The Grauniad headline. Saturday
#61
In the grand scheme of things, you and I debating this isn't overly important, but I said I would read your links and give a thorough response, so that's what I plan to do.
Reply
#62
I can't see as I blame you. Important things that I would be considering given your circumstance would be along the lines of 'where is the next beer coming from?', 'am I likely to end up looking like a tomato by dinner' and 'where are the kids?'
Reply
#63
(06-10-2026, 10:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I can't see as I blame you. Important things that I would be considering given your circumstance would be along the lines of 'where is the next beer coming from?', 'am I likely to end up looking like a tomato by dinner' and 'where are the kids?'

Big Grin hence why it'll probably be later on tonight with a couple of grammatical mistakes!
Reply
#64
(06-08-2026, 01:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-08-2026, 12:34 PM)Jacko Wrote: As a father. Parental responsibility, education and age gates are all that is required imo.

Maybe you should take that smug approach of 'I'm alright Jack' and explain it to the 128 teen suicides (2022) that have been attributed to internet activity here: Online harms? Suicide-related online experience: a UK-wide case series study of young people who die by suicide | Psychological Medicine | Cambridge Core

Or the parents of any future teens that come to harm from the simple act of online scrolling as shown here: Teens still exposed to violence and suicide online despite ruling - BBC News

And maybe you should read the evidence based government paper here: Understanding the impact of smartphones and social media on children and young people: executive summary - GOV.UK

And not even starting on the internet grooming, 'health' and 'beauty' related content, influencers that pour bullshit ideas out for likes, shits and giggles. But you're alright aren't you - these things didn't happen.

The original post, note this is after my suggestions, so I'm blaming parents by rote. Fair enough (and education and lack of age gates).

(06-08-2026, 06:19 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Here you go Jacko, I'll accept that it isn't just right wing bots. See how easy that was, now your turn - do you really think that the government will put a ban on social media for under 16s knowing full well it will be pointless for todays teenagers (future generations will benefit) or do you think that is one of many options that hey have looked at. The report comes out later this year.

And back to the commentary around suicides in teenagers, a very real point, do you think that was the parents fault because they didn't have the right level of parental responsibility in place.

Yes I think there is every chance of a blanket social media ban for under 16s under this clueless government because it is the easy thing to do, they have a real-time, in action case study in Australia and their Online Safety Act has failed, instead of the obvious repeal, I see them doubling down?

Answer to the other quite obviously heartbreaking question is I don't know and neither do you. Certainly wasn't in Adolescence which the government appears to have based all its policy on.

(06-08-2026, 08:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: To be exact Jacko what you have said is that there is no need to restrict internet and social media access because all it takes is "Parental responsibility, education and age gates are all that is required imo."

Now taking into account I have shown where it has been proven that social media was directly linked to the suicides of 128 teenagers, your statement directly points towards a lack of parental responsibility, education or age gates in all of these cases. That will be a kick in the teeth to those parents, who I wold suggest that in the majority of cases, felt that they had done exactly that.

What the Cambridge study actually says is that suicide-related online experience was reported in 24% (128/544) of suicide deaths in young people, and the authors explicitly stated that "its causal role is unclear." This debunks your claim entirely B1 but there are far more issues with the study.

The researchers use the term antecedent, something that preceded the death, not cause. An antecedent can be completely incidental. This study is designed such that it cannot establish causation.

The scope of the study was not 'social media'. It examined "suicide-related online experience", this includes searches for methods, posting suicidal ideas, and online bullying. It was noted by the authors that this was "not limited to social media." Imo, subsuming the entire internet into "social media" is a crude distortion of what was measured.

Then the elephant in the study (room): it seems obvious that already suicidal children or young people, searched online because of their suicidal ideation and not the other way around. The study found that those with suicide-related online experience were already more likely to have a history of self-harm, bereavement by suicide, social isolation, and pre-existing mental and physical health conditions, the profiling here csn only suggest deep pre-existing vulnerability, as opposed to a population harmed by the internet.

Now for the statistical issue, firstly there is no control group, suicidal teens, that didn’t go online (yeah I know, but a study is a study); secondly, the 544 are limiting, drawn from cases with police involvement and coroners reports.

Another major issue, again brought up by the researchers, many young people posting suicidal ideations or thoughts online are reaching out for help. Unhindered access to the Internet can provide reduced social isolation, crisis support or just someone to talk to.

Your misreading of this study is a classic case of correlation does not equal causation. Not least because the authors have said it doesn't.

What I will say is that I believe you have said that off the cuff to win a point (on the internet against a stranger btw) when I don't actually believe anyone thinks that.

I haven't, I'm very rarely point scoring when I believe a policy is inherently wrong.

Your statement that because you are a parent who would be able to have the right controls and education in place does not take into account how insidious the social media world is. This is the 1st government that has taken any real steps to do something about a problem that we are building up for our children and future generations and any intervention now is a good thing, and not Orwellian by any means (another throw away comment I believe you made to win a point again).

The Online Safety Act has been a complete failure, why do you think doubling down is the way to go? Aside from Keir said...

You can already see the impact on late teens / early twenties age adults in the way a number interact with the world. It is damaging on a wider scale than you appear to want to face up to, and as a Dad and Grandad I am pleased that someone is taking action now. You as a Dad should also be pleased that someone is looking at this with a view to making recommendations, as opposed to the wording being used that the outcomes will lead to Orwellian levels of control.

Is it any worse than the gangs of Mods, Skinheads, Casuals and Suedeheads that went about beating the shit out of each other back in the day?

Be clear I'm talking about an outright ban for under 16s when I draw Orwellian parallels, I think those are fair?

Keir to a 14 year old: ey up lad, you can vote in 2 years.

14 year old: cool, can I access the news in a contested information envrionment to decide who to vote for in the meantime?

Keir: fuck no.

Re. The BBC article, 6 fictional profiles is anecdotal, no conclusions re entire platforms can be drawn from such a small sample size.

Fake profiles are not comparable with real users. They are highly unlikely to replicate real behaviour and as such are unable to replicate the algorithm of a real teenager.

They make a mess of the gender split by using different platforms, which means the outcomes could be platform-driven rather than gender-driven, in spite of this obvious anomaly the article implies gender based vulnerability which cannot be qualified in any meaningful way given the method.

As far as I can see they complain about the volume of harmful content on Maya's without ever telling us the proportion, this means it's meaningless in context.

The irony of the whole thing is that both Motherwell and Wright point to parents taking more responsibility (awkward I know).

Lastly in this section, the executive summary. FFS Sake. I read tons of these with work and they're invariably shite, so I apologise, I've asked Claude, the most liberal AI I know, for a summary: This is not a policy recommendation. It is a research quality assessment that asks: do we have good enough evidence to make causal claims about social media and children's mental health at a population level? Its answer is, broadly, no.

Some further links for your consideration on the subject:

Mental Health Foundation report on threats to young people’s health: https://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/about-us...tal-health

Short answer this document/report recommends better education (who said that? Look up).

Details: Savanta have surveyed 16-21 year olds, not the demo we're discussing, no one that any restrictions will affect. Come on B1?

More people, 76%, feel connected by being in online communities than have experienced harmful content, 68%. 63% feel more confident or supported by online communities. This is buried beneath the harm stats.

Again, the recommended solution is better education. 

Clinical Partners report on Impact on young people’s mental health: https://www.clinical-partners.co.uk/arti...al-health/

The recommended solutions in this report are entirely parental. Did you read this B1?  Wink

A US report on linkage between the increase in Teenage suicide and social media: https://www.consumernotice.org/personal-...tatistics/

Have you researched this website? It's the online equivalent of an ambulance chaser!! It's primary function is to connect people with lawyers for personal injury lawsuits. It has active pages for social media harm lawsuits. The statistics page solely exists to build the case for litigation.

Did you just Google 'is the internet bad for kids?' Most of these links support my argument.  Huh

There’s lots of evidence out there Jacko that social media needs much better guardrails put in place and if the companies won’t put those in place and start to take responsibility then there is a case for banning under 16s from that use entirely. Social media companies have the algorithms in place to recognise that I will be talking about getting a new lawnmower and send 100s of adverts to my reels, so they have the technology to identify and control the material that children and teenagers are accessing.

Re the algorithms, I'm not sure if you understand how they work? Search for a lawnmower, get ads for a lawnmower is a straightforward, simple pattern recognition commercial/buying behaviour. Making the same judgement about what is or isn't harmful would be a subjective assumption about what is or isn't 
going to have a psychological impact on an individual.

Look we clearly disagree, most of your links also disagree with you, and I'm not saying we shouldn't throw it to the companies themselves to clean up their acts if it's feasible, but the case for an outright ban is nil. It would harm more kids than it helped. Depriving children of access to the very places where identity, social life and community exists in this day and age is a cruelty. 

It would be like demolishing a library because someone graffitied the wall.

I've tried to be polite, there is a point above you made that you had proven something (re the 128 suicides), this wasn't the case and previously another poster (who tbf is a bit of a biff), went in on me over similar. I appreciate these threads get heated given you're a rabid leftie  Wink and I'm a far right Dingles fan (according to the bored's useful idiot CF). But just know, I hope the length and content of this post despite disagreeing with you almost entirely shows I'm neither point scoring or on the wind-up, which you regularly accuse me of when we don't see eye to eye. Yamas B1.
Reply
#65
Thanks for all that Jacko. My initial thoughts on the commentary is that there appears to be a need in, at least the initial part of the response for you to start from what you want the answer to be and then shoehorn your response to fit that point. You are not looking at this from a viewpoint of being balanced you are choosing to ignore, IMO, key points in the report.

However, having said that, I have taken a look at some further data here: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales and can see that suicide rates in all age group categories between 2001 and 2023 have remained proportionately the same. This supports your point that the internet, albeit likely to be partially responsible and difficult to say with certainty that was or wasn’t a direct cause, has not led to an increase in the overall numbers. Thanks for making me think and do some more work.

I still don’t believe that we are living in an Orwellian state in any shape or form, and I do believe that the darker side of Social Media needs much better control from the companies themselves, something I believe that we both agree on. I also don’t believe that we will follow the Australia model and I’m not certain there is anything to support that conclusion that it will occur. The only commentary comes from reporters asking the perennial headline grabbing question of “Will you rule out x, y, z” before any report comes out in a way of getting a ‘scoop’ on any info, and then the PM of the day will say something along the lines of ‘I’m not ruling anything out, wait for the report’ to which the headline will rile out “PM will not rule out bringing ‘insert extreme comment here’.

Enjoy the rest of your holiday and I hope the missus didn’t give you too much grief when you explained to her that she needed to put her knicker’s back on because you were proving a stranger on the internet wrong. Wink
Reply
#66
If anybody thinks having access to Musks Twitter, or some of the ‘influencers’ across social media platforms shouldn’t be restricted to adults does not have their kids best interests at heart, whether they realise it or not.
Reply
#67
And as much as I agree with that Dekka, Jacko is right with his burning down the library because of some graffiti analogy. I would be looking to get restrictions put in place although there will always be work arounds.
Reply
#68
(06-11-2026, 10:09 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And as much as I agree with that Dekka, Jacko is right with his burning down the library because of some graffiti analogy. I would be looking to get restrictions put in place although there will always be work arounds.

But we aren’t talking about a total media lockdown, we are looking at restricting content inappropriate for young people. You only have to see the damage SM is causing to grown adults to realise a Wild West approach to the internet is damaging society.
Reply
#69
I think that part is what everyone is agreeing with
Reply
#70
Regarding Jacko's point on algorithms, advertising algorithms are different to social media content algorithms. The latter is designed to be addictive, I would say we can easily get around this by making it opt-in like we do with cookies and trackers for social media sites and default to chronological otherwise. It is a serious issue, not just for under-16s but everyone.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)