Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
06-03-2026, 07:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026, 07:39 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Two years ago all the ‘experts’ on here said we didn’t need to or shouldn’t bother trying to find new income streams… they also said data driven approach to recruiting was brilliant too.
As a club and fanbase we are incredibly conservative with a small c, and it does us no favours.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(06-03-2026, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two years ago all the ‘experts’ on here said we didn’t need to or shouldn’t bother trying to find new income streams… they also said data driven approach to recruiting was brilliant too.
As a club and fanbase we are incredibly conservative with a small c, and it does us no favours.
I don't recall a single person saying finding new income streams was a bad idea.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-03-2026, 08:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: (06-03-2026, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two years ago all the ‘experts’ on here said we didn’t need to or shouldn’t bother trying to find new income streams… they also said data driven approach to recruiting was brilliant too.
As a club and fanbase we are incredibly conservative with a small c, and it does us no favours.
I don't recall a single person saying finding new income streams was a bad idea.
When I said we needed to look beyond a few stalls on match day on Greggs carpark and some ABBA tribute acts in the summer I was told we should concentrate on ticket sales and flogging our best young players, every season. That should be the model apparently… it’s not sustainable if you want success these days.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
06-03-2026, 09:43 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026, 09:44 PM by Squid.)
(06-03-2026, 09:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-03-2026, 08:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: (06-03-2026, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two years ago all the ‘experts’ on here said we didn’t need to or shouldn’t bother trying to find new income streams… they also said data driven approach to recruiting was brilliant too.
As a club and fanbase we are incredibly conservative with a small c, and it does us no favours.
I don't recall a single person saying finding new income streams was a bad idea.
When I said we needed to look beyond a few stalls on match day on Greggs carpark and some ABBA tribute acts in the summer I was told we should concentrate on ticket sales and flogging our best young players, every season. That should be the model apparently… it’s not sustainable if you want success these days.
The majority of sensible people said that we needed to both increase our match day income stream AND improve our transfer business, particularly in terms of turning a profit on player sales, because we have been absolutely diabolical at the latter, particularly compared to other Championship clubs. And yes, those other clubs do seem to use data effectively as a tool, is it so wrong to suggest that we should do the same?
Your usual response is to just hark back to the days of Gary Megson's Dad, but sadly he is no longer available. The fact is, our scouting networks were never properly replaced following Dashworth going and have instead been operated on the whims of our revolving list of managers and chancers like Nick Hammond and Luke Downing.
Nestor made mistakes, but his remit was to bring down the age of the squad and keep us within PSR. Where he truly messed up was with his managerial appointments after Corberán. That's what cost him his job, as a decent manager would have delivered the mid table finish we were all expecting last season.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-03-2026, 09:43 PM)Squid Wrote: (06-03-2026, 09:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-03-2026, 08:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: (06-03-2026, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two years ago all the ‘experts’ on here said we didn’t need to or shouldn’t bother trying to find new income streams… they also said data driven approach to recruiting was brilliant too.
As a club and fanbase we are incredibly conservative with a small c, and it does us no favours.
I don't recall a single person saying finding new income streams was a bad idea.
When I said we needed to look beyond a few stalls on match day on Greggs carpark and some ABBA tribute acts in the summer I was told we should concentrate on ticket sales and flogging our best young players, every season. That should be the model apparently… it’s not sustainable if you want success these days.
The majority of sensible people said that we needed to both increase our match day income stream AND improve our transfer business, particularly in terms of turning a profit on player sales, because we have been absolutely diabolical at the latter, particularly compared to other Championship clubs. And yes, those other clubs do seem to use data effectively as a tool, is it so wrong to suggest that we should do the same?
Your usual response is to just hark back to the days of Gary Megson's Dad, but sadly he is no longer available. The fact is, our scouting networks were never properly replaced following Dashworth going and have instead been operated on the whims of our revolving list of managers and chancers like Nick Hammond and Luke Downing.
Nestor made mistakes, but his remit was to bring down the age of the squad and keep us within PSR. Where he truly messed up was with his managerial appointments after Corberán. That's what cost him his job, as a decent manager would have delivered the mid table finish we were all expecting last season.
I never said don’t use data, I said it needs to be seen as a tool, not the only metric to judge a player on. The club have already said that they relied too heavily on data last season and they will be taking a more nuanced approach this season.
I don’t know what data was used to bring in Mason or Ramsay, as there wasn’t any to go by at Championship level.
I agree our scouting network/recruitment has been aots since Ashworth left. However even then I don’t think it was as great as has been suggested.
Revenue from player sales alone or without investment by the owners, and other revenue streams won’t get us past midtable at best.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Name names of who said not increasing the non-football income stream was the way to go? I still believe the Halfords should be redeveloped ASAP , the players car park should go for one and build an inside 2-3 storey bar & food place akin to the the bar at Ashton Gate. There only needs to be ine gate for the East Stand Car park, move the Asle Gates across and build out the old Woodman Corner for this. When I've been to Bristol's for match day it's pretty full by 12ish with beer and food being sold aplenty. Post match too with screens.
People talk about it can't just be match day revenue - the rest of the week needs to be filled too. We don't even maximise match day, people arrive last minute as there's nothing to get there for and leave 5 minutes before the end to get away! That's the culture inbedded in our fanbase that's been allowed to grow and it will take quite a while to change fans habits to get there earlier or to stay later. It won't just happen overnight just because there'd be somewhere to go. We had fans arriving early in the past - there was the clubhouse and other pubs around the ground, that culture of being early was allowed to die off and needs time to be rebuilt.
As for scouting we had a great spell with recruitment: Olsson, McAuley, Billy Jones, Mulumby, Dorrans, Yacob, Jara, PIG, Brunt, Mozza, Odemwingie, Reid, Scharner, Lukaku, McClean (yes, really), MAF, Texeria, Koren, Gera, Phillips and I've probably missed numerous off.
I doubt many teams get more than 1 in 2 right, especially when you're picking up unknowns and potentials. There have been a number of "Ok" signings too, they've not all been a disaster. It went truly wrong in the AFI summer and then Pulis just wanted to sign experienced English based players which left us with an ageing group on high wages with little resale value.
I'd say Nestor hasn't done too bad with recuiting playing staff - Imray, Campbell, Heggem, Phillips, MOL, Heggebo, Diakite, Styles, Price, Adam Armstrong, Mikey and arguably a few others did a reasonable job as cover. Where it's gone really wrong is the manager and particularly the loans - not sure who's in charge of loan signings.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(06-04-2026, 11:37 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Name names of who said not increasing the non-football income stream was the way to go? I still believe the Halfords should be redeveloped ASAP , the players car park should go for one and build an inside 2-3 storey bar & food place akin to the the bar at Ashton Gate. There only needs to be ine gate for the East Stand Car park, move the Asle Gates across and build out the old Woodman Corner for this. When I've been to Bristol's for match day it's pretty full by 12ish with beer and food being sold aplenty. Post match too with screens.
People talk about it can't just be match day revenue - the rest of the week needs to be filled too. We don't even maximise match day, people arrive last minute as there's nothing to get there for and leave 5 minutes before the end to get away! That's the culture inbedded in our fanbase that's been allowed to grow and it will take quite a while to change fans habits to get there earlier or to stay later. It won't just happen overnight just because there'd be somewhere to go. We had fans arriving early in the past - there was the clubhouse and other pubs around the ground, that culture of being early was allowed to die off and needs time to be rebuilt.
As for scouting we had a great spell with recruitment: Olsson, McAuley, Billy Jones, Mulumby, Dorrans, Yacob, Jara, PIG, Brunt, Mozza, Odemwingie, Reid, Scharner, Lukaku, McClean (yes, really), MAF, Texeria, Koren, Gera, Phillips and I've probably missed numerous off.
I doubt many teams get more than 1 in 2 right, especially when you're picking up unknowns and potentials. There have been a number of "Ok" signings too, they've not all been a disaster. It went truly wrong in the AFI summer and then Pulis just wanted to sign experienced English based players which left us with an ageing group on high wages with little resale value.
I'd say Nestor hasn't done too bad with recuiting playing staff - Imray, Campbell, Heggem, Phillips, MOL, Heggebo, Diakite, Styles, Price, Adam Armstrong, Mikey and arguably a few others did a reasonable job as cover. Where it's gone really wrong is the manager and particularly the loans - not sure who's in charge of loan signings.
One thing I thought was great at Brighton when we played them in the Cup was that you had craft ale outlets still open around the ground where you could stop for a few before heading off (understandable given the trains there). It was great to be able to do that and mosey on down to the station when queues had died down. I'm sure enough people would do that at the Hawthorns if the opportunity were there.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(06-04-2026, 11:37 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Name names of who said not increasing the non-football income stream was the way to go? I still believe the Halfords should be redeveloped ASAP , the players car park should go for one and build an inside 2-3 storey bar & food place akin to the the bar at Ashton Gate. There only needs to be ine gate for the East Stand Car park, move the Asle Gates across and build out the old Woodman Corner for this. When I've been to Bristol's for match day it's pretty full by 12ish with beer and food being sold aplenty. Post match too with screens.
People talk about it can't just be match day revenue - the rest of the week needs to be filled too. We don't even maximise match day, people arrive last minute as there's nothing to get there for and leave 5 minutes before the end to get away! That's the culture inbedded in our fanbase that's been allowed to grow and it will take quite a while to change fans habits to get there earlier or to stay later. It won't just happen overnight just because there'd be somewhere to go. We had fans arriving early in the past - there was the clubhouse and other pubs around the ground, that culture of being early was allowed to die off and needs time to be rebuilt.
As for scouting we had a great spell with recruitment: Olsson, McAuley, Billy Jones, Mulumby, Dorrans, Yacob, Jara, PIG, Brunt, Mozza, Odemwingie, Reid, Scharner, Lukaku, McClean (yes, really), MAF, Texeria, Koren, Gera, Phillips and I've probably missed numerous off.
I doubt many teams get more than 1 in 2 right, especially when you're picking up unknowns and potentials. There have been a number of "Ok" signings too, they've not all been a disaster. It went truly wrong in the AFI summer and then Pulis just wanted to sign experienced English based players which left us with an ageing group on high wages with little resale value.
I'd say Nestor hasn't done too bad with recuiting playing staff - Imray, Campbell, Heggem, Phillips, MOL, Heggebo, Diakite, Styles, Price, Adam Armstrong, Mikey and arguably a few others did a reasonable job as cover. Where it's gone really wrong is the manager and particularly the loans - not sure who's in charge of loan signings.
Good post, mon. It could be done as long as there's some cover and some comfort, or I wouldn't see too many choosing to stay in a bleak, dark, windswept uncovered market style yard over winter games.
Posts: 7,718
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(06-04-2026, 11:37 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Name names of who said not increasing the non-football income stream was the way to go? I still believe the Halfords should be redeveloped ASAP , the players car park should go for one and build an inside 2-3 storey bar & food place akin to the the bar at Ashton Gate. There only needs to be ine gate for the East Stand Car park, move the Asle Gates across and build out the old Woodman Corner for this. When I've been to Bristol's for match day it's pretty full by 12ish with beer and food being sold aplenty. Post match too with screens.
People talk about it can't just be match day revenue - the rest of the week needs to be filled too. We don't even maximise match day, people arrive last minute as there's nothing to get there for and leave 5 minutes before the end to get away! That's the culture inbedded in our fanbase that's been allowed to grow and it will take quite a while to change fans habits to get there earlier or to stay later. It won't just happen overnight just because there'd be somewhere to go. We had fans arriving early in the past - there was the clubhouse and other pubs around the ground, that culture of being early was allowed to die off and needs time to be rebuilt.
As for scouting we had a great spell with recruitment: Olsson, McAuley, Billy Jones, Mulumby, Dorrans, Yacob, Jara, PIG, Brunt, Mozza, Odemwingie, Reid, Scharner, Lukaku, McClean (yes, really), MAF, Texeria, Koren, Gera, Phillips and I've probably missed numerous off.
I doubt many teams get more than 1 in 2 right, especially when you're picking up unknowns and potentials. There have been a number of "Ok" signings too, they've not all been a disaster. It went truly wrong in the AFI summer and then Pulis just wanted to sign experienced English based players which left us with an ageing group on high wages with little resale value.
I'd say Nestor hasn't done too bad with recuiting playing staff - Imray, Campbell, Heggem, Phillips, MOL, Heggebo, Diakite, Styles, Price, Adam Armstrong, Mikey and arguably a few others did a reasonable job as cover. Where it's gone really wrong is the manager and particularly the loans - not sure who's in charge of loan signings.
There won't be any names. Only further questions. Yours, Dekka.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-04-2026, 05:11 PM)Jacko Wrote: (06-04-2026, 11:37 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Name names of who said not increasing the non-football income stream was the way to go? I still believe the Halfords should be redeveloped ASAP , the players car park should go for one and build an inside 2-3 storey bar & food place akin to the the bar at Ashton Gate. There only needs to be ine gate for the East Stand Car park, move the Asle Gates across and build out the old Woodman Corner for this. When I've been to Bristol's for match day it's pretty full by 12ish with beer and food being sold aplenty. Post match too with screens.
People talk about it can't just be match day revenue - the rest of the week needs to be filled too. We don't even maximise match day, people arrive last minute as there's nothing to get there for and leave 5 minutes before the end to get away! That's the culture inbedded in our fanbase that's been allowed to grow and it will take quite a while to change fans habits to get there earlier or to stay later. It won't just happen overnight just because there'd be somewhere to go. We had fans arriving early in the past - there was the clubhouse and other pubs around the ground, that culture of being early was allowed to die off and needs time to be rebuilt.
As for scouting we had a great spell with recruitment: Olsson, McAuley, Billy Jones, Mulumby, Dorrans, Yacob, Jara, PIG, Brunt, Mozza, Odemwingie, Reid, Scharner, Lukaku, McClean (yes, really), MAF, Texeria, Koren, Gera, Phillips and I've probably missed numerous off.
I doubt many teams get more than 1 in 2 right, especially when you're picking up unknowns and potentials. There have been a number of "Ok" signings too, they've not all been a disaster. It went truly wrong in the AFI summer and then Pulis just wanted to sign experienced English based players which left us with an ageing group on high wages with little resale value.
I'd say Nestor hasn't done too bad with recuiting playing staff - Imray, Campbell, Heggem, Phillips, MOL, Heggebo, Diakite, Styles, Price, Adam Armstrong, Mikey and arguably a few others did a reasonable job as cover. Where it's gone really wrong is the manager and particularly the loans - not sure who's in charge of loan signings.
There won't be any names. Only further questions. Yours, Dekka.
You can AI previous threads dear.
|