Ben Stokes
#21
(06-09-2026, 10:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 10:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 09:47 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: In isolation, this would be a nothing story.

However, given previous indiscretions and the obvious strict curfew in place, it's absolutely a dereliction of duty for the captain to still be out at a club and enabling this behaviour in other team members, regardless of whether hew as drunk or not.

It all points to an complete absence of discipline, which seeps into things like training and practising etc. Not good enough.

This is what my above rant should have been. A lot more concise and less angry. 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that feels like this. If it was a once off incident, you could brush it off as 'one of those things', move on and learn, you could excuse it, 'they've just finished a match, it's fair enough to let their hair down'. 

However, it's not a one off. When you look at the bigger picture, how the team conduct themselves in the lead up to series, with the lack of preparation, and the general laissez-faire approach to our play, then it all adds up to a general culture that isn't right, there's a distinct lack of discipline and leadership, and the mentality is not right. It's not acceptable.

No, you rant is also very correct and needed.

This is in the main reason why I was amazed Key and McCullum were allowed to retain their positions. As you point out, this current attitude comes from the top and it simply won't change until those two are removed from position.

I was previously of the opinion that Stokes would be able to continue under different leadership, but I think this event points to the opposite. As you said, he doesn't really warrant selection as a batter any more, and as 4th choice seamer he isn't exactly providing much beyond captaincy.

I was staggered after the Ashes debacle that it was deemed to be all Zak Crawley’s fault as he was the
Only one who lost his position this latest incident now throws it back up to the top level people
McCullum Key & Stokes with all be under pressure to go now.
Ironically it seems a silly little argument in a nightclub will now decide what happens.
Reply
#22
From a MCC member ... Word is that Stokes plans to retire from International cricket. Not sure the IPL will want him mind!

If this happens now then English cricket will lose their best captain and be left a whole lot of nothing to take his place at the helm.
Reply
#23
(06-09-2026, 06:42 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: From a MCC member ... Word is that Stokes plans to retire from International cricket. Not sure the IPL will want him mind!

If this happens now then English cricket will lose their best captain and be left a whole lot of nothing to take his place at the helm.

The problem is the captaincy extends beyond the field. Allowing this incident to happen is terrible leadership and captaincy.

I agree that there would be a gaping hole left at captain if he does retire. It seems like it would be Harry Brook and I just don't see him as captain material. But there really isn't anyone else yet.
Reply
#24
(06-09-2026, 06:42 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: From a MCC member ... Word is that Stokes plans to retire from International cricket. Not sure the IPL will want him mind!

If this happens now then English cricket will lose their best captain and be left a whole lot of nothing to take his place at the helm.

I'm not sure he's England's "best captain". Brearley, Vaughan and Strauss in recent times have shown much more grasp of the essentials. What he's been is inspirational, but that wave has passed by. Much of his captaincy in the Ashes was unimaginative.

Don't forget that he followed on from two of the dullest captains (Cook and Root) who had the enormous benefit of Anderson and Broad to keep the ship sailing. Of course he livened things up and he will be remembered as the England skipper with the best stats.

The fact that there's a vacuum is probably inevitable in view of the cliquey closed shop of the England squad. Brook will be the same type of captain as Cook and Root, no new ideas, no respect shown by the squad, no discipline. Unfortunately he won't have Anderson and Broad to win matches for him.
Reply
#25
Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#26
(06-09-2026, 11:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer

To make it clear I meant the best captain CURRENTLY WITHIN THE SQUAD. Please let me know who is better within the current set up.

Take a week off!

As for franchise cricket, to earn millions then he would need to play in the IPL, and I am not so sure there would be many takers given his lacklustre performances and he may have to settle for thousands. But his name will carry some weight. Just not as much as those at the top of their game.
Reply
#27
(06-10-2026, 06:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 11:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer

To make it clear I meant the best captain CURRENTLY WITHIN THE SQUAD. Please let me know who is better within the current set up.

Take a week off!

As for franchise cricket, to earn millions then he would need to play in the IPL, and I am not so sure there would be many takers given his lacklustre performances and he may have to settle for thousands. But his name will carry some weight. Just not as much as those at the top of their game.

Been a while since we've had a Cuzer and RS spat.

*grabs popcorn*
Reply
#28
(06-10-2026, 07:10 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-10-2026, 06:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 11:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer

To make it clear I meant the best captain CURRENTLY WITHIN THE SQUAD. Please let me know who is better within the current set up.

Take a week off!

As for franchise cricket, to earn millions then he would need to play in the IPL, and I am not so sure there would be many takers given his lacklustre performances and he may have to settle for thousands. But his name will carry some weight. Just not as much as those at the top of their game.

Been a while since we've had a Cuzer and RS spat.

*grabs popcorn*

Spat is a bit over the top AB! This is a mere ripple in a glass of warm milk.   Big Grin
Reply
#29
(06-10-2026, 07:44 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-10-2026, 07:10 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-10-2026, 06:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 11:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer

To make it clear I meant the best captain CURRENTLY WITHIN THE SQUAD. Please let me know who is better within the current set up.

Take a week off!

As for franchise cricket, to earn millions then he would need to play in the IPL, and I am not so sure there would be many takers given his lacklustre performances and he may have to settle for thousands. But his name will carry some weight. Just not as much as those at the top of their game.

Been a while since we've had a Cuzer and RS spat.

*grabs popcorn*

Spat is a bit over the top AB! This is a mere ripple in a glass of warm milk.   Big Grin

I'm just assuming (hoping Big Grin) it's going to devolve into both of you putting a curse on each others houses Big Grin
Reply
#30
(06-10-2026, 07:44 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-10-2026, 07:10 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-10-2026, 06:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 11:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Englands Best captain? Loffin” Have a day off

He could play franchise cricket for the next two years and earn millions doing so, all over the world including the IPL, in such a media hyped tournament names sell and he’s a name

If he resigns it’s down to embarrassment and sheer unprofessionalism

He’s fucked right up just by being out, the rugby llad was the pissed up clown and instigated the trouble but bottom line is given the post Ashes debacle, few beers and to bed gents, simple

Cuzer

To make it clear I meant the best captain CURRENTLY WITHIN THE SQUAD. Please let me know who is better within the current set up.

Take a week off!

As for franchise cricket, to earn millions then he would need to play in the IPL, and I am not so sure there would be many takers given his lacklustre performances and he may have to settle for thousands. But his name will carry some weight. Just not as much as those at the top of their game.

Been a while since we've had a Cuzer and RS spat.

*grabs popcorn*

Spat is a bit over the top AB! This is a mere ripple in a glass of warm milk.   Big Grin

Pissing in his milk is a bit extreme tbf  Big Grin .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)