Tax rises for social care
#1
I am 100% in.

I have seen far too many times people's lifetime assets be stripped to £23k just because they have the bad luck to be very ill or dependent.

I agree with Burnham's point about it being as bad as USA in that aspect.

Take 5% or 10% of my estate*. I won't be here to care.

* But leave my Cayman Islands accounts and my superyacht alone
Reply
#2
It certainly needs addressing and fair play to Burnham for looking at it. Doesn't always have to be via taxation. Maybe a long-term care insurance scheme like they have in Germany
Reply
#3
Long long overdue
I do hope they can all be like adults & agree to a solution to this one

Years ago it was rare to see a private care home
The council ran them & were known as old peoples homes

Now those in receipt of benefits who have to pay to stay are giving state money to the millionaire owners
Instead could be going back in the council pot
Charge a fortune and pay staff peanuts
Reply
#4
You are right Pipkins. The private sector has made a lot of money out of care with asset stripping, hedge funds common in the past. Here is one
BBC News - Four Seasons Health Care goes into administration - BBC News
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-4810...=deep-link

As a principle I don't think profit should be made out of the sick and the elderly. But as a realist, most of the national scandals have been in the public sector and private doesn't always equal bad. There should be a mechanism where private providers shouldn't be able to make more than 10% on public sector contracts.

Will be interesting to where the Casey and Burnham work goes.
Reply
#5
There must have been 20 reviews into this situation in the last couple decades and nothing ever changes, despite it arguably being the biggest issue currently facing the government.

Burnham’s policy makes sense (as it did under May and previous suggestions) and in the long run it ought to save people money and ensure money goes into care over profits.

The next 3 years are Labour’s only chance to be bold. Whilst there will be rebels, the Greens and Lib Dems will broadly support many such measures meaning even a large number of rebels will fail to stop them passing. No party will have a majority like this for decades IMO, so Labour need to use theirs to make the changes people want to see (even if they don’t really know what they are) before it’s too late.
Reply
#6
We already have an NI increase for social care and a Council Tax precept for Social Care. Neither seems to have made any difference whatsoever. Perhaps we ought to look at how existing resources are being deployed, perhaps we ought to look at an alternative private insurance market too. There’s no guarantee that simply increasing taxes for everybody will solve anything.
Reply
#7
(07-29-2026, 06:18 PM)CIM Wrote: It certainly needs addressing and fair play to Burnham for looking at it. Doesn't always have to be via taxation. Maybe a long-term care insurance scheme like they have in Germany

Same thing isn't it? Just one goes to the state, one goes in the pockets of shareholders.

NHS model of elderly social care is required for as Burnham suggests. And I would rather know it's 10% of my wealth than pretty much all of it as it is now.

AB is doing a good job at appealing to the middle classes at the moment.

(07-30-2026, 08:17 PM)Protheroe Wrote: We already have an NI increase for social care and a Council Tax precept for Social Care. Neither seems to have made any difference whatsoever. Perhaps we ought to look at how existing resources are being deployed, perhaps we ought to look at an alternative private insurance market too. There’s no guarantee that simply increasing taxes for everybody will solve anything.

That social care budget is largely swallowed by rising working age care issues. A levy/tax ringfenced for old age/end of life care is essential on its own.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#8
I don’t doubt that. But we have already been sold a “Social Care Tax” twice already.
Reply
#9
Third time's a charm!!
Reply
#10
Social care needs fundamental reform, including funding whether that's from tax or not. Just raising employer NI (goes into the general tax pot, not ringfenced) and the surcharge (doesn't work given that specific councils are already so stretched that 2% does fuck all) is not going to fix it, trying to pretend they are by citing it as a reason and also complaining about further tax changes is a deliberately obtuse argument.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)