So was it the best England game ever?
#21
Nothing of the sort. Obviously you're new here
Reply
#22
(07-06-2026, 09:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 08:51 AM)MrBater Wrote: It's a weird one, it was a performance that in the truest footballing sense wasn't that great. Tactically we were good, Mexico were clueless, once we went have the ball and come at us. However, as a match it transcended pure football and in doing so elevates itself into an unforgettable display of passion, heart and sheer will power. Which in turn makes it one of the best ever....

As a spectacle it's hard to beat, drama, passion, under dog glory...

I just wish I'd been more awake Big Grin

For pretty much all my England supporting life, we've looked exposed tactically. Our players haven't grasped matches with the same ease as other international sides, and it was always blamed on the blood and thunder of the Premier League being very different to the continental divisions. Last night was special for me as it was the first time I've felt England executed Plan A brilliantly, but also cycled into Plans B and C effectively. 

Under Southgate we'd have gone out this morning, there's no way he'd have shown the know-how, nous and bravery to come through that tie. Under Roy, Capello and Sven we'd have lacked the grit, balls and mental strength to even show-up, and going back to the days of Keegan and Hoddle we'd have lacked the in game control.

Whilst I realise Mexico are not a top 10 footballing nation, we absolutely rose to the occasion and put in one hell of a shift.

ALSO.... Raul Jimenez is going to be unstoppable in the Championship next year sadly.

Mexico are literally 10th in world rankings!
Reply
#23
(07-06-2026, 09:51 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:29 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:25 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:14 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For pretty much all my England supporting life, we've looked exposed tactically. Our players haven't grasped matches with the same ease as other international sides, and it was always blamed on the blood and thunder of the Premier League being very different to the continental divisions. Last night was special for me as it was the first time I've felt England executed Plan A brilliantly, but also cycled into Plans B and C effectively. 

Under Southgate we'd have gone out this morning, there's no way he'd have shown the know-how, nous and bravery to come through that tie. Under Roy, Capello and Sven we'd have lacked the grit, balls and mental strength to even show-up, and going back to the days of Keegan and Hoddle we'd have lacked the in game control.

Whilst I realise Mexico are not a top 10 footballing nation, we absolutely rose to the occasion and put in one hell of a shift.

ALSO.... Raul Jimenez is going to be unstoppable in the Championship next year sadly.

Aye, I don't disagree. There have been other times where we've gone down fighting, but last night was more Battle of Britain.

Hard to say about Southgate, as I think he'd have had us cruising to start with, I agree though, no way he'd have got that fight after everything that happened, we'd probably have lost 4-3 in that eternity of injury time.
Dunno why people want to diss Southgate.
Easily the most successful England manager since Alf. Because he got a great team spirit and got players to play at their best. Quite an achievement.
That was a fabulous performance, and I agree one of the best since 66.
Tuchel is impressive. But he's not - yet - achieved anything.

Wasn't said as a diss to Southgate, more of an observation at how we look a very different beast under Tuchel.

You also missed out the fact Southgate's biggest asset was his seeming ability to get incredibly favourable draws in tournaments Big Grin

We really don't. 

Under Tuchel we looked a 'different beast' for about 20 minutes of the Croatia game and then showed great fight yesterday against Mexico, but it's still the round of 16. We were poor against Ghana, beat Panama who lost every game, 2-0 who Southgate's England were beating what.....5-0 by half time a few years back and we scraped past DR Congo.

I want to believe we are a completely different beast now, but I don't see any evidence of it. 

We will find out if we're a different beast when we come up against Argentina or France, as the criticism of Southgate was always that he couldn't do it against the top teams in the world. The great thing after yesterday's result is that the fans are buzzing and this has a big impact.

Have to disagree with you Sliced - the reason I consider TT's England a different beast to GS's is that the latter's sides were usually prepped with Plan A to counter an opposition and relied on the individuals to produce something, with the focus being on risk free, controlled football. That was fine in the main, but when we played a side our equal we looked stuck in transition and produced a large number of close games that ended in a draw or a narrow defeat.

Tuchel's England are more concerned with playing our game and not being so adaptive to the opposition. We are more aggressive, more proactive and want to gain territory up the field. We use pace and running a lot more, whereas Southgate's England were more methodical and slower in the build up. In attack especially I think you can see we have specific attacking patterns, something I always felt we lacked under GS. I think we know how we can hurt any team going forward and have confidence that our system will create chances, whereas under GS we had fewer attacking patterns and usually waited patiently for something to fall for us - which against lesser opposition it usually did, but against our equals it didn't.

Overall, Southgate's teams were all about being steady, securing the clean sheet and seeing what happened... Tuchel is more about implementing a style of play successfully knowing it can work in both attack and defence.
Reply
#24
Yes. Certainly the best England game I can recall.

The drama of it. We beaten better. We’ve played better. But all round that’s the best England performance I can recall.
Reply
#25
(07-06-2026, 12:18 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 08:51 AM)MrBater Wrote: It's a weird one, it was a performance that in the truest footballing sense wasn't that great. Tactically we were good, Mexico were clueless, once we went have the ball and come at us. However, as a match it transcended pure football and in doing so elevates itself into an unforgettable display of passion, heart and sheer will power. Which in turn makes it one of the best ever....

As a spectacle it's hard to beat, drama, passion, under dog glory...

I just wish I'd been more awake Big Grin

For pretty much all my England supporting life, we've looked exposed tactically. Our players haven't grasped matches with the same ease as other international sides, and it was always blamed on the blood and thunder of the Premier League being very different to the continental divisions. Last night was special for me as it was the first time I've felt England executed Plan A brilliantly, but also cycled into Plans B and C effectively. 

Under Southgate we'd have gone out this morning, there's no way he'd have shown the know-how, nous and bravery to come through that tie. Under Roy, Capello and Sven we'd have lacked the grit, balls and mental strength to even show-up, and going back to the days of Keegan and Hoddle we'd have lacked the in game control.

Whilst I realise Mexico are not a top 10 footballing nation, we absolutely rose to the occasion and put in one hell of a shift.

ALSO.... Raul Jimenez is going to be unstoppable in the Championship next year sadly.

Mexico are literally 10th in world rankings!

They were 14th going into this morning's game!
Reply
#26
(07-06-2026, 12:21 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 12:18 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 09:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-06-2026, 08:51 AM)MrBater Wrote: It's a weird one, it was a performance that in the truest footballing sense wasn't that great. Tactically we were good, Mexico were clueless, once we went have the ball and come at us. However, as a match it transcended pure football and in doing so elevates itself into an unforgettable display of passion, heart and sheer will power. Which in turn makes it one of the best ever....

As a spectacle it's hard to beat, drama, passion, under dog glory...

I just wish I'd been more awake Big Grin

For pretty much all my England supporting life, we've looked exposed tactically. Our players haven't grasped matches with the same ease as other international sides, and it was always blamed on the blood and thunder of the Premier League being very different to the continental divisions. Last night was special for me as it was the first time I've felt England executed Plan A brilliantly, but also cycled into Plans B and C effectively. 

Under Southgate we'd have gone out this morning, there's no way he'd have shown the know-how, nous and bravery to come through that tie. Under Roy, Capello and Sven we'd have lacked the grit, balls and mental strength to even show-up, and going back to the days of Keegan and Hoddle we'd have lacked the in game control.

Whilst I realise Mexico are not a top 10 footballing nation, we absolutely rose to the occasion and put in one hell of a shift.

ALSO.... Raul Jimenez is going to be unstoppable in the Championship next year sadly.

Mexico are literally 10th in world rankings!

They were 14th going into this morning's game!

Apologies, they're 10th now! Fuck knows!!! Huh
Reply
#27
It's not outrageous to acknowledge the great job Southgate did in rebuilding after the 2016 disaster and taking us further in tournaments on a more regular basis than most under 35 can remember.

Whilst also acknowledging that the game last night is one that under Southgate, we tended to come out on the wrong side of as evidenced by our results against limited but committed sides like Croatia and Italy.

Both things can be true, it's OK.
Reply
#28
(07-06-2026, 12:26 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: It's not outrageous to acknowledge the great job Southgate did in rebuilding after the 2016 disaster and taking us further in tournaments on a more regular basis than most under 35 can remember.

Whilst also acknowledging that the game last night is one that under Southgate, we tended to come out on the wrong side of as evidenced by our results against limited but committed sides like Croatia and Italy.

Both things can be true, it's OK.

Well said.
Reply
#29
As someone who goes bank to the 70s and didn’t see England until the 82 World Cup I find Southgate bashing a peculiar trait.
Two semi final penalty shootout losses is all I saw at the latter stages of competitions until he came along. Two finals and a semi final defeat in 6 years was better than I’d seen in the previous 44 years as a fan.
He got us very close.
Regards Tuchel he seems astute and it’s a better watch, but lose to Norway and the knives will be out. I think without winning it only a heroic close call at semi final or final stages will appease the media.
Reply
#30
(07-06-2026, 12:48 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: As someone who goes bank to the 70s and didn’t see England until the 82 World Cup I find Southgate bashing a peculiar trait.
Two semi final penalty shootout losses is all I saw at the latter stages of competitions until he came along. Two finals and a semi final defeat in 6 years was better than I’d seen in the previous 44 years as a fan.
He got us very close.
Regards Tuchel he seems astute and it’s a better watch, but lose to Norway and the knives will be out. I think without winning it only a heroic close call at semi final or final stages will appease the media.

Agree, Bertie. Me too. I remember England not even being at some World Cups, I remember going out of others over controversial goals, disallowed goals and some tournaments were only reported on for trouble on the streets or the circus around some mediocre player's wives greedily grabbing their 15 minutes worth. Southgate really did unite the players, and us as fans and we began to believe it might actually be possible for us to win it. Obviously I hope Tuchel goes up another notch but I'm grateful for us being a proper football nation again.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: