POR V CRO
#1
What a game
Reply
#2
+1. Proper WC tie, that.
Reply
#3
Superb....and what an ending.
Croatia hard done to
Reply
#4
Incredible game ruined at the end by VAR. It's maaaybe flicked his hair on the way through for that (fourth?!) disallowed goal of the game.

Both teams hit the woodwork, lots of saves by the keepers, disallowed goals, end to end action. Fantastic game.
Reply
#5
Just watched the highlights - the disallowed goal from Ronaldo, is as good a goal (I'm aware it didn't stand!) as I've seen this tournament. The touch and deft finish was sublime. Shame it didn't stand. It looked onside to me in the brief replays that were shown.

(07-03-2026, 01:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Incredible game ruined at the end by VAR. It's maaaybe flicked his hair on the way through for that (fourth?!) disallowed goal of the game.

Both teams hit the woodwork, lots of saves by the keepers, disallowed goals, end to end action. Fantastic game.

No issues with the decision at the end, it was offside. But VAR does ruin the game, even when it gets the right decision. It doesn't feel right to have a moment that Croatia had at the end, snatched away due to minimal video evidence and the slightest of touches. 

I'd rather see moments like that stay, even if they're technically against the rules of the game. I know that sounds ridiculous, but football is worse for constant stops for over analysis of every marginal decision in the game.

I know you have to have rules and lines somewhere to police the rules, but what advantages did Croatia gain in that late disallowed goal? The offside rule has been broken for as long as I've been following football. I'm not sure what the answer is, but it isn't what we have now. It's too pernickety.
Reply
#6
(07-03-2026, 06:06 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Just watched the highlights - the disallowed goal from Ronaldo, is as good a goal (I'm aware it didn't stand!) as I've seen this tournament. The touch and deft finish was sublime. Shame it didn't stand. It looked onside to me in the brief replays that were shown.

(07-03-2026, 01:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Incredible game ruined at the end by VAR. It's maaaybe flicked his hair on the way through for that (fourth?!) disallowed goal of the game.

Both teams hit the woodwork, lots of saves by the keepers, disallowed goals, end to end action. Fantastic game.

No issues with the decision at the end, it was offside. But VAR does ruin the game, even when it gets the right decision. It doesn't feel right to have a moment that Croatia had at the end, snatched away due to minimal video evidence and the slightest of touches. 

I'd rather see moments like that stay, even if they're technically against the rules of the game. I know that sounds ridiculous, but football is worse for constant stops for over analysis of every marginal decision in the game.

I know you have to have rules and lines somewhere to police the rules, but what advantages did Croatia gain in that late disallowed goal? The offside rule has been broken for as long as I've been following football. I'm not sure what the answer is, but it isn't what we have now. It's too pernickety.

But it's only offside if it touched the other players head, and to the naked eye that was almost impossible to discern. When and where VAR is choosing to intervene in this tournament is beginning to be a real issue.
Reply
#7
The ball rotation never changed so there is absolutely no evidence that the player touched the ball. We are now getting to the point that we need snicko to see if there was the slightest touch! The only conclusion that I can see is that VAR guessed. Absolutely shocking decision imo.

The game itself was absolutely superb. It never stopped. Brilliant.
Reply
#8
Herein lies the issue. Despite having all the replays available, we've got differing opinions on whether it's offside, or not.

I've never been a fan of VAR. It's not going anywhere and it's here to stay, but it is ruining the flow of games. It's not for me, and I'm glad the Championship is without it, and it's something we won't have to deal with for the foreseeable! It's just another reason why promotion to the PL is an unpalatable reward, despite it being what we all want and the clubs ultimate aim.

It's frustrating when we have games where the officials have cleared fucked up, Portsmouth at home last season as an example, but as annoying and rage inducing as that is, I'd rather suffer the inconsistences of human error throughout the season than put up with VAR.

(07-03-2026, 06:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: We are now getting to the point that we need snicko to see if there was the slightest touch! 

That's already in place. There's motion sensors inside the ball - and was used to make the decision.
Reply
#9
(07-03-2026, 06:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Herein lies the issue. Despite having all the replays available, we've got differing opinions on whether it's offside, or not.

I've never been a fan of VAR. It's not going anywhere and it's here to stay, but it is ruining the flow of games. It's not for me, and I'm glad the Championship is without it, and it's something we won't have to deal with for the foreseeable! It's just another reason why promotion to the PL is an unpalatable reward, despite it being what we all want and the clubs ultimate aim.

It's frustrating when we have games where the officials have cleared fucked up, Portsmouth at home last season as an example, but as annoying and rage inducing as that is, I'd rather suffer the inconsistences of human error throughout the season than put up with VAR.

(07-03-2026, 06:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: We are now getting to the point that we need snicko to see if there was the slightest touch! 

That's already in place. There's motion sensors inside the ball - and was used to make the decision.

Really? So why don't they play it on the big screens then. Show the ball tremor? They draw lines for offside so show the snicko.......The game has gone Tom......
Reply
#10
(07-03-2026, 06:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Herein lies the issue. Despite having all the replays available, we've got differing opinions on whether it's offside, or not.

I've never been a fan of VAR. It's not going anywhere and it's here to stay, but it is ruining the flow of games. It's not for me, and I'm glad the Championship is without it, and it's something we won't have to deal with for the foreseeable! It's just another reason why promotion to the PL is an unpalatable reward, despite it being what we all want and the clubs ultimate aim.

It's frustrating when we have games where the officials have cleared fucked up, Portsmouth at home last season as an example, but as annoying and rage inducing as that is, I'd rather suffer the inconsistences of human error throughout the season than put up with VAR.

(07-03-2026, 06:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: We are now getting to the point that we need snicko to see if there was the slightest touch! 

That's already in place. There's motion sensors inside the ball - and was used to make the decision.

Yes I heard that, begs the question why did the ref have to review it on the monitor if there was incontrovertible evidence from a chip inside the ball.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: