Bottom line now the emotions have settled.
#11
(07-16-2026, 06:56 AM)Mullers Wrote: It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.
That is the most sensible appraisal I have heard or read. They were failing in front of TTs eyes and he couldn’t do anything about it other than protect what we already had. We did not have a player or a captain on the pitch capable of moving them up. I suppose you could argue he could have taken Wharton.
Reply
#12
(07-16-2026, 07:23 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 06:56 AM)Mullers Wrote: It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.
That is the most sensible appraisal I have heard or read. They were failing in front of TTs eyes and he couldn’t do anything about it other than protect what we already had. We did not have a player or a captain on the pitch capable of moving them up. I suppose you could argue he could have taken Wharton.

Fair enough points but Tuchel had options. His first mistake was waiting almost 20mins and doing nothing, he then made the wrong sub when the game was crying out for control in midfield. It's not like he didn't have options, Mainoo on the bench (our best player from the semi against the Dutch two years ago) and even Jordan Henderson, a Foden, Palmer or Wharton would have also helped regain control and get us on the ball more but it was Tuchel's choice to leave those guys at home (Wharton in particular a strange choice after this season).
Reply
#13
(07-16-2026, 07:23 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 06:56 AM)Mullers Wrote: It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.
That is the most sensible appraisal I have heard or read. They were failing in front of TTs eyes and he couldn’t do anything about it other than protect what we already had. We did not have a player or a captain on the pitch capable of moving them up. I suppose you could argue he could have taken Wharton.

We had Arsenals vice captain on the bench. 

Ball carriers in; Madueke, Rashford and Mainoo, on the bench. 

Out balls in; Watkins, Rashford, Saka, Madueke, on the bench. 

A target man of sorts in Toney, on the bench. 

So he could have done lots of things, he CHOSE to protect the lead, it failed. It's on him.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
(07-16-2026, 07:39 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 07:23 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 06:56 AM)Mullers Wrote: It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.
That is the most sensible appraisal I have heard or read. They were failing in front of TTs eyes and he couldn’t do anything about it other than protect what we already had. We did not have a player or a captain on the pitch capable of moving them up. I suppose you could argue he could have taken Wharton.

We had Arsenals vice captain on the bench. 

Ball carriers in; Madueke, Rashford and Mainoo, on the bench. 

Out balls in; Watkins, Rashford, Saka, Madueke, on the bench. 

A target man of sorts in Toney, on the bench. 

So he could have done lots of things, he CHOSE to protect the lead, it failed. It's on him.

Correct.

I expect to see Tuchel given his marching orders. This wasn’t a “the better team won” moment, this was a completely self inflected defeat.

Argentina have some talented players and may well have fought their way back into the game, but we basically opened the door for them and invited them in.
Reply
#15
(07-16-2026, 07:43 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 07:39 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 07:23 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 06:56 AM)Mullers Wrote: It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.
That is the most sensible appraisal I have heard or read. They were failing in front of TTs eyes and he couldn’t do anything about it other than protect what we already had. We did not have a player or a captain on the pitch capable of moving them up. I suppose you could argue he could have taken Wharton.

We had Arsenals vice captain on the bench. 

Ball carriers in; Madueke, Rashford and Mainoo, on the bench. 

Out balls in; Watkins, Rashford, Saka, Madueke, on the bench. 

A target man of sorts in Toney, on the bench. 

So he could have done lots of things, he CHOSE to protect the lead, it failed. It's on him.

Correct.

I expect to see Tuchel given his marching orders. This wasn’t a “the better team won” moment, this was a completely self inflected defeat.

Argentina have some talented players and may well have fought their way back into the game, but we basically opened the door for them and invited them in.

Agree 100%.
Reply
#16
Ironically we didn't need more defenders on the pitch. The game was lost in Midfield. Rice hadn't got the energy and Anderson couldn't do it on his own. We gave up too much of the ball to their midfield players and allowed them to get it out wide to Messi and the other wide players.
We needed a ratter in midfield and didn't have one.
The bigget ballsy thing to do, if you wanted to try and hold on (which I don't believe in at all unless there's say 5/10 mins left when you score) would have been to have taken Kane Rogers and Bellingham off and just absolutely packed the midfield. Telling everyone who came on to get 10 yards further up the field and every time you get the opportunity you foul them. Just like they did first half.
Instead we we filled it full of defenders and went 10 yards further back.
For a supposed world class manager it borders on being a sackable offence for me. As said above, we did well to hold on to the hydration break, how on earth you can still think that was the correct tactic AFTER that is mind boggling.
Reply
#17
What nobody has mentioned is the fact that no team playing in the semi-finals of the World Cup with a day's more rest than their opposition has ever lost a semi-final. I thought that a lot of the players looked fucked not long after Gordon's goal and I suspect Tuchel did too. Whether he should have brought on more midfielders or attacking replacements is a moot point. The energy had gone, whereas the Argentinians - sure, part-fuelled by the necessity of having to go for it - certainly had more drive than us. It''s not the only reason but that extra day in a draining tournament matters and the statistics prove it.
Reply
#18
(07-16-2026, 08:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: What nobody has mentioned is the fact that no team playing in the semi-finals of the World Cup with a day's more rest than their opposition has ever lost a semi-final. I thought that a lot of the players looked fucked not long after Gordon's goal and I suspect Tuchel did too. Whether he should have brought on more midfielders or attacking replacements is a moot point. The energy had gone, whereas the Argentinians - sure, part-fuelled by the necessity of having to go for it - certainly had more drive than us. It''s not the only reason but that extra day in a draining tournament matters and the statistics prove it.

Argentina's QF was the last one to kick off after we'd already beaten Norway?
Reply
#19
Last night was on him and he's said so.

It's England we always show the bigger opponents too much respect. Right from the Anthems you could see how much more fired up they were than us. As I said before they are the Dingles to England's Albion.

All rather predictable once we scored.
Reply
#20
It’s like a broken record hearing some of you whining about Tuchel needs to be sacked.
We’ve had 60 years of this without a football messiah.
Getting within 10 minutes or so of the final does not mean we are shit.
Different animal international football is at the end of the competition as it’s knock out. It’s a brutal way to decide success.
Tuchel will learn, but honestly just going on about sacking him is just crybaby antics and rinse and repeat nonsense which has seen 60 years of trophies missed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)