Happy Brexit Day
#71
Translation it was shit but not as shit as predicted! The justification for every Brexiteer still clinging to the notion it was the right decision.

Proth give up, it was an awful decision, supported by those with vested interests and enabled by useful idiots.
Reply
#72
(07-02-2026, 07:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The benchline for success is that we didn't go all destitute, and any measure taken to soften the impact was unneeded with the BoE somehow manipulating the markets with all the data somehow being wrong and what is actually true is in your head.

Totally a sane justification. Meanwhile we're tens of billions of pounds worse off in tax, 6% worse off in economic growth and have relied on population growth over the last 6 years to prop up GDP and economic activity. All the hallmarks of a healthy economy that definitely needed extra red tape to deal with things. But hey, those 10k+ new customs officers are really raking it in.

If the BoE does not exist to manipulate markets, then what is the reason for its existence? Does anyone truly believe the BoE was ever "independent"? Certainly not after 2008, surely.

The conceit that the UK's problems are the result of a sub optimal trade deal for goods is entirely what is holding this country back from the fundamental reform our institutions require. 

Our national debt is not due to Brexit. Our sclerotic record on productivity is not due to Brexit. Our monumentally counter-productive Tax Code is not due to Brexit.  Our lamentable producer-led NHS is not a result of Brexit. Our culture of welfarism is not due to Brexit. Our disastrous record on housing policy is not due to Brexit. Our betrayal of our kids in a University ponzi scheme is not due to Brexit. The hollowing out of our defences is not due to Brexit. Our inability to deport rapists is not due to Brexit. Our cheap and lazy reliance on mass immigration as a short term fix is not due to Brexit.

Anti-Europeans used to use our membership of the EU as a convenient excuse for the failure of government. All government.

Pro-Europeans now use Brexit as a convenient excuse for the failure of government. All government.

What's the common denominator?
Reply
#73
Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?
Reply
#74
When have any Pro-Europeans blamed Brexit for everything? What they do blame Brexit for is making things worse. Tens of billions of pounds of tax per year lost, lost growth, red tape. And I'm sorry but pretending that we didn't use immigration to mask the economic impact of Brexit is ludicrous, that was literally enabled by post-Brexit immigration changes lmao.

And the BoE did not manipulate the market indicators that were used to justify the rate cut and then the rate rise, they are data points from the wider international banking and finance markets. Any suggestion that the BoE had the capacity to manipulate them is hilarious, do you need a tin foil hat? All to avoid admitting Brexit was stupid though I guess.
Reply
#75
(07-02-2026, 08:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?

Proth will only ever judge something is a success or not by the accumulation of money, so expect some guff about a failure of statecraft with a sprinkling of suboptimal trade deals as his only reply.
Reply
#76
(07-02-2026, 08:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?

There were two key areas - reducing immigration and improving the economy.

What do we think happened next?

No wonder the answers are riddled with waffle, because the simple facts are it failed spectacularly
Raw Sausage
Reply
#77
(07-02-2026, 08:36 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: When have any Pro-Europeans blamed Brexit for everything? What they do blame Brexit for is making things worse. Tens of billions of pounds of tax per year lost, lost growth, red tape. And I'm sorry but pretending that we didn't use immigration to mask the economic impact of Brexit is ludicrous, that was literally enabled by post-Brexit immigration changes lmao.

And the BoE did not manipulate the market indicators that were used to justify the rate cut and then the rate rise, they are data points from the wider international banking and finance markets. Any suggestion that the BoE had the capacity to manipulate them is hilarious, do you need a tin foil hat? All to avoid admitting Brexit was stupid though I guess.

I see I can add the BoE to the EU as institutions you have total faith in then. Bravo for you. Less so for everyone not in possession of wealth before the greatest manipulation of markets in history 18 years ago.

(07-02-2026, 08:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?

Personally I'm worse off than I would have otherwise been as a result of the last two governments. I suspect the nation is too.

The simple answer to your question is that government has agency to improve the situation but lacks the balls and the willingness for fundamental reform - which I had mistakenly hoped would follow Brexit. Instead, as I've previously posted, we have become more European in our governance since we left the EU - and largely for that reason we are worse off individually and as a nation.
Reply
#78
(07-02-2026, 10:02 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(07-02-2026, 08:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?

There were two key areas - reducing immigration and improving the economy.

What do we think happened next?

No wonder the answers are riddled with waffle, because the simple facts are it failed spectacularly

The benefit Brexits are coming
Either in 50 years or in the afterlife
This be the verse of the cultists. So it must be true.
Reply
#79
(07-02-2026, 09:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2026, 08:36 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: When have any Pro-Europeans blamed Brexit for everything? What they do blame Brexit for is making things worse. Tens of billions of pounds of tax per year lost, lost growth, red tape. And I'm sorry but pretending that we didn't use immigration to mask the economic impact of Brexit is ludicrous, that was literally enabled by post-Brexit immigration changes lmao.

And the BoE did not manipulate the market indicators that were used to justify the rate cut and then the rate rise, they are data points from the wider international banking and finance markets. Any suggestion that the BoE had the capacity to manipulate them is hilarious, do you need a tin foil hat? All to avoid admitting Brexit was stupid though I guess.

I see I can add the BoE to the EU as institutions you have total faith in then. Bravo for you. Less so for everyone not in possession of wealth before the greatest manipulation of markets in history 18 years ago.

(07-02-2026, 08:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nice deflect - simple question. Are we, as a nation, better or worse off out of the EU?

Personally I'm worse off than I would have otherwise been as a result of the last two governments. I suspect the nation is too.

The simple answer to your question is that government has agency to improve the situation but lacks the balls and the willingness for fundamental reform - which I had mistakenly hoped would follow Brexit. Instead, as I've previously posted, we have become more European in our governance since we left the EU - and largely for that reason we are worse off individually and as a nation.

The nation is worse off.

That’s the simple answer.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#80
And there we have it. The fundamental difference in outlooks
Proth speaks of "I"
You speak of "the nation"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: