportunity to feature in 101 games missing 20 games, 3 of which were due to suspensions.  Of the 17 games he missed, they were usually just 1 game here or there which isn't unusual for such a young player, and may have been rotation given what his ex coach said... He only missed more than 2 successive games on 1 occasion, an ankle injury at the end of the 23/24 season which he then came back from and played regularly until his move to us.

I have no idea how good Bany is, and I have no idea if his body is made of breadsticks or what, but given how successful the scouting was for Heggem, Campbell, Price, Heggebo, Diakite etc... I am sure we must have seen something to justify the outlay. All I do know is that he has been desperately, desperately unlucky since he arrived.

Voice of reason as per.

There will be no one more frustrated by the situation than Bany. Doubly frustrating when absolutely everything you hear coming from within the club indicates he's a talent.
Reply
#24
(08-03-2026, 01:14 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 12:53 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2026, 04:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I checked on wiki to see if he does exist. 

93 games in six years.  15.5 games a year. 

Victor Anichebe managed 19.5 over 11 years

and 18.5 during his three year vacation with us.

That's not entirely fair OF.

21-22 - he played 17/32 games (but was an 18yo that came into the team during the season - he played 15 of the last 17 when he came into the side) 
22-23 - 25/32 games - but missed 2 games due to suspension 
23-24 - 14/18 games - 1 game due to suspension - before transferring to Randers and played 8/15 - missing the last 7 games due to injury
24-25 - 15/17 games before transferring to us.

It's a little harsh to say he was a crock when we signed him - since coming into the team aged 18 he had the opportunity to feature in 101 games missing 20 games, 3 of which were due to suspensions.  Of the 17 games he missed, they were usually just 1 game here or there which isn't unusual for such a young player, and may have been rotation given what his ex coach said... He only missed more than 2 successive games on 1 occasion, an ankle injury at the end of the 23/24 season which he then came back from and played regularly until his move to us.

I have no idea how good Bany is, and I have no idea if his body is made of breadsticks or what, but given how successful the scouting was for Heggem, Campbell, Price, Heggebo, Diakite etc... I am sure we must have seen something to justify the outlay. All I do know is that he has been desperately, desperately unlucky since he arrived.

Voice of reason as per.

There will be no one more frustrated by the situation than Bany. Doubly frustrating when absolutely everything you hear coming from within the club indicates he's a talent.

What? Do you think the club are going to come out and say - ‘he’s a crock of shit and we’ve wasted over 3 million quid’?
Reply
#25
(08-03-2026, 01:19 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 01:14 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 12:53 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2026, 04:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I checked on wiki to see if he does exist. 

93 games in six years.  15.5 games a year. 

Victor Anichebe managed 19.5 over 11 years

and 18.5 during his three year vacation with us.

That's not entirely fair OF.

21-22 - he played 17/32 games (but was an 18yo that came into the team during the season - he played 15 of the last 17 when he came into the side) 
22-23 - 25/32 games - but missed 2 games due to suspension 
23-24 - 14/18 games - 1 game due to suspension - before transferring to Randers and played 8/15 - missing the last 7 games due to injury
24-25 - 15/17 games before transferring to us.

It's a little harsh to say he was a crock when we signed him - since coming into the team aged 18 he had the opportunity to feature in 101 games missing 20 games, 3 of which were due to suspensions.  Of the 17 games he missed, they were usually just 1 game here or there which isn't unusual for such a young player, and may have been rotation given what his ex coach said... He only missed more than 2 successive games on 1 occasion, an ankle injury at the end of the 23/24 season which he then came back from and played regularly until his move to us.

I have no idea how good Bany is, and I have no idea if his body is made of breadsticks or what, but given how successful the scouting was for Heggem, Campbell, Price, Heggebo, Diakite etc... I am sure we must have seen something to justify the outlay. All I do know is that he has been desperately, desperately unlucky since he arrived.

Voice of reason as per.

There will be no one more frustrated by the situation than Bany. Doubly frustrating when absolutely everything you hear coming from within the club indicates he's a talent.

What? Do you think the club are going to come out and say - ‘he’s a crock of shit and we’ve wasted over 3 million quid’?

You know as well as I do that when a player isn't up to it word gets out, not through official channels. A certain Frabotta springs to mind.
Reply
#26
And it’s not the club saying things in an official capacity - usually it’s journalists or people with contacts within the club who are passing on personal thoughts. As TJ says, when players are categorically not up to it you usually hear it, in Bany’s case the comments have generally been that he has a lot of talent and wants to succeed but is just having a torrid time with injuries.

I swear we have some fans who want us to release him just so they can say they were right when they judged him as shit after one injury, more than they want us to develop a decent talent
Reply
#27
(08-03-2026, 02:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: And it’s not the club saying things in an official capacity - usually it’s journalists or people with contacts within the club who are passing on personal thoughts. As TJ says, when players are categorically not up to it you usually hear it, in Bany’s case the comments have generally been that he has a lot of talent and wants to succeed but is just having a torrid time with injuries.

I swear we have some fans who want us to release him just so they can say they were right when they judged him as shit after one injury, more than they want us to develop a decent talent

Agree with this sentiment and hope, but I remember reading a warning when we signed him that he had terrific talent but would struggle physically in the English league. 
Seems to have been a correct opinion.
Reply
#28
(08-03-2026, 08:23 PM)shadman Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 02:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: And it’s not the club saying things in an official capacity - usually it’s journalists or people with contacts within the club who are passing on personal thoughts. As TJ says, when players are categorically not up to it you usually hear it, in Bany’s case the comments have generally been that he has a lot of talent and wants to succeed but is just having a torrid time with injuries.

I swear we have some fans who want us to release him just so they can say they were right when they judged him as shit after one injury, more than they want us to develop a decent talent

Agree with this sentiment and hope, but I remember reading a warning when we signed him that he had terrific talent but would struggle physically in the English league. 
Seems to have been a correct opinion.
But he has barely played in the English League, so we are none the wiser.
Reply
#29
(08-03-2026, 08:37 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 08:23 PM)shadman Wrote:
(08-03-2026, 02:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: And it’s not the club saying things in an official capacity - usually it’s journalists or people with contacts within the club who are passing on personal thoughts. As TJ says, when players are categorically not up to it you usually hear it, in Bany’s case the comments have generally been that he has a lot of talent and wants to succeed but is just having a torrid time with injuries.

I swear we have some fans who want us to release him just so they can say they were right when they judged him as shit after one injury, more than they want us to develop a decent talent

Agree with this sentiment and hope, but I remember reading a warning when we signed him that he had terrific talent but would struggle physically in the English league. 
Seems to have been a correct opinion.
But he has barely played in the English League, so we are none the wiser.

We are wiser as he keeps picking up injuries in games & training. It's the intensity of the English league (including training) he seems to struggle with. We were warned.
Reply
#30
No matter how you try to sugar-coat the situation, the fact is we bought a player who isn't fit for purpose. Unlucky for him, unlucky for the club, but money wasted until he gets fit, plays and shows some talent.

It's not even a Dike situation, because Daryl had an impact when he played and could arguably have been used more in the last season. Bany hasn't been involved at all. Even Shaun Cunnington managed 8 starts in his two seasons.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: