Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-04-2026, 06:34 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-04-2026, 06:16 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: Coming from an Irish Catholic family, Fintan O’Toole’s book ‘We don’t know ourselves’ is a must read around the control of the Church on State. It’s a brilliant book, if not hugely depressing and sadly in our very recent history.
Small Things Like These, a Cillian Murphy film on Netflix, covers the story of a Magdalene house and is quite a tough watch too.
The Magdelene Sisters was quite harrowing too.
Makes me laugh when I see people all nostalgic for the "good old days".
Posts: 7,461
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
I often watch Long Lost Family on ITV, frequently but now always the legacy of forced adoption. Worth remembering men suffered massively too, often the untold stories.
Anyone and everyone who had any part in it - cunts
Raw Sausage
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(07-04-2026, 11:24 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I often watch Long Lost Family on ITV, frequently but now always the legacy of forced adoption. Worth remembering men suffered massively too, often the untold stories.
Anyone and everyone who had any part in it - cunts
As the saying goes “ You can make good people do good things and make evil people do evil things. But to make good people do evil things you need religion”.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
07-04-2026, 02:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-04-2026, 02:44 PM by Tom Joad 25.)
I think when referring to religion as a generally repressive force it is important to realise it is predominantly the Abrahamic ones. The Eastern religions are much more of a philosophy and concerned mostly with self growth and empathy.
I had a generally good upbringing at school, predominantly by first nuns, then Marist brothers. I can honestly say I never saw any inappropriate sexual shenanigans, although we were probably so grimey you couldn't tell the lads from the wenches. There were a few beatings dished out mind but I believe that was the order of the day all over. There was a nice cosy feeling to being in the arms of the church but it all fell apart for me when i saw ill children. An all compassionate, all powerful, miracle working Lord wouldnt allow such suffering I dont care how mysterious his ways are.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(07-04-2026, 02:42 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I think when referring to religion as a generally repressive force it is important to realise it is predominantly the Abrahamic ones. The Eastern religions are much more of a philosophy and concerned mostly with self growth and empathy.
I had a generally good upbringing at school, predominantly by first nuns, then Marist brothers. I can honestly say I never saw any inappropriate sexual shenanigans, although we were probably so grimey you couldn't tell the lads from the wenches. There were a few beatings dished out mind but I believe that was the order of the day all over. There was a nice cosy feeling to being in the arms of the church but it all fell apart for me when i saw ill children. An all compassionate, all powerful, miracle working Lord wouldnt allow such suffering I dont care how mysterious his ways are.
True the ones that are more about a lifestyle are much better.
All the people (admittedly less than 5) people I know who went to religious schools hated the way the nuns treated them. Regular beatings and generally being made to feel like they were evil
Mysterious ways - what they tell us to encourage blind faith.
Posts: 1,020
Threads: 31
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
3
Not a big fan of religion. Good for those that need it I guess.
1923 - yellowstone prequel is pretty dark. Makes one wonder about the type of shit that went down in days gone by. Why were people / are people so warped in the name of religion? madness.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
07-06-2026, 09:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-06-2026, 09:20 AM by baggy1.)
Started responding to this a couple of times but paused each time. I was one of the 'forced' adoptions with a side of situation complications thrown in.
One thing that is not covered particularly well in any of the discussions about this was the lack of support from the state that mothers got in those days. About 40 years ago I obtained my file and did a bit of digging so without any particular importance or order here is my knowledge of what happened.
My mom, an Irish Catholic teenager came to England in 1967 to complete teacher training and was away from her family for the 1st time. That Christmas she met up with my Dad and it sounds like she had a bit of a kneetrembler and found herself in the family way soon after. From what it appears my Dad, a Dubh with a fair amount of charm without any substance, was putting it around (I'll cover that in a bit) and didn't feel the need to have his name anywhere near the birth certificate for fear of any maintenance requirements. Because my mom was from the western side of NI she couldn't go home for obvious reasons so found refuge with my Dad's sister whilst she waited until Albion had their last success in a major trophy and then let released me into the world shortly after that.
The records are a little bit sketchy from there but having been born in Kiddy, my mom found herself in one of those women's refuges that you read about in Sparkhill. She was getting regular visits but in November had run out of milk tokens and had no means to keep me, no family to turn to, and no options let to her. I then found myself in a children's home at the age of 2 months old and luckily for me, being the cutest baby in the showroom, I got chosen pretty much straight away.
I visited the care home annually after that with my adopted Mom and Dad to take clothes and presents so can tell you that, looking back, it was a very sad place to be. Rows and rows of cots and prospective parents choosing in the same way people would visit car show rooms. My Mom and Dad gave me a life that was great and, I suspect, many more opportunities than the alternatives on offer.
That is where the file ends and I did some heavy handed digging about 40 years ago and probably did more damage than good. A visit to NI made it clear early on that this was a very well kept secret and I'm not certain that my Mom had ever told anyone. I gathered that she had 'mental issues', as described by the local knowledge base (anyone who has any experience of village life in Ireland will know there is one person that knows everything and everyone) during her post natal days and moved with some of her family over to California. I suspect she had a breakdown and under the circumstances is not surprising. How we view these things today is very different to how they viewed them in the 60s.
Since that point I have met my Dad a couple of times but chose to keep a distance as, on the face of it, it could have become all consuming in the way that some Irish families can. I was welcomed back like the prodigal son but it was intense. It also became very clear that I had multiple half brothers and sisters from my Dad including at least two that had births withing 6 months of mine.
I have spoke to my mom once by phone and that was cold and straight forward. She thought I just wanted medical info, and I guess I upset the apple cart by wading in and finding her brother who I asked to reach out to her. I suspect he never knew.
Some comments on here about religion are right to a degree but not as all-encompassing as people would believe. As they say, different times.
Posts: 7,461
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Incredible read that B1, thanks for sharing that story. A lot to digest, brave of you to articulate all of that
Raw Sausage
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
07-06-2026, 10:38 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-06-2026, 10:38 AM by baggy1.)
Cheers GD, it's very easy to criticise the church and there are some really horrific cases that have come to light but it's very multi-layered. Young mom's didn't get more than the basic state support, and culturally the 'shame' of unwed mothers was embedded in both Ireland and the UK. Add to that the lack of sex and contraceptive education the result was a lot of young girls that had nowhere to turn and were treated appallingly through doing nothing more than what comes naturally to teenagers.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Echo the thanks for sharing, B1.
You're right, it was a multi-layered issue with regards to the whole social set-up and mental health was labelled in very different ways in those days as well. I still think the foundational issues came from the churches and their word at the core and very much drove people attitudes in other direction then. But as alluded to before for those veering even slightly off the "straight and narrow" in many areas of life, there was little or no succour.
Another pertinent example might in the 60s and also probably 70s that men would very likely, if required, go to war for "God and the King". How many nowadays would contemplate doing that for either today?
|