VAR has solved nothing?
#21
"A player has a right to put himself between the ball and the opponent"  

Correct.

He then hung his leg out and engineered a half arsed collision which the defending player could not avoid.

He cheated.  I can't remember if he was booked, but he should have been. 


This nonsense has been perpetuated by imbecilic twats like Shearer trying to rewrite the rules of football with drivel like " there was contact, he had every right to go down". 

This is why I've not listened to the commentary on any televised game for years. 
Reply
#22
(07-13-2026, 07:52 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: A player has a right to put himself between the ball and the opponent.

The Egyptian disallowed goal was probably the biggest disgrace I've witnessed with VAR. It's corruption, and it's not even hidden.

It wasn’t a penalty, he engineered getting ‘tripped’ up. For once I agree with Old Bugger sorry Baggie Wink this nonsense that Shearer and co spout about having every right to ‘cheat’ sorry go down if the defending player makes contact with the attacker is why you see so many dodgy penalties awarded that in retrospect were dives or dubious to say the least.
Reply
#23
(07-13-2026, 07:52 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: A player has a right to put himself between the ball and the opponent.

The Egyptian disallowed goal was probably the biggest disgrace I've witnessed with VAR. It's corruption, and it's not even hidden.

After the goal VAR ruled out for us at LiVARpool for being offside from a corner! Big Grin
Reply
#24
(07-13-2026, 06:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm amazed at the number of people agreeing with VARs decision on the Spence penalty call.

He gets in front of the defender and shields the ball. It's a foul, and a penalty.

Regardless, it wasn't a clear and obvious error from the referee, as evidenced by the divide on the decision, and therefore the on field decision should have stood.

As for VAR, it's going nowhere, but it is ruining the game. We're in a no better position when human error was allowed. In fact, I'd say more errors are being made by VAR than without it. It needs fucking off.

He gets in front of the defender and iniates contact and falls over. The defender does not place his hands on Spence or attemp to tackle him, it cannot be a foul.
Reply
#25
(07-13-2026, 08:19 AM)Old Fart Wrote: "A player has a right to put himself between the ball and the opponent"  

Correct.

He then hung his leg out and engineered a half arsed collision which the defending player could not avoid.

He cheated.  I can't remember if he was booked, but he should have been. 


This nonsense has been perpetuated by imbecilic twats like Shearer trying to rewrite the rules of football with drivel like " there was contact, he had every right to go down". 

This is why I've not listened to the commentary on any televised game for years. 
I’m sorry but he should not and was not booked, no it wasn’t a penalty because he initiated the foul but he would have gone down anyway because you are told to try and get your leg in front of your opponent, which is what he did the opponent was then always going to run into him but no foul no cheating just something that happens when running at full speed.
Reply
#26
Have to agree that it's not a penalty. The trouble is, in a different game, it could well be given, therefore VAR is still subjective, so, as the OP says has solved nothing.
The scariest thing VAR does, for me, is give already corrupt organisations more opportunity to influence decisions and therefore become more corrupt.
Reply
#27
I thought the referee got all the big decisions correct on Saturday night.
Reply
#28
(07-13-2026, 09:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Have to agree that it's not a penalty. The trouble is, in a different game, it could well be given, therefore VAR is still subjective, so, as the OP says has solved nothing.
The scariest thing VAR does, for me, is give already corrupt organisations more opportunity to influence decisions and therefore become more corrupt.

This in absolute spades.
Reply
#29
I don't think anyone is disputing VAR is corrupt?
Reply
#30
Some on here have lost the purpose of the question, which is the general use of VAR.
Every country can argue issues in a game. Take for instance the way Egypt feel robbed after Argentina beat them last week.
I’m certainly on the fence about it all. It’s taken a lot of spontaneity from the game.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)