Burnham’s win and Reform being sized up?
#81
I don't disagree with the general point so how can I be ignoring your views, however you will not accept on any level that there is an industry out there that is feeding into how to beat the system. You also highlight, as you did the other day, isolated cases that are clearly wrong and need to be addressed, when I show you the actual rules and therefore why this is individual error, then you disappear.

Jacko also highlighted why the wrong type of staff are being employed to manage these decisions, something we both agree on - lack of funding and outsourcing. That goes further to the point of it being individual employees, and crap ones at that, that are being left to manage the rules incorrectly. The rules are clear - that lad should have been granted his funding with no further need for assessment. An individual chose to ignore that and do a shit job
Reply
#82
(07-10-2026, 06:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Losing what argument MICS? As much as I want Burnham to do well he’s been handed the same levers that Starmer had, I’ll be interested to see how different things will be. There are massive long term implications for the left with the timing of this gamble and the panic over Reform has meant our eggs are in one basket. It’s a gamble that wasn’t needed at this point. Let’s hope it works.

And whilst you’re here how about a comment on the Wealth Tax thread that you were shouting for. Explain to us how we’re wrong.

I think that in your eagerness to write polemics, diatribes and use grown up words like prick, goon, fantasist etc,  you have got me mixed up with Derek. I can't ever recall calling for a wealth tax. I have said tax the weatthy more, sure. I have said that cunts that fuck off from the UK because they don't want to pay tax, like Dyson, Radcliffe and loads of others, should be made to pay a huge exit tax, be stripped of their citizenship and never be allowed to return to UK- even for a holiday.

Only Norway have really made a wealth tax work and they are nearly 50 years in. I am pretty much in line with this conclusion.
https://www.imidaily.com/tax/the-10-coun...-who-pays/

But, hey ho. It wouldnt be the first time you've made up shit about me- like all these insults that I've supposed to have given you. When I challenged you, you came up with precisely zero.

It would be quite amazing to see the anger and vitriol you seem to have developed for Derek and I to be dished out to Tories. Or even our resident cultist libetrarian Proth, albeit you and he are bedfellows on a lot of things which ought to sound alarm bells for you. Both of you are also never wrong 

As I said, twas ever the way with the Labour right- reserving their special type of bile for people in the Labour Party that don't agree with them.
Reply
#83
That’s because the Labour Party was originally established precisely to avoid being a far left organisation.
Reply
#84
I'm afraid MICS that your call for a Norway style tax is, as usual, one-eyed. You don't consider the exceptions that come with it or even that they don't have IHT because of it. Also comparing a nation that has a population of about half of London and less than 10% of the UK is completely illogical. However your words, as considered as they appear, are simply deluded and not researched at all.

Your constant sneering comments around grown ups and the shouting when it is good approach to politics doesn't take into account the bigger picture. Reform have peaked, Labour have delivered on a number of fronts and you have followed the media lines into thinking Starmer is the worst PM ever, he's not even the 5th worse of the last decade.

And your view of the Labour right is pathetic, who do you think have got Labour into power over the last 40 years? Corbyn was the pin up and unlike some of the gobshites about being Labour left on here I actually voted for him.

You haven't come up with one credible solution to the countries problems apart from change manager. Football politics at its best. I'd be making as much noise as you can now because you will soon find out changing manager is not necessarily the future. I hope it is for all of our sakes.
Reply
#85
(07-10-2026, 04:55 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-10-2026, 06:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Losing what argument MICS? As much as I want Burnham to do well he’s been handed the same levers that Starmer had, I’ll be interested to see how different things will be. There are massive long term implications for the left with the timing of this gamble and the panic over Reform has meant our eggs are in one basket. It’s a gamble that wasn’t needed at this point. Let’s hope it works.

And whilst you’re here how about a comment on the Wealth Tax thread that you were shouting for. Explain to us how we’re wrong.

I think that in your eagerness to write polemics, diatribes and use grown up words like prick, goon, fantasist etc,  you have got me mixed up with Derek. I can't ever recall calling for a wealth tax. I have said tax the weatthy more, sure. I have said that cunts that fuck off from the UK because they don't want to pay tax, like Dyson, Radcliffe and loads of others, should be made to pay a huge exit tax, be stripped of their citizenship and never be allowed to return to UK- even for a holiday.

Only Norway have really made a wealth tax work and they are nearly 50 years in. I am pretty much in line with this conclusion.
https://www.imidaily.com/tax/the-10-coun...-who-pays/

But, hey ho. It wouldnt be the first time you've made up shit about me- like all these insults that I've supposed to have given you. When I challenged you, you came up with precisely zero.

It would be quite amazing to see the anger and vitriol you seem to have developed for Derek and I to be dished out to Tories. Or even our resident cultist libetrarian Proth, albeit you and he are bedfellows on a lot of things which ought to sound alarm bells for you. Both of you are also never wrong 

As I said, twas ever the way with the Labour right- reserving their special type of bile for people in the Labour Party that don't agree with them.

Norway's wealth tax is justified by balancing it against a comparatively generous income tax, same as Switzerland. It also raises fuck all. When the current Norwegian government raised the wealth tax in 2022 by 10% from 1% to 1.1% the tax receipts from the wealth tax dropped because wealth outside of land is very mobile, they were targeting €130m and ended up losing close to €550m.
Reply
#86
And here is why being a grown up isn’t as much of an insult as you think it is, because it means experience and knowledge of what works because we’ve probably seen it tried and failed at some point in our lifetime. MICS is very exposed now because the one thing that we needed to get through the short term, stability, has been thrown out the window for populism.

I genuinely hope Burnham makes a difference but I’ll be honest I think he is going to get torn apart over three years. Which is also why I wanted them to hold fire and let Starmer take the flack for as long as he could. Another year and we will see Reform imploding which gets rid of the current panic but we are where we are now.
Reply
#87
The irony of those saying come up with a solution, is the fact they aren’t coming up with a solution, they merely offering the same solutions that have brought to where we currently find ourselves. Scratching their heads as to why UK politics has splintered, why popularism has suddenly taken hold and the country is in a complete mess politically since Brexit,

Getting lectured by a man who campaigned for Brexit, telling all those that would listen on the doorstep that leaving the EU would make the country better, and better off! Then we have the other Tory with a a blue and red half and half scarf, declaring things were ok under Starmer and he just needed time, when the ‘mastermind’ behind his election has listed the same failings that goons and fantasists have pointed out would see him fail even before the ballot boxes had closed.

Forgive me for not taking their political advice on anything.
Reply
#88
You answer the question without actually realising it Dekka, the instability that we have had from the GFC, from Brexit, from Covid, from changing PMs every couple of years or less is exactly the reason we are here. The austerity that was hoisted upon us that has directly led to the shite or no services available is a massive part in this, the damage caused to our trade from Brexit is another massive part of it.

The problem comes when we expect all of those things to be fixed in 2 years with “We want fluffy news” type of politics. Let’s hope that Burnham carries on the progress that has been made at home and internationally by Starmer. We needed stable more than anything at this point and we have got bored as a nation.
Reply
#89
(07-11-2026, 07:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You answer the question without actually realising it Dekka, the instability that we have had from the GFC, from Brexit, from Covid, from changing PMs every couple of years or less is exactly the reason we are here. The austerity that was hoisted upon us that has directly led to the shite or no services available is a massive part in this, the damage caused to our trade from Brexit is another massive part of it.

The problem comes when we expect all of those things to be fixed in 2 years with “We want fluffy news” type of politics. Let’s hope that Burnham carries on the progress that has been made at home and internationally by Starmer. We needed stable more than anything at this point and we have got bored as a nation.

Brexit happened because a majority that voted were not happy with the direction of the country. Where Proth is correct is when he says that Labour offered the same austerity measures as the Tories revelled in when Brown lost power. As much as I thought Brexit was an idiotic decision to have made, you can’t pretend that the two main parties are not to blame for offering no real alternative to vote for and the chaos that has subsequently happened. If politics was offering what people wanted in the UK then there would be no gaps and gripes that Reform or the Greens could fill/address. 

Tinkering around the edges, with trickle down economics hasn’t worked for the majority and never will. 

More of the same as Sunak offered is what Labour have so far delivered, and very few were happy with that direction. You say things take time, but Labour has three more years, and was walking towards defeat at the next election under Starmer, at best a hung parliament, so change was necessary. When all you offer is pretty much the same policies as Sunak with a softer face, and then say it takes time, you miss the point, people rejected the Tories not only for the chaos but also because people’s living standards and opportunities have stagnated or gone backwards for twenty years. Dare I say you’re out of touch with where the country is, hankering after 1997 2.0 and that’s not going to work.
Reply
#90
I don’t miss any point because you’re not making one. You moan about everything but don’t know what you want apart from ‘not this’.

Billionaires are as much a distraction as immigrants, they are not the solution. Big corporations are the problem but they’re global entities and until there is an agreement on global taxation standardisation you’ll not get anywhere.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: